Home
IMDb > Milagro de Candeal, El (2004) > IMDb user comments
Filter: Hide Spoilers:
Index 3 comments in total 

3 out of 3 people found the following comment useful :-
A beautiful documentary, 30 diciembre 2006
7/10
Author: saturno3x1 de Spain

This is in no way a commercial movie with the classical set-up of scenario, characters and scenes. It's just a documentary about Bebo Valdés traveling to San Salvador de Bahia in search of his ancestors' cultural inheritance. All the film long Bebo meets some people like Gilberto Gil, Caetano Veloso and, of course, Carlinhos Brown and his friends and neighbors at Candeal in Bahia. Nice meetings between nice people.

The film is about the effort made by Carlinhos to teach the Candeal youngsters to play drums and dance, to help their district to get over the misery, and all over the background of afro music in Bahia.

I found some dialogs quite amusing, because you can see a Brazilian character speaking Portuguese to a Cuban character who replies in Spanish, and they get on very well!

I enjoyed also the musical performances of Carlinhos and Bebo, and also the Candeal band, who have a very strong sense of rhythm.

If you are interested in Brazilian music or Yoruba culture, I'd truly recommend this film to you.

Was the above comment useful to you?

3 out of 4 people found the following comment useful :-
El milagro de Candeal, 1 mayo 2006
7/10
Author: Edgar Soberón Torchia (estorchia@gmail.com) de Panama

"El milagro de Candeal" is a documentary with simultaneous thematic lines, which are its major assets. As it progresses, these themes exclude themselves mutually, and director Fernando Trueba tries hard to integrate them.

At first, it appears as a documentary on religious syncretism: there is copious material to illustrate how a spiritual phenomenon took place in Brazil since the 1700s, combining elements of Yoruba religion with Catholicism. The film is structured around the voyage to Salvador do Bahía of famous Cuban musician Bebo Valdés, who follows the prediction made by a Cuban santera in the 1940s, and goes there to find his roots. The most beautiful sequence is the ritual in homage to Iemanjá, in which believers travelling in boats, throw flowers and wine to the sea; and the most revealing, and without any doubt the most enigmatic to an audience that has never witnessed these manifestations, is the moment when an old lady becomes the vehicle of an orixá (a deity.) But "El milagro de Candeal" is more than that: it is also a reflection on displacement: Valdés had never gone back to Cuba since his exile, and the barrio of Candeal works as the place for his reconciliation, not only with his faith, but with his origins. Since he is a notorious pianist, the musical aspect of his trip is the center. Happy music abounds in Candeal's streets (including one named after Bob Marley), at least from Trueba's point of view: that is what he mostly shows us, although one may hear, here and there, suggestions of social inequity, marginalization and racism.

The description of Candeal's community activities, of public officers, social workers and music teachers, is intense. In all moments, Valdés is a witness or an active participant. He is also a critic, as in the visit he pays to Gilberto Gil, one of the big exponents of the Brazilian new song in the late 1960s, and Ministry of Culture for Lula's government. Valdés comments that the social reforms done in Candeal, would do a lot of good to "Las Antillas" (meaning perhaps Haiti, Dominican Republic, or mainly Cuba.) In "Buena Vista Social Club", the Cuban musicians, in spite of their immense talent, were pieces of the scheme concocted by Wim Wenders and Ry Cooder, and they ended acting as such, losing part of their spontaneity. Trueba gives voice to the Candeal's dwellers, leading to the inauguration of a new plaza they build. Unfortunately, just as in "Buena Vista Social Club", the documentary becomes artificial when it centers on musician Carlinhos Brown, a key figure in the cultural rebirth of Candeal. There is even a carnival sequence with exclusive close-ups for him and the musicians and singers around him, leaving out all the crowds dressed to party, with a soundtrack that sounds prefabricated (or post-fabricated) in a studio. It is followed by something worst: the next morning, when all misery is shown without mercy by the camera. Maybe Trueba's strategy was to show life, beauty, and all that is constructive and positive in human beings, but he betrayed himself in the last moment.

In the final analysis, though, "El milagro de Candeal" is a documentary that should be seen. It is filled with so many priceless images and beautiful musical moments (including an intimate moment with Caetano Veloso singing and playing his guitar), that it is impossible to disregard it as trash.

Was the above comment useful to you?

7 out of 30 people found the following comment useful :-
Put a camera in Brazilian town, push record, and you have a film, 19 febrero 2005
Author: dutchtom1 de London

This is the umpteenth time that Fernando Trueba, a highly overrated director of movies which only exist because he survives on film-subsidies of the government. Basically Trueba goes to Brazil, puts a camera in the middle of a semi-poor area, asks some people to make music, starts recording and then goes back to Spain to show his holiday video to his 'audience'. An audience which exists mainly of people who think by saying they like Truba movies and Brazilian music from the barrio, they are good left wing intellectuals, but in fact are an arrogant bunch of ignorant followers who need someone to introduce Brazilian music to them, whereas it's so easy to discover it yourself, and better music than then the one displayed in this film. If there's any reason why the Spanish government should not pump more money into the 'directors/beggars' like Trueba, here's the proof. It's a disgrace. It's not surprising that Almodovar decided to leave the Academy, because it's made up of lazy directors like Trueba for whom film making is all about financial, and arrogance, rather than a passion to make good films. It'a terribly unoriginal documentary and definitely not a Brazilian Buena vista Social Club.

Was the above comment useful to you?

Add another comment

Related Links

Ratings Awards External reviews
Official site Plot keywords Detalles principales
Your user comments Your vote history