Her duet with
Tyler Hilton, a cover of the song "When The Stars Go Blue", originally by
Ryan Adams, is on the first
One Tree Hill (2003) soundtrack album, "One Tree Hill - Music from the WB Television Series. (January 2005) On the album she is credited as "Bethany Joy Lenz", her maiden name, as she was not married at the time of its release. The duet was a part of the storyline of
One Tree Hill (2003) between her character, "Haley James Scott", and
Tyler Hilton's character, "Chris Keller".