Liberators: Fighting on Two Fronts in World War II (1992 TV Movie) User Reviews

A very important, fake documentary. Don't know how to rate.

[khydraa · 5/10 · 8 April 2014]

While totally fake (which is why it was pulled), this should be shown to everyone in the United States as a case study of memory conformity, and is a great piece of evidence against those boobs who say,

"But we know there were six trillion killed, because we have all this testimony. So many people wouldn't lie would they?"

Well in this, we see at around ~35 people, all together, either lying, or misremembering, or something. And they do it with GUSTO! They're very passionate about events we know never happened.

Whether it's a lie or a clinic on the malleability of memory, or a mixture of both, it's an excellent thing to show to people who say "holocaust because testimony and eye-witness accounts".

Shines a little light on some overlooked history

[Varlaam · 7/10 · 5 February 1999]

"My country 'tis of thee, sweet land of bigotry", E.G. McConnell puts it wryly. He's just one of the veterans in this documentary about the black soldier in combat in World War II.

If there is any individual more neglected in the coverage of the campaign in North-Western Europe than the Canadian soldier, it would have to be the black American soldier.

As we saw in "Glory", the black in the military had had to prove himself each time the U.S. had gone to war. The Second World War was no different. The soldiers had to put up with some humiliating experiences. Being ordered to wait on German POWs while training in the South was one of many.

This documentary presents the stories of quite a number of veterans, but there are two main strands. In one, Dr. Leon Bass, retired high school principal and former combat engineer, gives his story to a congregation at a synagogue in New Rochelle, New York. The other strand follows a group from the 761st Tank Battalion, the "Black Panthers", as they retrace their steps from France through Belgium to the death camp at Buchenwald which they liberated.

To me, the weakest portions of the documentary are the segments involving Dr. Bass. He is clearly giving a presentation which he has given many times before, so he tends to be melodramatic when he pauses for effect. The other vets in the story sound the way vets normally sound. They have rarely been asked their stories in detail before, so they come across as fresh and spontaneous. The tankers, in fact, are a really appealing bunch in general.

The tankers have a warm reunion dinner with Belgians they had known in 1945. They visit the Sherman tank parked in Place McAuliffe in Bastogne. They meet a Jewish camp survivor at Buchenwald. Several survivors recall gruesome stories of imprisonment and inspiring ones of liberation. An important theme in the film is to contrast the racial animosities in the States with the far worse events in Europe.

As a bonus, the film contains some great archival footage early on: Lena Horne singing with the USO, Joe Louis training with his cavalry unit, and Messman Doris Miller, awarded the Navy Cross for shooting down a couple of Japanese planes at Pearl Harbor. At one time, there was even an all-black newsreel called "All-American News".

All in all, a thoughtful and informative documentary. The narration is provided by Denzel Washington (completely recovered from his dramatic death in "Glory") with occasional assistance from Lou Gossett, Jr.

Not a true story.

[zakmurphy · 1/10 · 2 February 2012]

Since the other review opened with a quote from E.G. McConnell, I figured I'd open this one with a quote from the very same man, "It's a lie. We were nowhere near these camps when they were liberated." - E. G. McConnell. Most agree that the Holocaust was just awful and most are so very anxious to believe in stories about black heroes during WWII, most will also agree that historical fact is much more important than a sensationalized story..

This movie is fraudulent. So fraudulent, the network (WNET) pulled its name from the credits and the distribution of this film has been "supressed." If you do end up viewing this, KEEP IN MIND, the 761st Tank Battalion DI NOT liberate any camps. I'm sure that they would have.. But they did not and could not..

This film being proved fraudulent did not stop Steven Spielberg from interviewing one of the same liars that is featured in this film, Paul Parks, whose story was not changed over the years.. The only thing Spielberg had changed was what unit Paul Parks was supposedly in.

Bottomline: this is an extremely disrespectful film. Disrespecting the men who ACTUALLY liberated these camps (9th Armored Infantry Battalion of the 6th Armored Division of Patton's 3rd Army) the men, women, and children who Truly suffered, but it especially disrespects those of us who honestly want to learn the truth. Such misinformation and propaganda is harmful for victims and villains alike as the murkier the water, the more unsure are your steps.