Graduated from Junipero Serra High School in San Mateo, California. Other alumni are Tom Brady and Barry Bonds.
Parents are Alfred Gutfeld (1922-1984) and Jackie Gutfeld (1924-2014). Jackie appeared on Red Eye w/Tom Shillue (2007) as FOX News "Senior" Correspondent in the "Messages from Mom" segment.
His father was of German Jewish, German (Catholic), and Irish descent. His mother was of Irish, French, and Mexican ancestry.
Adopted a puppy and named him Jasper, same name as Dana Perino's dog.
Is married, but has no children.
Frequent guests include FOX News anchors such as Laurie Dhue, Harris Faulkner, and Julie Banderas. Guests also include celebrities and famous people in fields outside of entertainment, including former CIA agent Mike Baker.