Statues also Die (1953) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
The Cruelty of Imperialism
ilpohirvonen18 February 2011
"When men die, they become history. Once statues die, they become art. This botany of death is what we call culture."

This smart opening line sets up high expectations for the viewer, and the film succeeds in redeeming all of them. After seven months I saw this film for the second time, this time on the big screen, and therefore decided to write a brief review of the film, I so admire. The film is an intelligent analysis of the cruelty by which imperialism has destroyed the art of the original Africa. It was made by two French masters to come - Alain Resnais (Hiroshima mon amour) and Chris Marker (La jetee). Together they created a masterpiece which changed our way of looking at Africa, due to which the film was instantly banned for four years.

In the late 1940's India became independent and it was just a matter of time when Europeans would get kicked out of Africa. Africa begun to wake up. Before this documentary people had only experienced Africa through imperialistic consciousness - Tarzan films were all the material people had seen of the colony and Africa's own films were still waiting to be made. The film was years ahead of its time, depicting imperialism - the political, economical and cultural exploitation of colonial possessions, and the European feeling of superiority. Just as Jean Rouch's The Mad Masters (1954) so did this documentary, about the art of indigenous peoples, get banned and therefore is still quite unknown compared to another documentary by Alain Resnais, about the legacy of WWII and concentration camps, Night and Fog (1955).

The commentary track by Chris Marker leads us to the sacred world of artifacts. But when they get cataloged and put behind museum showcases, they die too. We are shown how original art gets destroyed, how the old core values vanish. There is no sense in categorizing objects into art in a world where everything is art, a kind of world which Africa here represents. A man of the African community sees so much more in this art - he sees the faces of culture, where all we see is external beauty and picturesqueness.

Statues Also Die is a film about racism and western thoughts of superiority: "We look at Negro art just as it would gain its right to exist after giving the pleasure to us." African art is full of soul and beauty, filled with significance. But as Europeans steal it and take it from their land to the cold museums, the art loses its meaning. Europeans can only enjoy it aesthetically, they only see its external side and not the essence of it. They adore this art and as demand grows it turns into mass-production, trash - bazaar art.

Great art has been bought and spoiled, the black man was paid to sell his soul, to turn his heritage, culture and life into a comedy. Religious needs were replaced by commercial interests; "folklore, sports and music." The black man was able to make fun of the white man in the ring, or in a basketball game but after they won, they got bashed and kicked in the name of racism. The role of the boxer or the drummer, in the ring or in the orchestra, was born from the need to return the strikes their brothers had taken from the white man in the streets. White man enslaves the black man; an illustrating moment is the picture where a white man is guiding a black man to make a bracelet - white man has turned original African art into a portrait of himself.
23 out of 29 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The Modern Art Of Rebellion.
meddlecore22 July 2020
"When men die they become history. Once statues die they become art".

This film is about magic. The magic of creation enacted through the art of imagination.

For those engaged in this act become like Gods.

They show us that all things are connected to everything that have come before it, unlike in white colonial culture, where everything has become disconnected and at odds with one another. A perspective that is wholly unnatural.

It's also a film about immortality. Posing the question: would man exist at all if not for art?

They point out that man- like the Gods- can transcend death through the materialization of their double- once a shadow or reflection- into a material form.

But statues can also die...crumbling to pieces...or being buried in the archives of museums and institutions. Fading away, into nothingness. Like a dead language. Losing their magic through the effect of commercialization and reproduction.

External incursions have disconnected African people from their past, via the imposition of christian and islamic psychophants, who have taken their place...as their "new" ancestors.

While their world becomes a mere reproduction of the one that has conquered it.

And under such circumstances, the only "living art", becomes that of rebellion. It's form fleeting and transitory.

As all other forms become degraded by the colonizers who consume it, and for whom it is now produced- as either trinkets or spectacle.

This rebellion, thus, begins to manifest itself in new forms- such as sport, labour activism and music (like jazz)- through which those who have been disconnected from their past, start to push back against the fragile white ego, and culture, that tries to keep them repressed, every time they show signs of new life.

Marker, Resnais and Choqlain conclude this manifesto, by stating that magic can only be restored to our realms when all the pasts of all the people are given absolute equality. For if art created man as man created art, we are all, today, products of all the great cultures of yesterday.

The domineering aspect of white supremacy is quite literally...killing us all.

10 out of 10.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Botany of death we call culture
politfilm28 June 2019
The narrator says in the opening sequence: "When men die, they become history. Once statues die, they become art. This botany of death is what we call culture." This documentary makes an excellent analysis of the cold cruelty by which colonialism and imperialism destroyed the original art of Africa. They first enslaved and destroyed the civilization that created these objects and was able to comprehend them, they recognized only aesthetic properties of these artefacts, as if they exist only to entertain colonizers, transformed them into exotic souvenirs and further degraded them by turning them into mass produced commodities made to be sold on bazaars. Due to the harsh criticism of colonialism, the film was censored and almost the entire second half of the movie was banned. The full original version was publicly screened in France in 1968, fifteen years after it was made.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Pretty random and lacks focus
Horst_In_Translation27 July 2016
Warning: Spoilers
"Les statues meurent aussi" or "Statues also Die" is a half-hour documentary from France. This was made in 1953 by three pretty successful filmmakers, namely Chris Marker, Alain Resnais and (not yet) Oscar winner Ghislain Cloquet. This film is already almost 65 years old today and I cannot really say it has aged too well. First of all, despite the early attempt to explain the title, it does not really fit the film. The film depicts art for a long time and African masks, which is perfectly fine as there are probably many people who are interested in this subject. I myself am not among these. And then, later on, the film makes a completely random jump into culture, politics and society in Africa and also asks questions about race equality. I personally felt this did not fit in at all with everything we have seen earlier, regardless of how important and relevant the subject may be. Also color may have helped a whole lot as big part of the film is actually about color and also seeing these masks early on in color would have elevated the material for sure. I personally don't think this was a good watch. Thumbs down from me.
4 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed