Guns of a Stranger (1973) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
"Well I was kinda wonderin' if..., do you care if I call you the drifter?"
classicsoncall13 September 2016
Warning: Spoilers
Here's a Western that would have been right at home as one of Gene Autry's flicks back in the Forties, but done in the Seventies with singer Marty Robbins in the lead role. It's not a particularly good one, filled with inconsistencies and a decided lack of acting ability by any of the principals. Except for Chill Wills, I haven't seen any of the players in any other picture, so perhaps that would explain the acting deficit; Dovie Beams as Virginia was particularly lifeless. Taking a quick look at her bio on IMDb I was stunned by the mention of an affair she once had with a famous, former world leader. Check it out, I'm still shaking my head over it.

If you read the short description of the story on it's title page here, you'll note that Sheriff Matthew Roberts (Marty Robbins) was 'torn by inner anguish' after killing a rowdy gunslinger to open the story. Giving up his badge, he became a drifter of sorts, winding up in the small town of Fargo Springs. How the 'inner anguish' plays into his character is kind of questionable to my mind. That transition was never explained reasonably after Roberts gave up his job as sheriff, but even more so, he didn't seem to be conflicted with much concern after shooting three outlaws in the back over the rest of the story.

All the while as Matthews settles in and begins working at the Duncan Ranch, I kept wondering when the wardrobe department would outfit Miss Virginia with a different dress than the blue print she wore for most of the picture, day after day it seemed like. They must have figured it out after a while because she finally got to wear a couple different outfits before the picture ended. If you notice early in the story when Matthews first arrived, a breakfast scene seemed to place an awful lot of emphasis on Virginia's baking ability - "Your sister's biscuits are the best in the world". I think they tried a little too hard working that biscuit angle, I got it the first time.

With Marty Robbins' success at being a top flight country singer, it probably made sense to star him in an oater like this, but it would have helped a lot if the writing was better and the supporting players more up to the task. Even the arrangement of the songs seemed haphazard, they weren't spaced well throughout the picture with three tunes offered almost one right after another but in different settings. Then when they paired him up in a boxing match against a dubious Western champeen, I gave up on any semblance of a rational story.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
All Right, Be A Stranger
boblipton28 November 2019
Marty Robbins shows up to help Chill Wills and his grand daughter, Dovie Beams, keep their ranch, despite the local land baron, his henchmen and the local banker.

It has all the earmarks of a vanity project for singer-songwriter Robbins, who sings the title song and about the one-hour mark, starts to sing a few songs in concert with his henchmen. Wills is there to attract the B-western fans in the audience, but his ability to speak a line makes everyone else look poor. Despite some attractive shooting locations -- Old Tucson, the Superstition Mountains area -- Donald H. Birnkrant shoots the actors, most of whom aren't worth it.

Robbins had a long and successful career in music, but trying to make a B western star of him in the 1970s was a futile and ridiculous effort.
1 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Super singer but not an actor
davidcorne2459 January 2006
Marty Robbins was a great singer who was gifted with one of the greatest voices to ever grace any kind of music. He made a few films but most are just vehicles for his singing. This has him in a western role and is O.K. as long as you don't expect 'Shane' 'High Noon' or 'The Wild Bunch.' It was made in the 70's when sadly the western was in decline and would have probably gone down better in the 40's or 50's. Decidedly better than his other western movie 'Ballad of a Gunfighter'which must have had a budget of about 30 dollars and probably took as much at the box office. Marty's fans however will treasure having any movie by their man.
15 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed