The Dim Little Island (1949)

Calificación de los usuarios:

5.7/10   

Director:

Humphrey Jennings

Género:

Corto

Comentarios de los usuarios:

trying to hold things together

Reparto

Ralph Vaughan Williams

...

Narrator

Duración:

10 min

País:

UK

Idioma:

Inglés

Clasificación:

UK:U

Compañía:

Wessex Films

trying to hold things together

Jennings' penultimate film is a short piece in which four men – composer Ralph Vaughan Williams, naturalist Jamie Fisher, industrialist John Orston and cartoonist Osbert Lancaster reflect on the roles of caricature, 'wild nature', industry and music in Britain's national life and attempt to dispel the notion that the country is a 'dim little island'. Jennings' conception was to edit the four strands of visual and spoken narrative together to produce an interdependent portrait of a place in which nature, industry and culture hold equal importance in the life and new growth of the nation. This is familiar Jennings territory, and although there are some typically inspired and witty touches, such as matching words about a candle to a shot of a large industrial chimney, the oft-repeated charge, that after the war Jennings' films lacked passion, is hard to deny. The narration talks of the 'great upheaval of national consciousness and emotion' that the nation had recently experienced and that Jennings' films so eloquently expressed. For him to use the same techniques of stylisation and range of shots – a clip from Fires Were Started appears and there are shots of water that could have come from Diary for Timothy and wheat fields from Listen to Britain – but to address a post-war lack of confidence instead of a surge of wartime solidarity, means the film is not as convincing as it should be; its intended audience is rather vague. Maybe this is due to the tone of the narrative; the naturalist warns that we may have to 'ration the fun' we get out of nature, the industrialist warns that we need 'more work from below and more drive from the top'. If we have that, he says, 'we can still compete'. With so many warning notes in the narrative, it is unsurprising that our attention is drawn to the editing in the film - it seems to be trying to hold things together instead of reinforcing ties already present.