Italianamerican (1974) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
12 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Family
jzappa10 December 2009
The beginning of Martin Scorsese's career had much to do with his urge to portray the Italian-American Roman Catholic experience. Who's That Knocking at My Door and Mean Streets, for instance, are not just films about low-level hoods getting into trouble but on a more profound level dealing with the virtually reflexive affectations born out of their culture, heritage and masculinity complexes. One can see these movies over and over again and discover an undertone never before realized, because is not just Scorsese's interest in the subject but his lifelong saturation in it that gave them such endless dimensions and jittery spirit. Italianamerican, shot after returning from Hollywood to rediscover his ethnic roots, whether or not this home movie of sorts has the same vibrancy or histrionics as the director's features, is the last necessary word on the subject. Any vagueness in imagining the look and feel of the Italian-American middle-class Roman Catholic existence will be enriched by this 50-minute homemade doc.

The Scorseses talk about their experiences as Italian immigrants in New York among other things, while having dinner at their flat on Elizabeth Street. It is purely incidental that Scorsese's father Charles is quiet much of the time, guarded, slowly growing comfortable with the camera, while mother Catherine is with no trouble at all completely her zestful self. Just as if the director had taken us along while visiting his parents, they discuss, with little apparent preparation, the family's origins, their ancestors, life in post-war Italy and the burdens of poor Sicilian immigrants in America struggling to acquire livelihood and earn enough to support their families. She also instructs how to cook her meatballs. If you misunderstand her instruction at all, don't worry; the recipe's in the credits.

Italianamerican is very, well, easy, but it's one of the most endearing things a director has ever done. He shares his parents with us, his old home, the stories that brought him here. The quirks of his parents remind us of those of our own parents. It is pleasant just simply to watch two people who are never afraid to pick a fight with each other, have their many clashing opinions and have learned to let it all slide, to live with each other in peace. Their hostility is not hostility to them; it's just how they talk to each other.
15 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Real Italians caught on film!
caspian197819 November 2003
I got to see a clip of this documentary when Martin Scorsese came to Providence, Rhode Island to accept an award on behalf of Brown University. We got to see a small clip from every directed film that Scorsese had made in his 40 plus year career. Out of all the films, Italianamerican got the biggest laughs and the longest applause. Having been the only Italian and the only person who did not attend Brown University that got into Brown's auditorium (the security was terrible) to see Scorsese, I enjoyed the realism that Scorsese captured by watching his parents be themselves in front of the camera. All the other Irish people who attended the event enjoyed the film as well, but not as much as me.
16 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Every single Italian has to see Dis
dollfactory6 December 2022
I absolutely love this DOCUMENTARY!! They spoke just like Italian people talk if you were brought up like this you will totally understand why you are the way you are They were just like my grandparents. Listening to them tell stories brought me back to the days I miss so much I could watch them for hours. I would listen to my aunts and uncles talk for hours (drinking wine and espresso)telling these stories never ending stories .. The stories were intriguing. I really felt like I belonged in this family. There's something about Marty's Mom and Dad that relaxing they can be your own parents what a gift I stumbled across.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
the most 'home movie' of Scorsese's documentaries
Quinoa198412 August 2005
Like someone opening up a family scrapbook or putting on a video from footage you haven't seen in years, Italian/American is Martin Scorsese's personal look at his family, most particularly his parents Catherine and Charlie. Both have had memorable bits in his films (Goodfellas being their prime, as Catherine was Pesci's mother and Charlie the onion-cooking prisoner in jail), but are also willing to be on-screen for a kind of personal inquisition from Martin about the family's history. We learn about the ancestry of the Scorseses, on both sides, and how this influence came into the family. At times, strangely in such a short amount of time, the 'home video' factor is actually a little boring, as it would be in real life. Yet a fascination remains with these people, and the director's own deep interest in it (he references the family's history as well in My Voyage to Italy). A highlight actually occurs in the end, as Catherine offers up her recipe for tomato sauce! For Scorsese die-hards a must-see; a curiosity for anyone else interested.
18 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A film that Scorseses detractors-and admirers-should play close attention to.
coop-1625 March 2003
I recently read a pretty vicious attack on Scorsese in an excellent evangelical periodical, Books and Culture. It claimed Scorsese is, in a word, bloodthirsty, and still a street punk at heart.Granted, Scorsese has done his share of bloody films, but the violence which obsesses him isn't PHYSICAL, its emotional. In addition, Scorsese isnt simply obsessed with blood..hes obsessed with honor, tradition,and family. A clue to the shallowness of this critique of Scorsese could be found in the fact that the author actually thought Age of Innocence was just a studio assignment,which Scorsese agreed to do reluctantly. In fact, Scorsese obsessed over Wharton's novel for a decade after his pal, Jay Cocks, gave it to him. Everyone of Scorseses critics should watch this heart-felt, tender, and utterly bloodless film. I really hope he finally gets around to doing his long-planned feature film about his parents courtship,and his own boyhood in little Italy. P.S.the film also inspired me to buy The Scorsese Family cookbook!
14 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Memories!
Bolesroor7 November 2008
Martin Scorsese's "Italianamerican" is a documentary, really a home movie in which the legendary director sits down with his parents and listens to them reminisce about their experiences of growing up and coming to America.

This is a beautiful, effortless film by the greatest director of all-time. It's charming, and light-hearted, and so familiar you will be able to relate to his parents whatever your ethnic background.

As an Italian-American myself I have to admit it was like watching one of my own home movies. My grandparents were just like Charles & Catherine Scorsese... my grandmother taught me how to make sauce just like Marty's mother does in the movie. Everything about them- the look of their apartment, the way they speak and argue- made me nostalgic for my childhood days.

At one point Catherine is in the middle of relating one of her stories and you can spot Marty in the foreground picking at the leftovers in the salad bowl... film can be this low-key, this unassuming, and be just as moving as scripted studio fare.

Oh, for days gone by...
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Bittersweet
JustHavingALook28 September 2023
This is an intimate portrait of an era that doesn't exist anymore, and who knows whether it will come back ever again (at least in western countries). Personally the first generation born in the States from parents born in Italy should be the only one to be called American/Italian, the following one (Scorsese himself in this case) would "American with Italian roots", but that's just me... Anyway: touching discussion between Scorsese and his parents who, let's not forget, had some stints in the movie industry as actors. The dynamics between the father and the mother are so sweet and lovely that the bitterness of their experiences sits momentarily in the back row.

Love listening to them about who cooks better, who was working where, who couldn't speak English, having property on Staten Island (so to have small lot to grow some veggies), the long and harsh trip by boat.

Seeing Scorsese talking to them, eating at the table and organizing the shot is a pleasure. He was 28 if I'm not mistaken and ready to start working on Taxi Driver... what a time to be alive... This is a must see for not only those who scream "white privilege" (to maybe realize the world is not black and white... pun intended!) but also for aspiring filmmakers to open their eyes and see how much easier it is today to film and focus on a meaningful story, rather than spectacle.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
If you are Italian American baby boomer, you will relate to this film
wbrighenti25 September 2018
Martin's grandfather arrived in America in 1901. My grandfather arrived in 1888, during the Great Blizzard. Martin's father recalls how Italians were treated by the Irish. During the Columbus Day parades, the Irish would make fun of the Italians, ending in a huge fist fight.

Like his father's family, my parents grew up in poverty. There were large families living in small living places. My ancestors came to America to work for a $1 a day. As a hod carrier, my grandfather carried bricks and mortar up and down ladders all day, 12 hours a day, 6 days a week. Even when he was dying from prostate cancer, he had to work, pissing blood, to support the family.

Life was not a bowl of cherries, yet my parents believed in the American Dream and worked hard, saving their pennies, to provide their children with a decent life.

If you are an Italian American baby boomer, you will relate to this film.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Wish the documentary was longer
bhavyav-sridhar3 March 2020
Sweet little documentary where Catherine and Charles Scorsese casually talk old stories of their immigration, childhood, cooking..etc Random stuff. It is one of those rare pieces of work that can put it's audience in good mood and can make us appreciate little things.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Family Dynamics, Personal Issues, and the Director as "Auteur"
kidlingo2 May 2023
Scorsese still in his twenties, a grad student in the Film Studies Program at NYU, receives a grant to summarize and document the ethnic Italian community of New York. Instead of reciting statistics, he chooses to interview his mom and dad, the children of Sicilian immigrants living in Queens. Yes, they do describe their own experiences and the experiences of their immigrant parents, but what Scorsese shows us is Catherine and Charlie Scorsese, his parents, sitting on a perfectly respectable couch, cushions encased in spill-proof plastic, oversized italianate lamps, a large reproduction of stereotypical (representational) Italian art hanging on the wall behind them. The dynamic between the parents and their relationship to their son are fascinating. Mom is unembarrassed about speaking up. No fig leaves covering any of her remarks. Cajoling. Mischievous. It made me think about the theme of power struggle: there are lots and lots of power struggles in gangster films. It made me think about "the social construction of reality" both in real life and in the movies: how do you know what to believe, how isolated or enclosed are you in terms of the people you associate with, your "reference group", the people against whom you measure yourself and by whom perhaps you want to be measured and included. Did the young Marty Scorsese fulfill the mandate of the grant to create a documentary representing an entire New York ethnic group? Maybe, maybe not. Perhaps he did something more important.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Fun Doc
Michael_Elliott29 February 2008
Italianamerican (1974)

*** (out of 4)

Martin Scorsese short has him and a film crew talking with his parents about their history in America. The premise of this thing doesn't sound too interesting but Scorsese's parents are great storytellers and that keeps this 50-minute film moving quite well. Scorsese's father is very funny in his storytelling and his beliefs and without question he's the highlight.

Turner Classic Movies shows this every once in a while but you can also find it on a R2 disc but I'm not sure if that's official or not.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Grear Scorsese documentary, very personal
martinpersson9720 October 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Martin Scorsese is, of course, very well known to say the least, for his incredible feature films.

He is also, however, an incredible auteur when it comes to making interesting documentaries. And this one, unlike many of his great docs about bands, goes very personal into his upbringing, his parents and the culture of Italian-Americans.

It is lowkey, very subtle and doesn't revolve around too much but being in the moment, and the interviews and insight are very interesting. It is all around very beautifully put together in terms of both cutting and editing, and very tightlt paced.

Overall, definitely a recommended Scorsese documentary!
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed