Elephant Walk (1954) Poster

(1954)

User Reviews

Review this title
45 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Vivid tale of comeuppance, lust and beauty
jimor19 August 2005
ELEPHANT WALK may not be the acme of literature or of film, but it is great entertainment in the quasi-melodramatic mode. It is the story of love, both genuine and illicit, as well as overweening ambition, devotion, and the arrogance of personal tyranny. A previous reviewer, John Mankin, questions why the central focus of the film, the mansion called Elephant Walk, should have been built by the former owner, the "governor" the late Tom Wiley, right across the elephants' traditional path to the major source of water, the river. To miss this point is to essentially miss the point of the whole center of the film: the hubris of man. That his son, played by Peter Finch, should become enthralled by the super image and enigma of his revered father, is not unexpected, since the son was without a mother growing up in a foreign jungle with only his father and his father's rowdy 'boys' club' as his role models. The point of the father was that he was a self-made man who would tame nature to his liking, and that liking was not just a tea plantation upon the lands the elephants once dominated, but also that he would dominate even the large bull elephant that led the herd, and thus he would dominate his son and all around him, and so we join the tale after the elephants have been denied the crucial dry season access to their pathway to water. Who could know that this dry season would last so long and what the elephants would do in desperation to get water? This is the nexus of the film: what will animals do to get water; what will humans do to get power or love? Ceylon, today's Sri Lanka, is the huge island off the coast of India where the plantation is located and one quickly learns that it is the real scenery of the story, not just the expenses of Miss Taylor. Were it not for this exotic location (much of the film was shot in Ceylon), and the magnificent "bungalow" this would have been just another potboiler. One must recognize the atmosphere created here as integral to the time and place, as it illuminates the latter day wealth and power attained by the English immigrant 'conquerors' that were part and parcel of the British raj. It is only such wealth gained by the use of virtual slave labor that one could build so magnificent a residence of ebony, teak, and marble. Not to be overlooked are the wonderfully carved Jalees (grille work window and doorway borders) evidently specified by art directors J. McMillan Johnson and Hal Pereira and obviously made by the cheaper labor on the island. Such craftsmanship reveals the careful attention to detail that these men sought.

For those immune to the blandishments of time, place, and architecture, there is always the allure of Miss Taylor, as she marries a man she doesn't really know and is tacitly wooed by a another man, against the background described, and under the overarching tyranny of the legacy of a man deceased. As I said, it is not great literature nor even great film, but it is great spectacle long before that term was debased by the special effects extravaganzas of today.

This is one of those films made to be seen on the giant screen of an outdoor drive-in, not on the home TV, so arrange the largest screen to see it on to fully appreciate its fine camera-work and scope.
34 out of 38 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Old fashiond fun
ryancm21 July 2005
Corny but fun film of the 50's. Except for her first scene in the bookstore, Liz Taylor looks gorgeous, especially outfitted as she is. Every curve and then some shows. A bit talky at first, but gains momentum as picture goes on. Lush scenery, although some process shots look...well like process. Peter Finch is good as the head of the tea plantation and is a bit ruthless at times. Good guy Dana Andrews shows up as a good romantic interest when needed. Whom will Liz end up with? The elephant stampede at the end is well worth the price of admission. By the way, the DVD transfer is great. Worth a look just to see the 50's style filming..No sex, violence, foul language. OK for the whole family.
23 out of 27 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Liz is an exquisite creature with an unquestioned beauty and talent...
Nazi_Fighter_David5 June 2002
Warning: Spoilers
Robert Standish's novel is about a triangular romantic situation on a Ceylonese tea plantation... So the events of the Ceylon backgrounds and pictorial beauty are rewarding points to William Dieterle's film...

The story is about a rich powerful planter (Peter Finch), who brings a charming and tender beauty (Elizabeth Taylor), into the jungle as his bride... The plantation, of course, is endangered by some kind of wild life... For this reason Taylor — elegant as never in dazzling costumes — finds herself in a strange atmosphere... The echo determination of a ghost, the bad temper of a husband obsessed by the memory of his autocratic father, a highly dangerous disease, and the fury of wild animals...

In her confusion, boredom and annoyance Elizabeth Taylor looks to a friendly face, a pretentious foreman (Dana Andrews), who admires her beauty but tries to conquer her love...

With echoes of "Jane Eyre," the mysterious Yorkshire mansion with a brooding master, and "Rebecca," the innocent young second wife hunted by the image of the glamorous first wife, "Elephant Walk" is a menace melodrama with a wide view of a huge tropical bungalow, exotic dances with rage excessively colorful, stampeding big bull elephants, amazing mansion set on fire, all in the company of an exquisite creature with an unquestioned beauty and talent...

The movie gave Liz a change of scenery, and allowed her more creative energy and self-respect than most of her other willful debutante-rebels… The wife here has a sharp tongue and a strong will, and so Taylor plays her movie star heroine with more spirit than she was given credit for
28 out of 35 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Impressions of a Nine-Year-Old
rlaux21 January 2006
My parents took me to this movie when I was nine years old. I have never forgotten it. I had never before seen anything as beautiful as Elizabeth Taylor. (She was twenty-two when she made Elephant Walk) Remember, I'm nine, so the feelings aren't sexual, I just couldn't see anything else on the screen. I just wanted to sit at her feet like a puppy and stare up at her. She has begun to show her age, (She's almost seventy-four) but I still believe her to be one of the most beautiful and breathtaking women to ever have lived.

I have seen the movie several times since, and it is a sappy melodrama. What saves it is, of course, Miss Taylor's beauty, magnificent scenery, the very impressive elephant stampede, and a well-made point on human arrogance in the face of nature.

All in all, a well-spent couple of hours watching the movie channel or a rented video.
33 out of 42 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Glamorous film in which a beautiful girl marries a tea planter and returns with him to his plantation in an isolated jungle mansion
ma-cortes16 November 2014
Agreeable romance/adventure film in which a British gorgeous woman marries a wealthy colonial owner and go to live in his huge plantation but it happens to be on the path where elephants roam. This romantic adventure movie in soap opera style was lavishly produced by Paramount Pictures with all-star-cast , glimmer cinematography and luxurious scenarios . As the young bride named Ruth Wiley (Elizabeth Taylor) of a rich planter (Peter Finch) finds herself the only white woman at Elephant Walk tea plantation, British Ceylon . In the plantation Dick Carver (Dana Andrews), works as a right-hand man and she finds certain protection , thanks to Dick the tough foreman , then a mutual attraction emerges each other , soon makes him indispensable . The jungle , of course, is endangered by some kind of wild life and some dangerous elephants , for this reason she finds herself in a strange atmosphere . Furthermore , a cholera epidemic outbursts , followed by elephants destroying the plantation . There takes places a searing story of sudden love and sudden death in the hot green hell of the Ceylon jungle , being threatened by the hovering , ominous appearance of the hostile elephants . One man and several elephants claimed the land , two men claimed the woman who lived there .

This exciting film has emotion , romance , intrigue , exotic landscapes , colonial settings and results to be pretty entertaining . Ceylon's balmy jungles provide the backstage for a triangular torrid love between Elizabeth Taylor , Peter Finch and Dana Andrews , in this post-prime William Dieterle effort . Intelligent and engaging script which uses intriguing situations to give us an acceptable movie in a high sense and intimate sensitivity and that kept me entertained for the almost 100 minutes of duration . ¨Elephant walk¨ is an enjoyable adventure movie , a menace melodrama with a wide view of a huge tropical bungalow , exotic scenarios with rage excessively colorful , big bull elephants , an amazing mansion , a love story , drama and many other things . The movie is very persuasively made , usually rise to a crescendo of emotion and had at the time a remarkable success. Entertaining romance/adventure is visually striking with a spectacular final . I liked everyone in the excellent cast, and the male and female actors , especially Elizabeth Taylor , were all very attractive . The hit of the show is undoubtedly for the fetching and attractive Elizabeth Taylor who gives one of her best screen acting . Elizabeth wears lush gowns splendidly designed by expert costume designer Edith Head . Although Vivien Leigh was originally cast, but her mental illness begun affecting things during filming, and so she was replaced by Elizabeth Taylor ; many long shots and shots from behind are still of Leigh . Furthermore, a thrilling as well as breathtaking climax at the mansion in which the protagonist are besieged by a herd of elephants . This picture bears remarkable resemblance to ¨Escape to Burma¨ (1954) by Allan Dwan that contains a similar jungle scenario (Sri Lanka) , elephants and known actors as Barbara Stanwyck , Robert Ryan and David Farrar . It also has several points in common with ¨The naked jungle¨ by Byron Haskin regarding a woman , Eleanor Parker , who marries a planter , Charlton Heston , living in jungle until a final tragedy takes place . ¨Elephant walk¨ packs a colorful cinematography print in Technicolor 1.37:1 and composed for Widescreen presentation, by Loyal Griggs considered to be one of the best cameramen of the 40s and 50s . Sensitive as well as evocative musical score by the classic Franz Waxman .

This adventure yarn from the golden age of Hollywood was well directed by William Dieterle as a classic example of drama/romance/adventure of the fifties . Dieterle is a German director who was in Hollywood by 1930s and directing dramas (Scarlet down, Fog over Frisco, Fashions) , costumer (Hunchback of Notre Dame,Kismet,Omar Khayyan) and biopics (Life of Emile Zola, Dr Ehrlich, Juarez, Madame Curie, Reuter) that were a revelation at the box-office. Rating : 6,5/10 , better than average . Well worth watching . The picture will appeal to Elizabeth Taylor fans .
11 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Us versus Them, writ large
tom_amity17 March 2005
Warning: Spoilers
At first glance, ELEPHANT WALK is a saga of the wicked decadent rich. That's the angle all the reviewers here have discussed. Something like the TV show DALLAS, maybe, if a lot more imaginative.

But the more interesting aspect is that it's a parable about (**SPOILER, SPOILER!**) nature taking back her own. Y'see, the lovably decadent and endearingly hateful characters in this film are paying an ancestral debt for the originally sinful act whereby the previous generation's patriarch simply HAD, in his hubris, to build his equivalent of "Tara" right in the path of what had been the local elephants' right-of-way from time immemorial. Typical human behavior, I fear, but the fact is that elephants are just as territorial as we are, and if you cut off their right-of-way they will still retain the long memory for which they are so noted. Even if all they can do about it is gather in front of the land y'all stole, flap their ears and trunks at you, and trumpet their displeasure.

And while all this is going on, the Liz Taylor and Peter Finch characters are having the fancy marital problems which take up all the attention of IMDb reviewers. The reviewers' attention span is like that of the characters in the film, an attitude which is something like "who cares, they're nothing but a bunch of silly elephants". Indeed, one character says with a smirk, "the natives here believe elephants are people. They call them the Elephant People." Ridiculous idea, right?

Well, not exactly. One otherwise fine day, an epidemic ravages the Elephant Walk plantation, and as a result there are no native servants ("beaters", in the local jargon) there to drive them away for the white masters' benefit. In fact, to the Elephant People's delight (and mine, I must admit), NOBODY is there to answer their challenge, so they walk on in and reclaim their heritage. (No doubt they are at this time singing the elephantese translation of Woody Guthrie's: "As I was walking that ribbon of highway,/I saw a SIGN that said no tresPASSING,/But on the other side, it just said nothing./That side was made for you and me.") And the invaded mansion catches fire from a downed chandelier, burning to the ground. Because no humans are there to protect it.

No, I'm wrong. There's ONE human there, one old native who's been serving Master too long to know what's good for him and too old to be running around helping contain the epidemic. He does wave his arms and shout "Go back, Elephant People! Go back!", and the predictable pachydermal response is is "Yeah? Or what?" They trample him, of course. And praise the Lord, they destroy the mansion.

This has been long winded, but I really wanted everybody to pay attention to what this film is really about. The moral of this story is: There comes a moment, in the awful providence of God, when nature turns the tables on her rapists. A moment when you will realize, as the poet said, that "You'll never get rid of the boom-de-boom nomatter whatcha do." And when that happens, all the acting talent and the costumes and the lovable decadence in the world won't save the Taylor and Finch characters. Their sizzling love and hate affairs won't amount to a hill of beans.

If Tarzan existed, this would be his favorite movie.

O give me a home/where the elephants roam... But seriously, guys, I think this is a pretty good cautionary tale.
48 out of 70 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Intriguing soap opera with shades of "Rebecca"!
moonspinner5525 March 2007
A beautiful shopgirl in London is swept off her feet by a millionaire tea plantation owner and soon finds herself married and living with him at his villa in British Ceylon. Although based upon the book by Robert Standish, this initial set-up is highly reminiscent of Hitchock's "Rebecca", with leading lady Elizabeth Taylor clashing with the imposing chief of staff at the mansion and (almost immediately) her own husband, who is still under the thumb of his deceased-but-dominant father. Taylor, a last-minute substitute for an ailing Vivien Leigh, looks creamy-smooth in her high fashion wardrobe, and her performance is quite strong; however, once husband Peter Finch starts drinking heavily and barking orders at her, one might think her dedication to him rather masochistic (this feeling hampers the ending as well). Still, the film offers a heady lot for soap buffs: romantic drama, a bit of travelogue, interpretive dance, an elephant stampede, and a perfectly-timed outbreak of cholera! **1/2 from ****
15 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
If you liked "Giant" you'll like "Elephant Walk"
HotToastyRag19 July 2017
Elizabeth Taylor's role in Elephant Walk reminds me of her role in Giant. She's married to a very powerful man, but she can't seem to quell her rambunctious nature, often starting fights and dishing out what she takes. So, if you liked Giant, try this one, and vice versa.

In Elephant Walk, Liz is wooed and wed by the wealthy Peter Finch, but when he takes her into his world (much like in Giant), she doesn't quite fit in. She moves to the tropical tea plantation in Ceylon, but the cultural and lifestyle changes are difficult. And when hunky Dana Andrews enters the picture, she just might find a distraction from her new surroundings. . .

With Liz and Dana, there's lots of eye candy in this movie. A few strong-willed speeches and some romantic scenes don't make it the most memorable film to come out of the 50s, but it's worth it if you like good-looking people up on the screen.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A truly underrated Elizabeth Taylor film
weekly-movie-review12 December 2008
The scintillating Elizabeth Taylor stars in this lesser-known classic as a young girl from London who falls in love with a tea plantation owner from British Ceylon (current day Sri Lanka). Upon arrival she instantly feels out of place and is forced to adapt to the new culture as well as be in constant awareness of the angry elephant herd. William Dieterle, who also directed The Life Of Emile Zola and Portrait Of Jennie , does a masterful job of bringing a somewhat dark, and almost eerie, undertone to this romance and the setting is one of the most beautiful I've seen with the black and white themed mansion and the gorgeous island scenery.
13 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
"Rebecca" Meets "The Letter"
glmoritz15 June 2007
Warning: Spoilers
I watched "Elephant Walk" for the first time in about 30 years and was struck by how similar the story line is to the greatly superior "Rebecca." As others have said, you have the sweet young thing swept off her feet by the alternately charming and brooding lord of the manor, only to find her marriage threatened by the inescapable memory of a larger-than-life yet deeply flawed relative. You have the stern and disapproving servant, a crisis that will either bind the couple together or tear them irreparably apart, climaxed by the fiery destruction of the lavish homestead.

Meanwhile, "Elephant Walk" also owes some of its creepy jungle atmosphere to "The Letter," the Bette Davis love triangle set on a Singapore rubber plantation rather than a Sri Lankan tea plantation.

Maltin gives "Elephant Walk" just two stars, and IMDb readers aren't much kinder, but I enjoyed it despite its predictability. Elizabeth Taylor never looked lovelier, and Peter Finch does a credible job as the basically good man unable to shake off the influence of his overbearing father. Dana Andrews -- a favorite in "Laura" and "The Best Year of Our Lives" -- is wasted as Elizabeth's frustrated admirer. The real star is the bungalow, one of the most beautiful interior sets in movie history.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Rather like Rebecca, except with elephants....
AlsExGal17 July 2022
... with Abraham Sofaer as a kinder gentler Mrs. Danvers.

John Wiley (Peter Finch), a Ceylon (Sri Lanka today) planter, is in London. While there he meets and marries a bookstore clerk, Ruth (Elizabeth Taylor) and brings her back to his estate - "Elephant Walk". But once home John begins to change. He seems haunted by the specter of his father, Tom Wiley, a harsh man who built Elephant Walk - named such because it is literally in the path of the historic elephant path to water. John drinks heavily, broods, and parties all night with a bunch of fellow planters, barking at Ruth if she complains. The supervisor of all the servants - Appuhamy - gets up every morning and talks to the grave of John's father, Tom, mentioning that he does not like Ruth, and that her ways are cold and distant. Appuhamy should know because he is cold and distant to Ruth, who only wants to take her place as running the household, but between Appuhamy, her distant husband, and the ghost of her father-in-law she is pretty much ganged up on. So let's also throw in that this movie is somewhat like "Giant " too in that regard.

But a ray of sunshine is the presence of an Elephant Walk foreman, Dick Carver (Dana Andrews) who falls in love with Ruth at first sight. Ruth wants her marriage to work, but between a foreman with bedroom eyes, a very haunted and brooding husband, epidemics and elephants, her path is a hard one. How will this work out? I'd say in a visually spectacular way for the time, yet utterly predictable.

Paramount certainly put energy into designing Liz' fashions. While they were at it they should have maybe put more money into shooting on location. There are shots that are clearly on location in Ceylon. But then they will intersperse those shots with those that are obviously on some Hollywood lot with back projection of the countryside. When Liz and Dana Andrews take a horseback ride through the plantation, the cheesiness of the back projection ventures into Ed Wood territory.

There is an interesting backstory to the making of this film. Apparently Vivien Leigh was originally supposed to have the part of Ruth, but illness prevented it. At age 40 she would have looked almost as odd as the fresh young bride as Liz would have looked in1939 as Scarlet O'Hara given she was seven at the time.

In spite of good performances by the entire cast, the sum of the thing is rather hokey and overwrought. Still, since all but the "tent pole" studio era films made by Paramount are hard to find, I'd say give it a look if it ever comes your way.
10 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Elephant Walk is an ode to Resistance.
laresrevolt21 August 2015
In Elephant Walk,directed by William Dieterle and set in Ceylon (now Sri Lanka), the elephants symbolically represent resistance to British colonialism. Viewed from an anti-colonial perspective the film becomes a highly charged, beautifully made pamphlet against colonial grabbing as practiced by the masters of Elephant Walk, British Empire profiteers. To build his fortune, Tom Wiley, the dead, arrogant, greedy tyrant colonizer stopped at nothing, including cutting off the water supply of the Elephants and, collaterally, of the native Ceylonese. However, usurping wealth (tea) and using people as virtual slaves resulted, as usual, in knee-jerk resistance to an unjust economic order, to environmental spoilage, to the rule over the many by a few, to a system formatted to make sure the rich get richer and the poor get poorer. This resistance is what the elephants represented. Instead of the ignored elephant in the room, this picture is about resistance symbolized by elephants that won't be ignored. Elizabeth Taylor portrayed a person born and raised in England who remained oblivious to the true nature of the colonial system. She was like 99% of Brits who, like most of us, were and remain victims of the class who has declared it has a right to possess the world and its people. Today we call this class Wall Street, The Banks, The 1%. Fortunately, in 1972, Ceylon became Sri Lanka and the natives recuperated their land. They may not be any richer today but anything beats being a virtual slave at the hands of British colonial masters, one of the greediest, most arrogant and dehumanizing groups ever to infest the planet. The movie masterfully depicts the true nature of the money-hungry economic parasites who were interested in only one thing – making $$$$££££ - and willing to do anything to get it. John Wiley the character so excellently portrayed by Peter Finch, is more true to life than say, The Great Gatsby, a romanticized version of a 1 percenter. The more I watch this film, the better it gets. Elisabeth Taylor is stunning. Peter Finch is captivating. Dana Andrews is, as always, excellent. The supporting cast is superb. The direction is masterful. The natural decor is hauntingly luxuriant and the interior sets are memorable. So is there anything wrong with this picture? Only that it remains underrated.
8 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Tea and sympathy.
brogmiller21 February 2022
Although not nearly as ludicrous, this could be seen as Paramount's companion piece to its 'Naked Jungle' from the same year and instead of hordes of killer ants we have herds of marauding pachyderms. The presence of William Dieterle in the director's chair is a definite plus.

Distinct echoes here of 'Rebecca' with Peter Finch and Elizabeth Taylor as Maxim and Mrs. De Winter and Abraham Sofaer as Mrs. Danvers. Ironic indeed that Mr. Finch was Laurence Olivier's protegé as Olivier was prevented by prior commitments from appearing in this. Miss Taylor was replacing the indisposed Vivien Leigh whose interest in Mr. Finch was more than purely professional.

The film itself boasts the customarily splendid Paramount production values, is beautifully shot by Loyal Griggs with a suitably dramatic score by Franz Waxman. Mr. Finch glowers magnificently, Miss Taylor at twenty-two is in the full bloom of her beauty and the always excellent Dana Andrews has a thankless role as 'the other man'. Following his 'greylisting' William Dieterle was to find worthwhile directorial assignments increasingly elusive but he does his very best here with the material at his disposal.

People see films in surprisingly different ways and an earlier reviewer has suggested that the stampeding elephants represent 'resistance to British colonialism.' Yes, well.....
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Man against nature with a romantic angle
NewEnglandPat3 August 2005
Essentially a story of man versus nature, this film has beautiful cinematography, the lush jungles of Ceylon and the presence of Elizabeth Taylor but the film really never gets going. Newlwed Taylor is ignored and neglected by her husband and later is drawn to the plantation's foreman, played by Dana Andrews. The plantation is under the spell of owner Peter Finch's late father whose ghost casts a pall over Elephant Walk that becomes a major point of contention between Taylor and Finch. The elephants are determined to reclaim their traditional path to water that was blocked when the mansion was built across their right-of-way. The beasts go on a rampage and provides the best moments of action in the picture. Taylor and Andrews have some good moments as she struggles to remain a faithful wife in spite of he marital difficulties with Finch.
19 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Spectacle, melodrama and elephants
T_Side18 June 2017
ELEPHANT WALK's plot is essentially that of Daphne Du Maurier's REBECCA. Elizabeth Taylor plays a new bride, plucked from London to be the mistress of an enormous tea plantation in Ceylon (modern day Sri Lanka). Her husband, Peter Finch, blends into his old role as plantation Governor, in thrall to his dead father and the influence of his colonialist friends. The nights are spent drinking to excess as Taylor simmers in the bedroom, wearing a series of alluring nightgowns to be appreciated by nobody... Nobody, that is, apart from Dana Andrews's jaded plantation manager, destined to be the third point in the film's love triangle.

Taylor is a fish out of water in her massive new home, the palatial Elephant Walk, so called because it was built by Finch's father right in the path of the route the elephants took to reach water. The symbolism here should be clear enough. The elephants want their path back and are stopped in their attempts by Finch's army of retainers, until a bout of cholera cuts down their numbers... Finch has a Mrs Danvers style manservant, who worships the old Governor as though he's still alive, not remembered a little too closely via his ostentatious mausoleum in the garden and his old study, which is locked at all times.

Finch is fine as the boozy, weak willed lead, trapped by memories of his father and drinking to forget. Andrews plays the traditionally stolid American male presence, but it's Taylor's vehicle and despite being a little miscast (she's a bit too forthright to play a demure bride) stands out through sheer force of personality. The role was initially Vivien Leigh's, and some footage of her can still be seen in several long shots; sadly ill health removed her from the project.

The film is essentially a pot-boiler, elevated by the Sri Lankan photography, the set built for the Elephant Walk 'bungalow' and a good cast, also the fact that any movie directed by William Dieterle can never really be boring. But it would have been better with Vivien Leigh, the star whose mental health problems removed her from a project that was made to fit around her. In her hands it would have been quite a different and potentially more interesting and definitely more complicated film, whereas with Ms Taylor its female presence is played straight and the script's sympathies - which really should lie with Finch's tragic daddy's boy - get lost.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
No "happily ever after" for Elizabeth Taylor at the movies
Mankin21 July 1999
Warning: Spoilers
"Elephant Walk" (***) caused me to consider once again how often during her movie career Elizabeth Taylor fell in love with men she lost or who rejected her. She spends most of "Cat on a Hot Tin Roof" (1958) begging an apathetic Paul Newman to sleep with her. In "Suddenly Last Summer" (1959), her cousin Sebastian is more interested in the local peasant boys than in her. In "Raintree County" (1957) she has to fake a pregnancy in order to get Montgomery Clift to marry her. In "Place In the Sun" she loses Clift to the electric chair. In "Night Watch" (1974) she discovers that hubby Laurence Harvey is having an affair with another woman. In "Elephant Walk" she spends her wedding night alone because her husband, played by Peter Finch, would rather carouse with his drinking buddies. I guess being one of the most beautiful women in the world doesn't mean you will be lucky in love - certainly not in Elizabeth Taylor's case, either on or off the screen. The film itself is an enjoyably over-the-top melodrama with a splendid production, a fine score by Franz Waxman and that famous elephant stampede at the end to top it off. Of course, one can't help wondering why Finch's father would insist on building a house right on a spot the elephants have claimed as their own. Why not, say, a mile away?
16 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
If elephants could talk . . .
charlytully5 May 2009
Warning: Spoilers
. . . or type on a computer keyboard, they'd probably give this eponymous film a rating of "10." After all, no elephants are shown being killed during the movie; it is not even implied that any are hurt. To the contrary, the master of ELEPHANT WALK, John Wiley (Peter Finch), complains that he cannot shoot any of the pachyderms--no matter how menacing--without a permit from the government (and his tone suggests such permits are not within the realm of probability). Furthermore, the elements conspire--in the form of an unusual drought and a human cholera epidemic--to leave the Wiley plantation house vulnerable to total destruction by the Elephant People (as the natives dub them) to close the story. If you happen to see the current release EARTH, you'll detect the Elephant People are faring less well today.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Not great, but pretty entertaining...and Liz Taylor is stunning
vincentlynch-moonoi18 July 2012
Warning: Spoilers
I'm not a particular fan of Elizabeth Taylor, although that's not to say I didn't like her performances. And, in my view, it was the first half of the 1950s (when this film was made) in which she did her most pleasing work. I have to say that at this point in her life, she was extremely beautiful.

One of the interesting things about this film is that it originally starred Vivien Leigh, who had to drop out due to her bi-polar disorder. Taylor was a substitute, and I think a very good one. Some scenes, although not the ones with Taylor, were filmed in Sri Lanka. When the film was mostly re-shot with Taylor, her segments were filmed in Hollywood. There are a few scenes where, from a distance, you can see Vivian Leigh...particularly the beginning of the scene at the Buddhist temple. Some of the on-location scenes are quite stunning, and you get a glimpse of a real tea plantation.

Peter Finch is very good in this film. You're not supposed to like him too much, and he played that just right. Taylor is exquisite. Perhaps better than Finch's role is that of Dana Andrews (who completes the triangle); Andrews is a much underrated actor, possibly due to problems with alcohol.

I like this story -- a marriage between two people who have lived very different lives, and then the jungle and another man come in between them. My only criticism is the scene where the elephants tear down and set fire to the mansion...not as convincing as the rest of the film. But this is definitely worth a watch, although it may not end up on your DVD shelf. The print shown on TCM is nicely restored.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Watchable by Anyone with a Taste for Fifties Melodrama
JamesHitchcock14 June 2022
The story is set in the years immediately after the end of World War II. John Wiley, a tea planter from Ceylon, as Sri Lanka was then called, meets a young woman named Ruth on visit England. The two fall in love, marry and move back to John's plantation, Elephant Walk, so named because it was built across a migration route used by a local herd of wild elephants to get to water. The elephants, in fact, still try to use the route, and have to be kept out by a wall or frightened away by occasional gunshots.

Ruth and John face several problems in their marriage. She feels lonely because she is the only white woman in the district. John's elderly Ceylonese servant Appuhamy takes a dislike to her, which matters because John often takes the experienced older man's advice. She in turn takes a dislike a group of white men, all of them bachelors, who regularly call at John's bungalow where their main occupations are getting drunk and playing rowdy games of indoor bicycle polo. (In Britain itself, the word "bungalow" has come to mean a modest single-storey dwelling, but in colonial usage it could also be used to mean a plantation owner's mansion, which might have two storeys, as John's indeed does). John calls these men his friends, but Ruth believes that they are parasites who are exploiting his hospitality for the sake of the alcohol he gives them.

Worst of all, John refuses to countenance any changes in the running of the plantation; he is dominated by the memory of his late father Tom, who died several years earlier, and believes that everything must be done as it was in the old man's day. Tom's study is preserved as a shrine which Ruth is forbidden to enter. Ruth feels that she is falling out of love with John, and finds herself attracted to his American manager Dick Carver.

The original intention was to have the roles of John and Ruth played by Laurence Olivier and Vivien Leigh, who were of course husband and wife in real life. Olivier was committed to other projects, but Leigh was cast opposite Peter Finch. She began filming in on location in Ceylon but had to withdraw for health reasons, being replaced by Elizabeth Taylor. I cannot help thinking that the film would have been very different had it been completed with Leigh. Finch was sixteen years older than Taylor, and the film that we have is in many ways a standard older man/younger woman romance of the sort that was so popular in the fifties. Leigh, however, was actually four years older than Finch, and had Ruth been played as a middle-aged woman rather than a young girl the relationship between the two main characters would have been altered.

There are obvious similarities between "Elephant Walk" and the Charlton Heston/Eleanor Parker vehicle "The Naked Jungle", also from 1954. Both films have at their centre a plantation owner who marries a wife who finds it difficult to fit into plantation life, leading to tensions in their marriage. (In "The Naked Jungle" the main character is American and owns a rubber plantation in South America). In both films the plantation is threatened by a seemingly unstoppable force of nature, the elephants here and an army of ants in the other movie. And the two films are similar in terms of quality. In neither case is the film its stars' greatest triumph; Heston and Parker made many films that were better than "The Naked Jungle", just as Finch and Taylor appeared in many better than this one. This does not mean, however, that either film is a bad one. Like "The Naked Jungle", "Elephant Walk" was popular with audiences in its day, and continues to be watchable today, at least by anyone with a taste for fifties melodrama. 6/10.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Quite an excellent movie
LaDonnaKeskes13 March 2010
Warning: Spoilers
I was prepared for a turgid talky soap opera cum travelogue, but was pleased to find a fast-paced script, an underlying moral, excellent portrayals from all the actors, especially Peter Finch, amazing special effects, suspense, and beautiful cinematography--there's even a shot of the majestic stone Buddhas recently destroyed by the Taliban. Not to mention Elizabeth Taylor at her most gloriously beautiful and sympathetic, before she gave in to the gaspy hysterics that marred her later work. All the supporting players round it out, and I do wonder who trained all those elephants.

Speaking of the stone-Buddha sequence, you really can discern that it's Vivien Leigh in the long shots. Her shape and the way she moves is distinct from Taylor's. The only thing marring that sequence are the poorly done process shots, where the background moves by much too fast for horses at a walk.

If you want a thought-provoking film that is beautiful to watch and never boring, spend a few hours with Elephant Walk.
8 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
not to be confused with the baby elephant version
myriamlenys8 May 2019
Warning: Spoilers
A blushing bride follows her husband to Ceylon, where he owns a vast tea plantation. Upon her arrival, the bride discovers that her husband is indeed richer than Cresus. She also discovers she is going to live in a palatial mansion. So far the good news, but there is also bad news. The mansion was built by her late father-in-law, an egomaniac of rare ambition. He knowingly and deliberately erected the building in the middle of an ancestral route followed by elephants...

Viewed as a drama about the relationship troubles of a young couple, "Elephant Walk" isn't all that interesting : it is a slice of shallow melodrama. I'm afraid that the character of the young bride rubbed me the wrong way, since I don't like people rushing into marriage without studying their prospective partner closely. Here it is obvious that Ruth - because that's her name - couldn't be bothered to ask even the most basic questions, such as "Are both of your parents alive ?", "How do you remember your father ?" and "How do you spend your days ?". Listen, if even she doesn't care about the family, the lifestyle and the soul of her spouse, why should we ?

The movie works better, indeed it works very well, as a richly exotic adventure movie set in Ceylon. The scenery is to die for and there's a thumping, thundering climax where the rich mansion gets flattened by an angry elephant herd. (I don't believe I'm being too spoilerish here, since this outcome could have been predicted by any reasonably astute three-years-old.) Do watch Elizabeth Taylor - or her stunt double - trying to outrun a giant stampede : it's a rare treat.

In its own way "Elephant Walk" contains a warning of great relevance : there's nothing brave, adult or wise about defying Nature. On the contrary...
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Oh Give Me A Home, Where The Elephants Roam
bkoganbing23 October 2006
Elizabeth Taylor, fresh from Chillingford-on-the-Thames, has just married Ceylonese tea planter Peter Finch and he's taken her back home. He's got quite a place over in what is now Sri Lanka, a 'bungalow' big enough to have a polo field. And that's exactly what they do there. He and his father's friends get on bicycles and play polo in the living room.

It's all tradition you know started by Finch's dad who is known to one and all as 'the Guv'nor.' He must have been something else, in everyone's memory he becomes almost a caricature of the colonial Briton.

The man must truly have been nuts or else he was one of those colonials who Noel Coward warned went out in the noon day sun a little too long. He built this palatial estate right on a well worn path that the elephants use to get to fresh water when the streams dry up in their neck of the woods. The local natives have to periodically ward them off with noise. They can't kill them because of the strict conservation laws and the Buddhist tradition.

Maybe I missed something here, but did he have to build the house right there? Does make for a spectacular climax though.

Peter Finch feels the need to keep traditions up and all the friends come over every week, get stinking drunk, and play bicycle polo in the living room. Not exactly the home Liz had in mind. She seeks some solace with overseer Dana Andrews who being American is not into all the colonial British traditions.

Elephant Walk, which is also the name of the Finch estate, has the advantage of some really beautiful cinematography in Sri Lanka. Lends an air of realism to a rather unreal plot.

Check out Abraham Sofaer who plays the major domo of Elephant Walk with the biggest handlebar mustache on record. One that Terry-Thomas would have envied.

Vivien Leigh was supposed to do Elephant Walk, but she bowed out do to health issues. That tuberculosis did flare up at the right time though.
17 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
man versus nature
ksf-219 February 2023
Similar to the more recent "white mischief" from 1987, ruth (liz taylor) goes off to an exotic british plantation on another continent, to be with her ambitious husband. But when she arrives, the husband acts badly, and the life is nothing like she imagined. In elephant walk, hubby (peter finch, at 38) is used to staying up late, and misbehaving with his buds. What john knows, but ruth doesn't, is that the elephants are angry that their path to the spring has been blocked by the house. And hubby seems to pay more attention to his friends, his house, even his dead father than he does to his new, young wife. And drama when cholera breaks out... it brings someone back into ruth's life. Excellent performances by taylor, finch, and the house manager, played by abraham sofaer. Big adventure on another far-off, exotic, mysterious continent. Great stuff! Turner classics plays this one pretty often. Fun adventure, british empire-style. The locations show several sri lanka locations... would be interesting to really know how much was filmed there, and how much was filmed back home.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Dated But Enjoyable
Tunica12 March 2000
This is a lot of silliness about a woman from London who marries a tea planter from Ceylon whom she barely knows. It's full of cliches, and the Liz Taylor character is not believable. It has a marvelous set, some exotic location footage. It shows Taylor at the height of her beauty. She looks stunning.
7 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Why do film makers think they can write a story better than the original author?
mannbarbara7 December 2019
Warning: Spoilers
Elephant Walk was a great book about a tea planter in Ceylon who fell in love with a lovely girl in England just before the First World War. Ruth was an English girl who couldn't find a suitable husband and decided George (not John) Wylie was her last chance. She liked George who was a big, genial fellow who loved his whiskey and she believed she could make him happy. Having grown up in India, Ruth wasn't shocked at the way the men lived and she was a sensible girl, who was prepared to adapt. Taylor played her too shrewishly, but then she always sounded as if she was hysterical! Ruth's only real problem was (as in the film) the way Elephant Walk controlled George's life. However George was willing to help Ruth to make changes and was far more amenable than the way Peter Finch portrayed him. The story was really about their gradually getting to know one another and developing a liking and respect for each other. Appuhamy was similar to his film character only more interfering and Carver (in the book his name was John Geoffrey Wilding) was a user who never loved Ruth. There was so much more to this excellent book that it is a shame that Hollywood had to ruin it. Of course, the setting and the elephants were much the same and, visually, the film is beautiful, but that is the only thing I can say in its favour. Hollywood even changed the ending. The bungalow was only destroyed by one elephant, the lop-eared old bull. I can, however, heartily recommend the book.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed