Undercover Girl (1958) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
10 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
4/10
Boring B-Movie Crime Thriller
JamesHitchcock27 August 2015
When Billy Peters, an investigative journalist, is shot dead in a deserted London street, it soon transpires that the reason for his killing was that his investigations were getting too close to the reasons behind another murder, that of a wealthy playboy named Mark Buxton. This sounds like a job for Scotland Yard, but Johnny Carter, a colleague of the dead man who also happens to be his brother-in-law, starts doing his own digging, and uncovers a murky business involving Soho gangsters, blackmail and drug dealing. He also discovers another personal connection to the affair in that Peggy, the actress sister of his girlfriend Joan, has become one of the gang's victims.

The above could be the plot of a typical film noir, and some British directors, notably Carol Reed and Robert Hamer, did indeed adopt the American noir style. "Undercover Girl", however, is not really made in that style. A few night-time scenes do indeed recall expressionist noir photography, but for the most part the photography and the direction are flat and uninteresting; most scenes seem to have been shot on a single camera, without any cross-cutting, doubtless because the film was made on a very limited budget.

I assumed that a low-budget B-movie like this one would have been made for the home market only, but "Undercover Girl" was in fact also released in America where it was known as "Assignment Redhead", possibly to avoid confusion with another "Undercover Girl" made a few years earlier. Neither the British title nor the American one makes much sense; there are several girls in the movie, but none of them actually go undercover. Johnny is not given an assignment to investigate Billy's death- in fact, his editor tries to warn him off, and his investigations are all carried out on his own initiative. (The only "assignment" he receives is to photograph a Brazilian beauty queen, a character presumably introduced for the sake of younger male viewers happy to watch any film which featured, however briefly, a scantily-clad glamour girl). As for "redhead", the film is made in black-and-white, so we cannot tell if any of the characters are red-headed.

Both Johnny and Joan are played by Canadian actors, Paul Carpenter and Kay Callard, and I wondered if this was done to increase the film's appeal in the American market as their accents would have sounded more familiar to American ears. Joan and Peggy are supposed to be sisters, but nobody seems to have noticed that their accents do not match. Or, if somebody did notice, they did not care enough to do anything about it. Peggy is played by Jackie Collins, who at this period was trying to follow her sister Joan into the acting profession, but if this film is anything to go by Jackie did not share her elder sibling's dramatic talents and was wise to move into the literary world.

To be fair to Jackie, nobody else in the film displays much in the way of dramatic talent either. Admittedly, B-movie crime dramas were not generally noted for Oscar-class acting, but they did occasionally feature rising stars on their way up; Joan Collins herself, for example, had made a couple in the early fifties. Nobody involved here, however, appears to have gone on to greater things. Banal direction and run-of- the-mill acting are not the film's only weaknesses; the sets are drab and boring and the plot can be difficult to follow. The running time is only 68 minutes, but somehow it seemed much longer. "Undercover Girl" still occasionally turns up on British television, but I cannot say it is still worth watching. 4/10
12 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Pedestrian crime film with familiar ingredients
wilvram29 May 2012
Some confusion exists over UNDERCOVER GIRL, as it was released in the US under the equally meaningless title ASSIGNMENT REDHEAD. This happened to be the name of another British crime film, made the previous year and known in the US as MILLION DOLLAR MANHUNT, thus leading to credits for the two productions getting muddled on occasions.

Here, regular 'B' lead Paul Carpenter plays a photographer taking over the investigation into a shady nightclub owner, whom, he believes, is responsible for his reporter brother-in-law's murder. He works for the kind of magazine that mixes glamour photos with articles "lifting the lid off Soho" and exposing gambling rackets - "what goes on behind the net curtains". So much for the supposedly sedate Britain of 1957. Meanwhile Carpenter's girlfriend Kay Callard is concerned about sister Jackie Collins who's also involved with the vicious club owner/gangster, played by Bruce Seton, best known at the time for his portrayal of that exemplar of 1950s law and order, Fabian of the Yard.

Carpenter uncovers a blackmail racket and drug pushing, centred on a dodgy nursing home, but, flatly presented and directed, it's not as interesting as it sounds. Obviously made on a low budget, time is padded out with Carpenter taking photos of Maya Koumani as 'Miss Brazil' while the background score of Bill Trytel further reinforces the resemblance to the kind of 1930s quota quickie of which he was a veteran. As an actress, Jackie Collins doesn't do badly, though inevitably, is more memorable for her sensational figure.
11 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Take a Butchers at this
malcolmgsw17 September 2015
Yes a typical Butchers B film from the 1950s.It moves at quite a pace particularly in the last reel.Though the title left me a bit bewildered since there is really no undercover girl in the film.The film centres around Bruce Set on a club owner who has a lifeline in blackmail and murder.Unusual to see Set on as a crook.He was to play Fabian of the yard,and lived to regret it.It typefaces him and all but ruined his career.Although essentially a British B film it was clearly made with the American market in mind.There can be no other explanation for the inordinate amount of gun play around at the end.The film is no great shakes but passes a reasonable hour.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A rather not boring British thriller
searchanddestroy-11 February 2009
Warning: Spoilers
One perfect example of Butcher's films. The little company which produced so many B thrillers in UK during the 50's and early 60's. Not masterpieces but good crime or drama features. The topics are, in most cases, all the same. In this little film, for instance, nothing really unusual. A guy whose brother in law - his sister's husband - has been murdered. Our hero - I don't remember the actor's name - investigates and discovers that his brother in law was the victim of a racket. Accident racket and blackmail. From that, all we see is foreseeable: gals, big boss, henchmen with hang dog looks, some fights and so on...

The ending, you smell it several miles in advance.

No more comment.

I took it from ITV, Thames. So, maybe you can try for it too.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Carpenter on the prowl
Prismark106 October 2018
Undercover is a cheap B film filler with film noir intentions. Johnny Carpenter, an American journalist in London. He sets out to find why his brother in law, Billy Peters, also a journalist was killed.

Carpenter finds a bunch of gangsters running scams such as extorting people who would be involved in set up accidents after they were drugged and allegedly ran over an elderly gentleman in a drugged state. They are also involved in drug dealing as well.

There is nothing too involving or exciting here. A lot of the scenes have interior settings. There is a pointless photo shoot involving a beautiful model. Author Jackie Collins has an early acting role who plays the sister of Carpenter's girlfriend and is also mixed up with the gangsters.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Well, It's A Story
boblipton10 April 2023
When his brother-in-law is killed, two-fisted magazine photographer Paul Carpenter goes looking for the guy who did it. His quest leads him to a hit-and-run racket, combined with blackmail, as well as a bevy of beautiful birds, including Kay Callard, Monica Grey, Jackie Collins and Maya Koumani (whose character name is "Miss Brazil").

For a cheap Butchers' second feature, it's an unpretentious, amusing little film, directed by Francis Searle. Searle was one of those British directors who directed cheap movies, mostly thrillers, and brought them in on budget, about a good as his mediocre scripts and short budgets would let him. Here's one where no one seems to have take it very seriously, and it works better for it. The result is a pleasant time-waster.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
The Buxton Case
richardchatten28 July 2020
Despite the title, the sleuthing is nearly all in the hands of 'B' movie stalwart Paul Carpenter in this talky (and in places sloppily post-synced) little period piece set in cheap-looking 'luxury' apartments which matter of factly breezes through a tawdry plot involving murder and narcotics. (It was only when Maya Koumani turned up as 'Miss Brazil', sporting a tight shiny dress and a phony foreign accent that I realised that I'd actually seen this tinny little quickie on Central Television about twenty five years ago; which shows how memorable it all was.)

Sometimes interestingly lit by Jimmy Harvey, the mood music provided by Twickenham Films veteran Bill Trytel occasionally livens things up, and the women naturally all look awesome in the fifties style; although the amount of drinking & smoking shows that it's not just the snazzy threads that 'Mad Men' got right!
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Undercover Girl
CinemaSerf16 April 2023
Enthusiastic photographer "Carter" (Paul Carpenter) is determined to investigate a dodgy nightclub owner whom he thinks is behind the killing of his brother-in-law. Meantime, his gal "Joan" (Kay Callard) is concerned that her naive and innocent sister "Peggy" (Jackie Collins - yep, that one!) is getting herself too closely entangled with this self same hood - "Ted" (Bruce Seton). Before long, "Carter" is knee-deep in a blackmailing and drug-running racket but can he get to the bottom of things before he, too, goes the way of the dodo? The story is actually a little more sophisticated than the routine - faking accidents to extort cash and to coerce the victims into helping with their lucrative peddling, but the dialogue is way too plentiful and there is a lot of padding - especially the scenes with the "Miss Brazil" (Maya Koumani) that rips the pace out of the film quite successfully. Seton really doesn't engender the slightest sense of malice - though maybe that's because he has been in so many of these B-features that his face is synonymous with just about every role you'd care to mention, and that does impact on the potency of his characterisations. It ends as you'd expect and is entirely forgettable stuff, sorry.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Middling Brit B noir, annoying score, unremarkable ladies
adrianovasconcelos23 April 2023
Highly prolific British Director Francis Searle has under his belt some noteworthy B films like CLOUDBURST or WHISPERING SMITH HITS LONDON, but he cannot hide poor form in UNDERCOVER GIRL.

Incidentally, I am at a loss as to this title. There is no undercover police or other girl, most of the girls who appear in the film appear to be under life threat or close, so why anyone in that situation should be foolish enough to go undercover into the vipers' nest would be tough to fathom.

The ludicrous and deceitful title aside, Paul Carpenter drives a nail in the film's coffin by posting a performance mediocre enough to match those of Kay Callard, Jackie Collins or Monica Grey. In fact, the only female who grabbed my attention was "Miss Brazil", alluringly played by Maya Koumani but a completely unnecessary role in the plot.

Bruce Seton steals the show in the small part of criminal king pin Ted Austin, even if his final fisticuff against Carpenter leaves much to be believed, beginning with the fact that he could have shot Carpenter dead and settled the issue without exposing himself to a punchup.

Dull cinematography by Geoffrey Faithfull, even duller score by Trytel, to match the dull script by Bernard Lewis.

Though only 69' long, UNDERCOVER GIRL is an out and out waste of time.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Solid thrills with the dependable Paul Carpenter
Leofwine_draca4 September 2016
Warning: Spoilers
UNDERCOVER GIRL is another British B-picture with a crime story and lead role for Canadian star Paul Carpenter. Carpenter plays a slightly washed up photographer working on a local newspaper who becomes rather peeved when his brother in law is murdered by persons unknown. With the police slow to act he decides to investigate the mystery himself and soon uncovers a sinister blackmail plot centred around a strange nursing home.

It's predictable stuff indeed but nonetheless a film which gets by with a certain finesse and features all of the right elements in the right order. A short running time and snappy pacing means that this is a never less than engaging thriller. Carpenter is a more than dependable leading man and second only to John Bentley in the sheer number of appearances he made in British B-thrillers during the 1950s. UNDERCOVER GIRL is a dodgy title because no girl in the film goes undercover, although the American re-titling of ASSIGNMENT REDHEAD is equally invalid and anyway had already been used for a film made the previous year.

The film is particularly strong for its female characters, principal of whom is the lovely Kay Callard who looks very arresting with blonde hair. Maya Koumani has a memorable cameo as a buxom model in one randomly inserted moment, although the most notable of all is Jackie Collins as a blackmail victim. Bruce Seton was best known on TV and in film for playing detectives but makes a very good fist of the master villain here. Watch out for B-movie favourite Milton Reid in an early role as a hired thug complete with goatee beard. This is one of the best films I've seen from cheapie director Francis Searle.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed