The Perfect Clue (1935) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Comes Up Short
boblipton9 January 2019
When William P. Carleton announces he is going to get remarried, daughter Dorothy Libaire announces she will not stay in the same house if he does. Daddy says fine, so she elopes with Skeets Gallagher...until somewhere north of Albany, she realizes what a bad idea it is, jumps the train, busts her ankle and winds up hiring David Manners to tour in his jalopy until her sprain mends.

Manners admits frankly he's just out of prison for embezzlement, but he was framed. He knows who stole the money, but the guy has a wife and child, so... anyway, they are in a town where Manners needs to see a lawyer. When he goes to his office, the man dies in his arms. With his record, they will pin it on him.

It's an attempt to merge Screwball with a how-catch-em mystery, and much as I want it to work, it doesn't. The script never because wacky enough, Miss Libaire's character remains a spoiled brat too long and there aren't enough jokes, Gallagher's drunken character aside. There's no chemistry between the actors, no sparkle.

A lot of this can be put down to the fact that this is a Larry Darmour production, distributed through states rights. He had no money for the production, none for stars, less for a director, and less than nothing for retakes. David Manners in a freefalling career, was the most he could manage, and Manners does all right, but it just isn't enough.

It's a pity, because it could work. Enough people thought it did work that by the end of the following year, Darmour was distributing through Columbia. That would give his productions a little breathing room. It's too bad he didn't produce this a year later. Even as it is, it's not bad. It simply lacks the sparkle needed for screwball.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
A ridiculous but enjoyable story.
planktonrules8 August 2018
"The Perfect Clue" is a film that is enjoyable...but you need to turn off your brain and just enjoy it. Otherwise, you might think of how ridiculous and improbable the plot is...and that would ruin it.

Mona (Dorothy Libaire) is a spoiled rich girl. When her father decides to remarry, instead of being happy for him, she stomps off in a snit...a snit that takes her on a cross-country adventure. Along the way, she meets up with David (David Manners) and thinks he's a nice guy...until he tries to rob her! Now here's where it gets odd. Instead of robbing her, they end up going on adventures together! It all comes to a halt when cops think David murdered someone...and with his prison record, they're quick to assume the worst. What's next? See and find out for yourself.

The fact that Mona and David fall in love is amazingly far-fetched...but enjoyable. In fact, I'd say that about the entire film!
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Good actress in quirky story.
ecaulfield11 July 2009
Warning: Spoilers
Synopsis: He couldn't rob a woman, so I married him.

Mona (Dorothy Libaire) is mighty frustrated about Dad's (William P. Carleton) upcoming nuptials. So she and family friend, Ronnie (Richard 'Skeets' Gallagher) devise a plan to get back at Dad that includes Mona marrying for spite. Are you game? she asks.

Father is not dismayed or deterred from his plans. On board a train for Buffalo, Mona receives his telegram telling her he will meet them in Niagara Falls! So Mona prematurely leaves the train at a whistle stop. She hires David (David Manners) to drive her to Albany where she hopes to catch another train back to New York. But for the balance of the film, Mona is detoured which means she eludes Dad and has time to show David that she is a socialite with a nurturing side.

On the rugged road to Albany, driver David attempts to rob her jewelry: "Do I have to take 'em from ya?" This is a bit of a funny sight because David Manners is so clean cut looking, especially in that beret type of hat he wears. Mona doesn't scare easy. She gives him her valuables and asks, "What am I supposed to do, wait here for a streetcar?"

He drives off, and she walks along apparently spraining her ankle. Then a car drives up. Well, what do you know? It's the same guy, David. He's back. "I couldn't rob a woman."

This time, he resolutely agrees to drive her. She has no qualms about taking off with him again. She just needs a little help with her ankle. He finds her spoiled and selfish. She can't roll her own cigarettes, so he calls her Scatter brain. They have to sleep in the car because it's stuck in the mud. She says, "Good night, Jesse James."

David confides that he spent a year in Sing Sing after being set up for a crime he didn't commit at the bank he worked for. Who would give an ex-con a job, he asks? Mona would be glad to hire a convict. She asks him to drive her around for $25 a day until she's ready to go back home. Tough guy David says he'll drive her around until her ankle is better.

It turns out Dorothy's ankle is fine. David accuses Mona of using him for a thrill. But Mona sticks around to look after David. She doesn't want him accepting any crooked job offers.

There's another big scrape to come, and David will find out what a true friend he has found in Mona. The Perfect Clue is worthwhile because of the quirky way that Mona and David's friendship is formed and because the film allows Mona to be strong and determined rather than scared. She affects events as much as the world affects her.

The film avoids the melodramatic and keeps a light touch even when David is overcome with trouble. Skeets Gallagher's way with a humorous line is used to good effect. He stands up for goldfish ("They can't organize. They have no home life.") and declares alcohol the ultimate meal.

Why didn't Dorothy Libaire have more movies? She makes a spirited heroine.

Recommended. I dig that short excerpt of bluesy music on the Alpha Home Entertainment DVD that introduces the film.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
A perfect B+.
mark.waltz8 March 2016
Warning: Spoilers
Enjoyable programmer flies by in an hour, focusing on the antics of a spoiled socialite (Betty Blythe) and the bond she creates with ex-con David Manners while on the run from her widowed father. While pop is searching for her, she is being tamed by the hardboiled Manners who keeps trying to shake her off to no avail. Manners is falsely accused of murder, and it takes the love-sick Blythe not only to help him prove his innocence, but to get her off as an accessory while convincing her father that Manners is worthy of her love.

A mixture of battle of the sexes comedy, social drama and crime thriller, this is a pretty decent time filler from poverty row. Manners had pretty much ended his A list film career and was on the verge of permanent film hiatus. At times, it seems like several different movies with its varying subplots. The plot line involving Blythe's father simply vanishes from view, leaving a big hole in the conclusion.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Mediocre film
gridoon202431 March 2013
Warning: Spoilers
The first thing you need to know about "The Perfect Clue" is that it's absolutely NOT a detective film, an action film, or a mystery, as the title and the Alpha DVD cover (see the IMDb picture) seem to suggest; it's actually a romance, with a bit of a (simple) crime plot on the side. Which wouldn't necessarily be so bad, except that David Manners is not the most endearing leading man here, and Dorothy Libaire, whom I remember being terrific in the same year's "Murder On A Honeymoon", gives a rather awkward performance at times, as if she still hadn't fully adjusted to "the talkies". At least she has a winning smile. The film is not unwatchable, however it is a strictly mediocre affair. ** out of 4.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed