Scattergood Meets Broadway (1941) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
When the story lines run dry out in the sticks, take a branch to the Big Apple.
mark.waltz2 July 2019
Warning: Spoilers
When city slickers try to get something over on country bumpkin guy kibbee, they better make sure that they've got their rain coats because he'll bleed them dry before they have the chance to bleed him dry. Overhearing that an elderly widow's son (William Henry) has gone to New York to attempt a career as a playwright, Kibbee follows him there and ends up becoming involved in show business himself while spouting his folksy wisdom. Define set Henry is about to be taken in by con man producer Bradley Page and aids him in a romance with sweet Mildred Coles while distracting tough-talking actress Joyce Compton from interfering in their relationship. There's also Chester Conklin as Compton's check-writing daddy who keeps breaking up with her and assorted New York types who are alternately annoyed and amused by Kibbee's light-hearted, no-nonsense attitude. Compton takes desperate measures to get her hands on Kibbee's dough, but of course he has the last laugh.

"You don't smoke. You don't play checkers. You don't drink lemonade. What do you do you do?", Kibbee asks a disgruntled hotel waiter after having earlier tipped him only a dime. It's moments like this that makes the series more than just a bunch of corn trying out in the big city sun. Several of the series regulars appear briefly but most of this entry takes place in New York City and shows that just because someone isn't used to big city ways doesn't mean that they are unprepared in dealing with them.

Compton is delightfully trashy as the hard-hearted city girl determined to make her break one way or another, but her reaction to how Kibbee deals with her sorted attempt at blackmail tops everything that she did before. This is indeed a variation of the often filmed play "The Butter and Egg Man" where Compton gets to show how a bad actress looks when attempting to emote and once again Kibbee gets the better of her. In spite of its enjoyable moments, it's obvious that in its fourth episode, the series was running out of steam and would slowly fade out after only two more entries.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
The Country Mice Meet The Big City Rats
boblipton14 December 2023
William Henry left Coal River to see if he could get his play produced. He meets Mildred Coles in the park, and they bond over his curing her hiccups. Henry hasn't been able to get a producer to read his play. Miss Coles works for two produces, Frank Jenks and Bradley Page. Joyce Compton has a sugar daddy willing to back a play with $15,000, but all they're getting are he-man works; Henry's play foots the bill. With $15,000 in the bank, the producers are riding high, until the process servers appear for old bills and clean them out. They make Henry a partner, and skip town, leaving him on the hook for everything.

Meanwhile, Guy Kibbee and his toupee are in town to see how Henry is getting along. Can he save the play, take care of the bad guys, and ensure that young love will triumph?

The Scattergood Baines films were based on a series of short stories by Clarence Buddington Kelland. Scattergood was an amiable fellow who sat in front of his general store and didn't seem to do much, but as the owner of the local railroad, the bank, and several mills, he was a power throughout his state, and a canny, amiable fellow, always willing to help out good folks in need. Cheaply produced and directed by Christy Cabanne, they relied on good performers like Carl Stockdale and Emma Dunn, and small-town audiences. Most of them, and this one in particular, were amiable time wasters, pleasant enough for a neighborhood second feature.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Not enough Scattergood...too much big city.
planktonrules30 November 2023
"Scattergood Meets Broadway" is the third of five Scattergood Baines movies made by RKO and starring Guy Kibbee. So far, I have enjoyed the first two movies quite a bit...but this third one isn't up to the standards of the previous two. Now I am not saying it's bad...but it is a disappointment.

All the previous Scattergood movies are set in the small town where he is a leading citizen. However, most of this one is set in New York City AND the story is mostly different from the previous films as well. In fact, it's like Scattergood in name only.

The story finds that a citizen in Scattergood's town has gone to New York to make good writing plays. However, he's had no luck and despite letters back home telling his family how good things are, Scattergood suspects otherwise and travels to the big city. There he finds that some grifters have just offered to put on the guy's play...but they are cons and Scattergood isn't as stupid as they think he is! What's next? See the film.

As I talked about above, the formula for the film is quite different...and I didn't like that change. Scattergood is a secondary character and the change in setting and style really don't work IF you loved the previous films. If you've never seen them, then "Scattergood Meets Broadway" will likely seem better. Overall, a watchable film with some good moments but the film is a definite step down from the previous ones as well.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed