User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
2/10
The Black Sheep of the Gilmoreverse
NSchimpf9 March 2007
Warning: Spoilers
This show was aired only once on ABC Family when GG started out its off-network run and not even considered as an extra for any of the series' DVD box sets, and there was a very good reason for it. If you're the type who cringes through reunion specials ("One Day at a Time", I'm looking at you!), this is going to make your forehead permanently wrinkle from the horrible presentation.

Mind you, this isn't a criticism of the cast at all...they did a great job on the special, all of them. But when Brooke "Wild On & Rockstar" Burke is hosting the special, you know that the producers took the term 'contractual obligation' to a new low, and produced a show that made the cast wish this off their resumes the moment it ended. A hint of the amount of money WBTV and ABC Family spent on the special is found in the producers of the show, who are more well known (or not) for producing video clip show compilations of sports injuries for TLC and other networks looking for timeslot filler.

Pretty much, before the special, Burke had never watched an episode of the series, ever, and the clips presented were the first time she had watched the show. Going off a script written by a 7th grade "Introduction to Playwriting" student, Brooke then asks the stupidest questions known to the cast, and which they've probably answered in real life at every meet-and-greet, ever. Just watching Liza Weil stare daggers at Brooke as she asks the dreaded 'Are you like Paris in real life?' question and expects an earth-shattering answer, kept my love for her as an actress and a woman very strong. Another awkward moment occurs when she asks Alexis and Keiko if they visit each other's homes all the time, a question not exactly burning in the minds of the fans, not to mention too personal for a light forum like this show. They then look at each other awkwardly and decide that the question was horribly posed, and ask Brooke to go on. Everyone looks like they'd be interviewed by an Aerie Girl instead, and the entire thing beyond the cast's answers has the feel of a very bad infomercial. Or worse; a staple of ABC Family, "The 700 Club". You half expect fake applause and Brooke leading a prayer circle any minute.

There's nothing new revealed at all about the cast, the characters, or the show in particular at all. It's a rundown of the first two seasons that can be better spent on a fansite with screencaps, clips, transcripts, and past media articles. The cast has forgotten about this horrible mess, and you should too.
15 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
An uncomfortable mess of a 'backstage special'...
popster_rox15 February 2006
Warning: Spoilers
The presenter claimed that she would 'get the scoop' on The Gilmore Girls and help fans of the show find out the inside story. All this 'backstage special' did was make me (a devoted Gilmore Girls fan) physically cringe at the presenters sickly sweet way of trying to make it sound like she actually knew anything about the show and, by the end, become extremely bored as each actor were asked the same questions. Through the presenter's manner it came across that she had only quickly watched the pilot episode 2 minutes before meeting the cast and knew little of the plot of the show past that point. Furthermore, she had an odd way of complementing the cast which was obviously awkward for both her and the actors involved. She even went as far as describing Scott Patterson as 'the hottie of the show'!

The questions asked were vague and clearly not thought through. The answers the actors would give were blindingly obvious and showed just how uncomfortable they were about being there. There were some points of interest raised such as issues relating to the complicated relationship between the three generations of the Gilmore women, but apart from that, little of 'the inside scoop' fans really wanted to hear was discussed.

This backstage special is worth watching is you are a new fan to the show and don't know much about it, but if you are a long-time fan then you should stay well away from this uncomfortable mess which really just states the obvious!

** 2/10
14 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed