Five Minutes from the Station (1930) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
10 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Guess who's coming to dinner
jotix10028 November 2006
Warning: Spoilers
Imagine the spot Bert, an office employee, puts his wife Carrie when he announces he is bringing his boss, Mr. Mason, to dinner. That, by itself, would mean a lot of preparations in order to impress the boss. At stake, is a new position in the shipping department, something that Bert would like to be considered. At the height of the Great Depression, this proposition could drive a wife to commit suicide. How is Carrie going to get everything for dinner and make a good impression?

When Bert arrives with Mr. Mason, he introduces him to Carrie. Everything seems to be in order. When they sit to dinner, the only beverage Carrie has is some ginger ale! Mr. Mason proceeds to ask Bert his opinion about who is the best candidate for the job. When he names someone else, Bert tells his boss he has made a wise decision, even though he is hurting inside for being overlooked. Mr. Mason smells something burning, and sure enough, the dinner has been burned! What else could go wrong? Carrie questions Mr. Mason about why has he denied Bert the promotion, as she breaks down feeling their chances escape her husband. It's at this time that Mr. Mason decides to go back to town and he takes a moment to explain to Bert that he has something much better for him because he has taken the right approach and he has put the business needs ahead of his own.

This Vitaphone one reel packs a lot of ideas in a short time. Directed by Arthur Hurley, this short film should be seen by people trying to get ahead in the business world. Of course, times have changed and it's a different environment; no one today could believe in the way Bert reacts, but obviously, the person that really mattered took notice of his sacrifice.

Sylvia Sidney, in one of her earliest appearances, plays Carrie, the wife that dares to question her husband's boss. Lynne Overman is good as Bert, and Berton Churchill is Mr. Mason.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Mostly of historic interest...but not bad
preppy-328 November 2006
Short in which Bert (Lynne Overman) brings his boss (Berton Churchill) home to dinner. It seems there's a big promotion that's going to happen in the company and Bert hopes he gets it. His wife (Sylvia Sidney) wants it too.

Interesting short showing how bad it really was during the Depression. It's made quite clear that the couple barely has enough to eat (Sidney says she had to go from door to door begging for food) so you're rooting for them. Sidney was unknown when this was made but she's great. Churchill is good as the boss. Overman was a little TOO whiny for me.

No great shakes and more historically important than a good drama but worth seeing if it's on. TCM shows this between movies occasionally.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Depressing Vitaphone short about the Great Depression era...
Doylenf20 September 2008
Awkwardly staged short subject has SYLVIA SIDNEY pleading with her husband's boss to give him the promotion he so richly deserves--after a disastrous dinner which goes wrong in every possible way.

While this serves as a reminder of hard times during the Great Depression, it's hardly a memorable short subject. The dialog is as awkward as the staging with none of the actors at their best.

SYLVIA SIDNEY is passable as the distraught wife, a role she would go on to play in countless other films, but she can't save the short from being impossibly dull. LYNNE OVERMAN as her husband is convincing enough but the whole project was doomed from the start with a lifeless script.

Summing up: An early talkie is a depressing look at hard times.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Old short still timely today
miller-416 June 2000
This short film dating from 1930 is still relevant today. The plot of an employee hoping to get a promotion still rings true. The acting is superb, especially by Sylvia Sidney in one of her first film roles. Sidney shows a real assertiveness here as a woman that is unusual for the time as she fights for her husband's quest to move up in the company. Lynne Overman and Berton Churchill are the other two players and they offer good support. This short is a real treat.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
The Scene Changer
boblipton6 November 2019
Lynne Overman calls wife Sylvia Sidney to tell her he's bringing boss Berton Churchill home for dinner.

It was a situation comedy staple for decades and before then, it was undoubtedly used as a 'scene changer', a short skit played in from of closed drapes while the workmen scrambled to change the sets on stage. This one is played seriously. It was shot out at Warner's Vitagraph studio in Brooklyn, an important testing stage for Broadway performers whom the studio was considering for putting under contract. In 1930, a lot of talent was tested, including Spencer Tracy and Pat O'Brien.

The two men got contracts and Miss Sidney did not. I think it was because Churchill's booming baritone recorded very well, and Overman's lighter voice sounds fixable. Miss Sdney's voice flutters near the top of optimal recording range. I suspect the Vitaphone equipment was not as good up there as Paramount's was.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
The main message of this cautionary tale . . .
tadpole-596-9182569 October 2019
Warning: Spoilers
. . . is for guys to put their foot down about who's wearing the pants in the family. Hen-pecked white collar worker "Bert Adams" has a "Mrs. Problem" located about FIVE MINUTES FROM THE STATION. Unfortunately, since Bert's low-budget wife is not named "Greta G.," she never gets close enough to the train tracks of this aforementioned station for the heavy wheels of the locomotive to solve his problem as they did "Mr. Karenin's." Instead, "Carrie Adams" has a penchant for churning out not really chewable entrees and for chewing out Bert's boss. As anyone with a grain of Common Sense will realize, this is not the proper combination of attributes necessary for the distaff side of a marriage to support her spouse by provided him the back-up of a placid business dinner. No doubt America's ubiquitous Papal Censors made the studio releasing FIVE MINUTES FROM THE STATION snip out the original ending of this piece (which probably involved those unforgiving iron circles of doom famous for giving "Anna K." her just desserts!).
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Somewhat interesting historically...
gerardjones24 October 2005
...but stiff, false, and bleak. Even Sidney doesn't show much except her ability to weep nervously, which would stand her in good stead later. From this, it's hard to see what audiences (or B.P. Schulberg) saw in her. This two- reeler's only virtue is giving us a glimpse at what movie makers at the raw end of the '20s thought would be a reassuring fantasy to young white- collar workers. The Depression was already making a lie of it, but Warners was still a couple of years from catching on. Sidney's tearful joy at the thought of buying an electric washing machine is revealing, though. A female screenwriter who knew how hard young mothers worked.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Quick Glimpse At Depression Era Domestic Life
Ron Oliver27 November 2000
A VITAPHONE VARIETIES Short Subject.

Living only FIVE MINUTES FROM THE STATION, a lowly clerk takes the Big Boss home for dinner. His determined wife sees this as an opportunity to campaign for her husband's promotion.

Realistic & sensible, this little 3-character drama deals forthrightly with some of the pressures & dreams of an average young married couple in the early months of the Great Depression.

Celebrated actress Sylvia Sidney makes one of her first screen appearances. Lynne Overman plays her husband; and Berton Churchill as the boss presents the sort of character he would portray many times in the next ten years.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Fair
Michael_Elliott2 December 2008
Five Minutes from the Station (1930)

** (out of 4)

Vitaphone short has a man (Lynne Overman) bringing his boss (Berton Churchill) home even though his wife (Sylvia Sidney) doesn't want him there. The poor couple have to beg for food in order to serve the boss and both are heartbroken when they learn that the job the husband wanted is going to someone else. This is a rather dry early talkie that feels like half an hour instead of the fourteen-minute running time. That's not really a bad thing because the director gets a lot of stuff into the short running time and while the film isn't a total success it does work as a history lesson as the movie comes off very realistic of the Depression-era. The performances are very good with the still unknown Sidney standing out. Churchill had a pretty long career but he's probably best remembered for being one of the founding members of the Screen Actors Guild.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Wow--an entire movie crammed into only 14 minutes!!
planktonrules22 July 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Berton Churchill plays the usual type role he was known for in Hollywood--the gruff boss. Lynne Overman is his employee that is hoping that he'll get a raise, so when the boss invites himself over to their apartment with very little notice, he nervously calls his wife (Sylvia Sidney) and begs her to understand. Well, things do not go perfectly at this impromptu meal and when the subject of the new job comes up, the boss does NOT give Overman the job--but asks him if he thinks a coworker would be good in that role! Well, considering that the meal was rushed and burned and they were so disappointed, his wife has had enough and explodes--telling the boss that her hubby is perfect for the job and he had a lot of nerve inviting himself over and ignoring her talented husband!! Surprisingly, Churchill is thrilled with her gumption and announces that due to this and many other reasons, he's giving Overman an even better promotion and the film ends.

This is an early Vitaphone short that manages to tell a story in what might usually be done in 60 or more minutes--and it does a very good job of it. Considering that it was made in the early days of the talkies, it's a very good and entertaining film--well written, excellently paced and very clever. It's also a very nice curio and lets you see how the average Joe lived.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed