My Six Convicts (1952) User Reviews

Unusual funny and human comedy-drama

[Crispin-3 · 8/10 · 5 March 2008]

A sleeper that evidently few have seen recently, this unpretentious comedy-drama can take an honorable mention in the long list of prison films. An early Stanley Kramer production, it received critical acclaim but was not a box-office success. Nevertheless, it has good character acting, some very amusing scenes, and enough dramatic tension to hold the attention and set off the comic moments.

Don't be put off by the overly earnest opening, as the new, wet-behind-the-ears psychiatrist arrives at the prison hoping to reform the penitentiary system single-handed. Although Kramer reportedly had prison reform in mind in making the film, this movie is not about psychological theories, which are lightly passed over with buzz-word gobbledygook. It's not even about the good doctor himself or his research so much as it's about the six cons of the title, as they become human beings to us.

Speaking of buzz-words, the genial Connie's psycho-babble malapropisms are among the best of the running gags. The many funny scenes stand out against the grim realism of the penitentiary, shot on location at San Quentin. The comedy also contrasts sharply with the dramatic dilemma the "doc" must face between gaining (and keeping) the confidence of his six cons and learning too much to be healthy in the deadly reality of prison life. But overall this is a human comedy more than an edge-of-your seat drama.

There are excellent photographic moments using long wide-angle shots to dramatize the starkness of the prison environment, which contrast well with the friendly intimacy gradually established in the psychiatrist's office. And the movie gets an extra star for the fine score by Dimitri Tiomkin, famous for many much better-known movies from "It's a Wonderful Life" to "The Guns of Navarone".

It's well worth watching for this to come around on television, as you are unlikely to find it at your corner video store -- not available on DVD or VHS at the time of writing.

What makes a convict tick?

[bkoganbing · 7/10 · 8 October 2012]

A no big name cast, but a lot of solid character players make My Six Convicts a really original and worthwhile film about our penal system. What makes a convict tick, that's what psychologist John Beal is in the state prison system to find out and you be the judge if he did.

Beal is sent to San Quentin and since that's where this film was shot, I'll use that as the prison name to find out to see if we can better rehabilitate convicts. Actually part of the answer is supplied in Goodfellas where Henry Hill says that people who work are stupid. Just take what you want at least until you get caught.

This film is about the thousands of guys who aren't connected who do wind up in the joint for one reason or another, that group you saw demanding their meals while the wiseguys were dining elegantly. As in every prison picture any place of incarceration has its own set of rules and code which one had better learn quickly.

Beal needs a staff and he comes up with six of them, Gilbert Roland, Millard Mitchell, Alf Kjellin, Marshall Thompson, Jay Adler, and Harry Morgan. All join up with Beal for their own reasons, but all of them worry about confidentiality, a real important thing in Beal's research. But it's also something that the cons worry about when it comes to being a stool pigeon. And that's a guy with no popularity and limited life expectancy.

The six convicts are quite a study in convict Americana. Although all of these guys are near and dear as great character players my favorites would have to be Millard Mitchell, Gilbert Roland, and Jay Adler. Mitchell is your old convict who knows the system inside out and how and when to play people to get what he wants, he was an ace safecracker by trade before going in. Roland is a gangster who is doing his time and waiting to be deported where on his stashed loot he's going to live the good life.

Adler was a truly sad case, a guy who got greedy and caught and who is a great example of recidivism. After he gets his parole he doesn't know what to do on the outside so he deliberately violates parole to get back. A truly institutionalized human being and between the time of the making of this film and now, no one has found a way to deal with that.

My Six Convicts from Columbia's B picture unit is a great film of some wonderful case studies of the criminal mind.

s

The 1963 film The Great Escape benefited from this earlier prison film

[Ed-Shullivan · 8/10 · 17 June 2020]

Well I must say this prison film was a nice surprise. Both the realism of the filming that took place at San Quentin State Prison and the strong acting by all lead seven (7) actors kept me paying attention to the very end. Was it a realistic portrayal of life in prison? No, but the story line was superbly executed and the the psychologist (John Beal) referred to as simply "Doc" who narrates a lot of the story was well presented.

It did remind me of the later 1963 Oscar nominated prison film The Great Escape starring Steve McQueen, Charles Bronson and James Garner. Although the actors who starred in this lesser known film such as Millard Mitchell and Gilbert Roland never attained the star status of McQueen, Bronson and/or Garner their acting was top notch and most enjoyable.

This is a most under rated film and more than deserving of my 8 out of 10 IMDB rating.

Erratic but Well Meaning

[boblipton · 7/10 · 5 March 2008]

This early Stanley Kramer production is well-cast, with fine performances by Millard Mitchell, a typical bit of interesting overplaying by Gilbert Roland and some good work by the rest of the supporting cast, including Byron Foulger and Henry Morgan. But although the early scenes are nicely done in an appropriate semi-documentary style -- director Fregonese started out doing public-service shorts about firefighters and the police -- the majority of the movie is taken up with moments of melodrama. I also have the uneasy feeling of no real connection -- that the 'six convicts' of the title are meant to be types, rather than individuals.

Cameraman Guy Roe, who started out with well-regarded B noirs like ARMORED CAR ROBBERY and later went into TV work, does some handsome work with good choices of angles. Look for the sequence in which the convicts get upset about the pitcher being withheld from the game.

Not uninteresting but not for me

[searchanddestroy-1 · 27 January 2023]

It is rather unusual to show a prison movie this way, from the psychological point of view. The classical jail scheme is about violence, brutality, escape plan, not from this angle. That said, it is unusual but, sorry, I was pretty bored. I prefered RIOT IN CELL BLOCK 11 or BRUTE FORCE, or THE LAST MILE. I tried to avoid this Hugo Fregonese film all long those years, and I finally tried it. And that confirmed I was damn right to run away from it. Again, I don't say it's a bad film, not at all, but for moviegoers in search of prison films, I warn, it is very special. Psycholgical study of inmates; it is definitely a drama and not a crime flick, as some dictionaries say. Not the Hugo Fregonese's film that I will remember in first. Or only to avoid it again in the future.

A psychologist goes to prison, but not as an inmate

[SimonJack · 7/10 · 25 June 2021]

"My Six Convicts" is an interesting comedy drama about one of the first psychologists to work in a prison. John Beal plays Doc who is given a six-month trial effort to see if he can accurately test the convicts for their IQs, and study their backgrounds. This was part of an idea he had to see if it would make sense to staff prisons with such professionals in the future. Doc's biggest challenge is to earn the trust of the inmates.

After some chicanery by a couple of inmates, and Doc's pointing out the advantages of lighter duty in working with him, half a dozen men come around. They agree to work on his staff, and they become the first to take his tests. Millard Mitchell plays James Connie who surreptitiously steers the Doc and the inmates through a successful effort. Mitchell gives a great performance and received a Golden Globe award as best supporting actor in 1952. Other prominent actors among the inmates are Gilbert Roland as Punch Pinero, Harry Morgan as Dawson, Marshall Thompson as Blivens Scott and Jay Adler as Steve Kopac.

The film is a fictional adaptation of a real story. An attempted prison break, killing and suicide aren't in the book. The source is a 1951 autobiographic book by Donald Powell Wilson, "My Six Convicts: A Psychologist's Three Years in Fort Leavenworth." While Fort Leavenworth is a federal penitentiary in Kansas, the setting and story for this film was at San Quentin, a northern California state prison.

The comedic light touch lifts this film and helps in the individual portrayals of the six convicts' lives in more depth. It's a film worth seeing if one can find it on DVD.

Getting to the root of the criminal mind.

[mark.waltz · 8/10 · 4 March 2024]

A violent but brutally honest look at life in a men's prison as seen through the prison psychiatrist's mind. Powerful performances from Millard Mitchell, Gilbert Roland, John Beal and Marshall Thompson, this studies the motivation behind many different kind of crimes, and the results are a combination of predictable and surprising.

As the psychiatrist, Beal gives a fully grounded performance, not too angelic or philosophical, doing more listening than talking, and discovering through his research that there's a prison break being planned. Mitchell deserved the Golden Globe nomination that he got, reminding me a more serious combination of Slim Summerville and Buddy Ebsen with his droopy face. Thompson, a criminal suffering from shock, is the most profound. Frequent brutality doesn't sugar coat this, and makes for a realistic examination of the correctional sector.