The Wrecker (1929) Poster

(1929)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Daft but spirited silent British thriller with spectacular train crash sequences
des-474 January 2010
Warning: Spoilers
A totally preposterous but fast-moving and quite enjoyable potboiler that doesn't outstay its welcome, this film also boasts additional interest for its audacious train crash sequences and its status as almost the first British sound film.

It's based on what had been a very successful West End play, co-written by Arnold Ridley, later better known as Dad's Army's Private Godfrey. The characters are all stereotypes of the day: the hero (Joseph Striker) is a good chap, the sort who puts up his fists when some cad threatens him with a firearm, who has retired from being rather good at cricket to help his uncle run a railway, while his plucky girlfriend (Benita Hume) ends up saving the day. There's an annoyingly dense private detective (Leonard Thompson) for comic relief, an oily villain (Carlyle Blackwell, who got star billing) and his moll (Pauline Johnson) who comes good in the end. The villain, the owner of a bus company who also masquerades as a railway general manager, has a cunning plan to promote road transport by organising the wrecking of trains. He should have just waited a few decades for the British government to wreck the railways and then franchise them out to the bus companies.

It's the sort of film where characters turn amateur detective rather than doing the obvious and going to the police, and even a series of horrendous rail disasters and a murder can't shift the impression that this is all a rather jolly jape.

The film claims to feature the most spectacular staged rail crash in British film history, and with some justification. The "money shot" shows a loco hauling a full rake of six coaches down an incline at 65km/h smashing into a steam lorry at Salters Ash level crossing on the since-closed Basingtoke to Alton Light Railway (later the location for the better-known Oh, Mr Porter!). The lorry is simply pulverised; the train jumps from the track and crashes onto its side, belching huge gouts of steam. There's lots of other authentic railway detail if you're interested in that kind of thing: the Southern Railway cooperated with the film makers to provide authentic locations. The railway is brilliantly and innovatively filmed, including one remarkable shot where the camera appears to track sideways from the exterior of a moving train to the interior of the coach.

The soundtrack was never intended to have full dialogue, just sound effects and musical score, with a few snatches from a radio announcer – in fact a plot point revolves around a phonograph recording of the villain instructing a henchman. It's now lost and the current DVD release features a decent new score by veteran silent film accompanist Neil Brand.
8 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Silly comedy thriller but of interest
malcolmgsw2 June 2017
This a comedy thriller but it isn't funny and doesn't thrill.However it is of interest.First of course the train crash which is quite spectacular.Secondly for the views of everyday England in the twenties,not so different from today.Thirdly because the film was made on the cusp of sound.It had a score and we hear the villains voice in an incriminating recording of a telephone conversation.Clearly Gainsborough were trying to make this film acceptable to an audience who wanted nothing but talkies.One of the big problems of a film such as this was the number of interrupted required.It does become rather tiresome.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
One of cinema's most spectacular train crashes
vampire_hounddog30 July 2020
A bus company is sabotaging a train line with the aim of discrediting the rail comapany and taking over the route. After a couple of deadly 'accidents', the managing director Sir Gerald Bartlett (Winter Hall) hires his nephew (Joesph Striker) who was involved in one of the accident's to investigate what is behind the crashes.

Based off a play of the same name by Arnold Ridley (better known as Private Godfrey in DAD's ARMY) and Bernard Merivale, it is very much a companion piece to Ridley's better known play, 'The Ghost Train'. One of the screenwriter's who adapted the play was Angus MacPhail who would go on to be one of the leading screenwriters in the 1930s and 40s in popular British cinema, including the 1931 version of THE GHOST TRAIN.

The film is best known for its spectacularly staged railway crash which was filmed outside Alton on a disused railway line, which would 8 years after this be the location for the Will Hay classic, OH, MR PORTER!, a film that would also draw in elements of Ridley's 'The Ghost Train'. Other than the crash, the film is otherwise undistinguished. THE WRECKER was co-produced by Michael Balcon and Arnold Pressburger and directed by a Hungarian, Géza von Bolváry who made the majority of his films in Germany and Austria, even under Nazism. THE WRECKER would also form the basis of an American B picture, THE PHANTOM EXPRESS (1932).
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Angus MacPhail's Screenwriting Debut
Single-Black-Male23 October 2003
The 25 year old Angus MacPhail made his lucky break in this silent film where he adapted a play for the screen. It was the same sort of thing that Alfred Hitchcock was doing at the time and their paths would eventually meet over a decade later.
2 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed