The Best of the Nostalgia Critic
"Hello, I'm the Nostalgia Critic. I rember it so you don't have to."
This is a tribute to his greatest episode performances.
This is a tribute to his greatest episode performances.
List activity
5K views
• 0 this weekCreate a new list
List your movie, TV & celebrity picks.
93 titles
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Nostalgia Critic reviews Gordy (1994) of which is similar to Babe (1995).
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerChad RoccoPaul SchulerThe Critic counts down his top 11 favorite moments from the 90's Batman animated series.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerFollowing his Let's Play of Bart's Nightmare, The Nostalgia Critic has come under scrutiny from his "adoring" fans who have had him incarcerated in an Internet state penitentiary. In attempt to regain his fan base, The Critic agrees to do a positive review for "James and the Giant Peach", despite actually disliking the film, and is held at gun point under the threat of being shot if he dares point out any flaws. He goes on to ridicule the song lyrics, the questionable disappearance of James' parents via a wild rhino, and many other story elements that are never really addressed.Overall, he feels it isn't the worst film he's ever seen and deems it acceptable.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe critic does his first top 11 list.
- 2007– 22mTV-MA7.5 (74)TV EpisodeDirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug Walker
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerRob WalkerThe Critic is horrified to learn about the existence of another animated Titanic film, which is The Legend of the Titanic (1999), and finds it to be even worse than Titanic: The Legend Goes On... (2000).
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Critic reviews Titanic: The Legend Goes On, an Italian-animated movie that not only rips off James Cameron's movie and every animated movie ever made, it also includes the horrors of the Rapping Dog.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerYup, the Critic has given in and will be reviewing The Care Bears Movie. He finds it to be the insipid, ball of multi-colored fluff its reputation paints it to be.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerContinuing the month of Nostalgia-ween, where everything is supposed to be scary, the Critic counts down the top 11 scariest performances and characters that can still send shivers down our spines.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerRobert EnglundThe Nostalgia Critic reviews the 1989 animated cult film; Little Nemo.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerCyriak HarrisThe Critic looks back at some of the weird stuff our childhood entertainment subjected us to.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerChester A. Bum takes the Critic to court after he accuses the Critic of ripping off his review of the latest Transformers film: "Dark of the Moon."
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerMichael Crawford as a badger? Oh this has GOT to be an instant classic. The NC reviews 1993's Once Upon a Forest.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Critic knows that the bad guy always gets the coolest musical number, and these are his favorites.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Critic counts down the most badass villains the Mouse House ever gave us.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe critic despite not having any knowledge of the franchise he reviews Pokémon the first movie.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerBennett WhiteRob WalkerThe Nostalgia Critic reviews 1986's Care Bears movie - A New Generation.
- 2007– 14mTV-MA7.3 (100)TV EpisodeDirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Critic lists the movie and television scenes that still make him cry.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Critic has finally found a movie with no redeeming value whatsoever: The Garbage Pail Kids Movie.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerRob WalkerJohn Moschitta Jr.Still reeling from the bashing he received at the hands of the director of "My Pet Monster," a depressed Critic decides to take a break from reviewing movies and instead reviews old nostalgic commercials.
- 2007– 29mTV-MA8.7 (124)TV EpisodeDirectorDoug WalkerStarsJeff BridgesJeff GoldblumDennis HopperIt's another trip down memory lane as the Critic reviews more nostalgic commercials where he takes aim at 1-900 hotline numbers and sees some inappropriately-named products.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerRob WalkerJay ChapmanThe Critic reviews a third batch of nostalgic commercials that includes a risqué Ghostbusters toy commercial and we also find out whatever became of Zack, the self-proclaimed Lego Maniac.
- 2007– 21mTV-MA7.6 (73)TV EpisodeDirectorDoug WalkerStarsYul BrynnerCharlton HestonDoug WalkerIt's an Old vs. New battle of biblical proportions as the Critic compares the legendary Cecil B. DeMille epic "The Ten Commandments" with the animated musical "The Prince of Egypt," right down to who's the best God.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerWith the recent remake out on DVD, see which film holds up as the better Western.
- 2007– 14mTV-MA7.3 (114)TV EpisodeDirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Critic compares two of his favorite movies: Tim Burton's Batman, and Christopher Nolan's The Dark Knight.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerRob WalkerBhargav DronamrajuIn his first review of "Nostalgia-ween", the Nostalgia Critic takes a look at the last Ernest movie released in theaters titled "Ernest Scared Stupid" which is really stupid.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Critic checks out the worst thing to happen to Alaska since Sarah Palin: the movie, Alaska. The film's mean-spiritedness turns the Critic off as he doesn't gravitate toward the characters or the situation. He feels the movie takes place in Hell after it froze over.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerRob WalkerThis week, the Critic has to deal with the overly-schmaltzy, overly-whimsical Troll in Central Park, the ultimate low-point in Don Bluth's career.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerLindsay EllisIn the second review for "Sequel Month", The Nostalgia Critic tries to re-unite with The Nostalgia Chick to review the direct-to-video sequel. She refuses and so he must go it alone finding out that it is actually worse than the first film.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerMark KauslerJerry BeckA longtime Tom and Jerry fan, the Critic is devastated to hear the cat and mouse not only talk, but sing, dance, and get along.
- 2007– 18mTV-MA7.8 (141)TV EpisodeDirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerMalcolm McDowellJaleel WhiteThe Critic reviews the two cartoons based on the Sonic series, each of which gets a very different reaction out of him.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Nostalgia Critic reviews 1987's Jaws 4-The Revenge.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Critic counts down the sexiest animated women.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerRob WalkerThe Critic reviews the worst Batman movie ever made, becomes particularly outraged at the Bat-Credit Card, and concludes with a rousing musical number.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Critic remembers the illogical Super Mario cartoon, including the obnoxious Zelda segment.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Critic reviews the 1993 live-action adaptation of Super Mario Bros. He feels that it does the game, as well as movies in general, a grave injustice.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Critic attacks "Kazaam", for its implications of slavery, pedophilia, and Shaq's horrible acting and rapping.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Critic teaches a class on "Bland Shit 101", using Disney's Blank Check as the curriculum.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerElisa HansenAntonella InserraIs life still like a hurricane? The Nostalgia Critic checks out the first few episodes of the Duck Tales cartoon.
- 2007– 8mTV-MA7.7 (127)TV EpisodeDirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerIn this two-part episode, the Critic reviews two of the most popular fighting games that became really bad movies. First up: Street Fighter, a movie saved only by the performance of the late Raul Julia as M. Bison.
- 2007– 8mTV-MA7.6 (132)TV EpisodeDirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerIn the conclusion of this 2-part episode, the Critic reviews the other bad movie based on a popular fighting game: Mortal Kombat, a movie weighed down by Johnny Cage's bad quips.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Critic reviews George Lucas' notorious Marvel Comics adaptation.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerKirsten DunstMargot KidderThe Critic examines the worst examples of those with too few positive characteristics to counter (but negative ones to heighten) the basic fact that they ultimately exist to be bailed out of trouble - over and over...
- 2007– 17mTV-MA7.7 (100)TV EpisodeDirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Critic remembers some movies so we don't have to... but maybe we want to remember these ones.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerAlyssa MilanoThe Critic reviews the Double Dragon movie, which makes a lot less sense than the plot of the game.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Critic looks at the decline of Burt Reynolds' movie career, and how starring in a family action buddy-cop comedy opposite a little boy did not help it in the slightest.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Critic looks at the cinematic manifestation of Michael Jackson's ego, and finds it all stupid...except for the awesome Smooth Criminal music video.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Critic does another positive review, this time of Disney's Gargoyles animated series.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Critic reviews yet another Nintendo cash-in, the animated series about a boy who meets a bunch of characters who barely resemble the games they're based on.
- 2007– 20mTV-MA7.8 (107)TV EpisodeDirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Critic compares Ralph Bakshi and Peter Jackson's adaptations of JRR Tolkien's classic.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Critic reviews one of the movie adaptations of Captain America and introduces the concept of the "Psyche-Hitler".
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Critic reviews another horrible comic book movie and notes how many starving children could have been saved with the film's budget.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Critic looks at one of his favorite guilty pleasures, Judge Dredd.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Critic looks at a stupid Michael Crichton adaptation that is only salvaged by the brief appearances of Bruce Campbell and Ernie Hudson.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerClaire BishopTired of being the "friendly" ghost, Casper decides to haunt the Critic on Halloween by subjecting him to his first live-action feature...but the Critic is ready to fight back.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerRaoul Puke, father of Fozzie Journalism, sits in for the Critic and reviews this drug trip of a movie.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerNoah AntwilerLewis LovhaugThe Critic finally gives in and checks out a film by Uwe Boll, which leaves him quite literally speechless. He takes comfort that he's in no condition to review the movie...but Spoony and Linkara have his back.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerBMX bikers from the 80s? I've heard of worse things to make a movie out of. The Nostalgia Critic reviews 1986's Rad.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Critic loves the Superman movies...well, two of them...but has to admit they have their fair share of stupidity.
- 2007– 27mTV-MA7.6 (115)TV EpisodeDirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug Walkerthe Nostalgia Critic counts down the top 11 dumbest moments in the Spiderman movie trilogy directed by Sam Raimi.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerRob WalkerThe Critic reviews the worst holiday special of all time. The previously unreleased, cult fan-based Star Wars Holiday Special.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerRob WalkerThe Critic wraps up Schwarzenegger Month with End of Days, which isn't as scary as it should be...except for the cat.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerRob WalkerBhargav DronamrajuThe Critic reviews Junior, a comedy so boring he has a hallucinatory dream sequence.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerFor the first installment of 'Sequel Month', the Critic reviews The NeverEnding Story III. Terrible practical effects, a horrible script and even worse acting makes NeverEnding Story II look like the original.
- 2007– 19mTV-MA7.5 (109)TV EpisodeDirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerBhargav DronamrajuThe Critic looks at the sequel to one of his favorite childhood movies.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerAllison PreglerLewis LovhaugThe Critic ignores warnings from his fellow reviewers and reviews notorious actor Tommy Wiseau's "personal project," the disturbing yet entertaining masterpiece known as "The Room."
- 2007– 3mTV-MA7.4 (112)TV EpisodeDirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Critic praises Animaniacs for being written just as much for adults as for children, and cites examples.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Critic gets into the Christmas spirit by reviewing a semi-Christmas movie: that time Rodney Dangerfield was an animated dog. It's one-liners galore.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Critic looks at Hulk Hogan's uninspired sci-fi comedy Suburban Commando, which provides a very quotable line courtesy of Christopher Lloyd: "I was FRO-zen to-day!"
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerBrad JonesThe Cinema Snob joins the Critic as they review a subpar horror movie about a little man in grotesque make-up who is on a blood quest for gold.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerRob WalkerThe Nostalgia Critic reviews the Stephen King mini-series IT.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Nostalgia Critic reviews The Magic Voyage.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Nostalgia Critic reviews the Stephen King Miniseries The Langoliers
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerMichael EllisDouchey McNitpick, the Critic's most annoying fan, points out mistakes from previous episodes.
- 2007– 17mTV-MA8.0 (96)TV EpisodeDirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerBrian HeinzNo critic is perfect and are common to making mistakes in their reviews. It is time once again for the Nostalgia Critic to fess up and admit to his own collection of screw ups in his latest Top 11 list.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Critic's second top 11 list.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerRob WalkerBhargav DronamrajuThe Critic decides to look at one of his favorite actors in one of his least favorite movies.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerLewis LovhaugBenjamin DanielThe Critic looks at the series premiere and finale of Full House, and makes a shocking discovery about the Olsen Twins.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Critic compares adaptations of Roald Dahl's "Charlie and the Chocolate Factory". He may be a bit biased, as he doesn't tend to care for Tim Burton's re-imaginings.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Critic takes an amateurish approach to Let's Plays by reviewing Bart's Nightmare.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Critic's joy at realizing that he is going to review the Avengers movie based on the Marvel Comic superheroes turns to disappointment when he finds out that the Avengers movie is actually the unrelated yet notoriously bad 1998 film.
- 2007– 21mTV-MA7.1 (70)TV EpisodeDirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerDoug Walker steps out of character to discuss 11 films/shows that he has no plans on reviewing as The Nostalgia Critic, mainly because they're not as bad as people think, other reviewers have already tackled them, they're too recent, or he can't make heads nor tails of it.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Critic looks at how a movie meant to inspire reading can be uninteresting by reviewing one that he's completely forgotten.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerBrad JonesWhy do Stephen King Mini-Series bring us so much joy?
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Nostalgia Critic reviews a bad remake of one of his favorite movies, The Haunting. As he reviews it, he picks apart the story, complains about Owen Wilson's character stating the painfully obvious, and he gawks at the incredibly sexy Catherine Zeta Jones.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerWrapping up Nostalgia-Ween with one of the strangest sequels ever. It's time for the Exorcist II - The Heretic.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Critic takes a look at the horrible sequel to the 1999 found-footage smash hit, The Blair Witch Project. He likes the original, but finds the sequel incoherent, horribly acted, badly edited and dreadfully acted.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerNash BozardThe Critic reviews "Doug's 1st Movie," a movie based on a cartoon that tormented him during his youth.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerElisa HansenTake a look at the origins of the hit cartoon.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerJames RolfeBy popular demand from his viewers, the Critic takes on one of the worst animated movies he's ever had to review: "Felix the Cat: The Movie."
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerPhelan PorteousRob WalkerThe Critic and Phelous team up to review an unlikely Christmas movie: The first Child's Play movie.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerJim TrokenAllison PreglerKeanu Reeves and Drew Barrymore? Yay. 1986? Nay.
- DirectorDoug WalkerStarsDoug WalkerThe Critic reviews The Grinch in light of the holiday season, but it's a movie he despises for some reason. Flamboyant, loud, and made to annoy, yet how does it bring the people such joy? In a Seuss-style critique, the Critic prepares to tear into The Grinch, the movie of the week.