Dubai (2005) Poster

(2005)

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Feels dry in a squandered desert of potentials
Jay_Exiomo3 October 2005
"Dubai" is the latest movie of Star Cinema, the film outfit of one of the two leading television networks here in the Philippines; hence, expect it to be very much hyped. Expect no less than A-list Filipino stars and high-profile personalities to be asked after watching a premiere about their comments, nay, praises for the film. Yes, this movie has a lot of glamor going on for it as is always the case with its predecessors, but in more ways it doesn't deliver.

Aga Muhlach plays Raffy, an overseas Filipino worker (OFW) living in Dubai, United Arab of Emirates (UAE), and we first see him driving a pickup truck across the desert while singing along an Eraserheads song. John Lloyd Cruz is Raffy's younger brother Andrew, whom he sees after nine years. After financially supporting Andrew for some time, Raffy summons his brother there to get work and get to fulfill his dreams. You see, they grew up orphaned, had plans of migrating to Canada and sees Dubai as their ticket there. But things get awry as Andrew falls in love with fellow OFW Faye (Claudine Barretto), who turns out to be Raffy's ex-girlfriend. It seems that Raffy and Faye are still in love with each other.

To tell the truth, the film's Middle Eastern location seemed more of a ploy to feature something else other than Manila. The studio bigwigs maybe were thinking, "The OFW-driven theme worked in 'Milan,' let's do it somewhere else!" But what worked in Italy didn't work out here. Firstly, director Rory Quintos seems to drag this whole movie. Granted, slow-paced movies aren't necessarily bad, but it has to be thoughtful and should convey the slow passage of time. But "Dubai" just seems to drag on forever.

What's worse is, the film stumbles upon trying to find its identity. What exactly is this movie all about? The obvious reference would be "Milan," where the daily lives of OFWs are featured as a background to a love story. But other than hint at obvious aspects of living abroad, the issues of Filipino immigrants aren't clearly tackled. If this film, though, is all about the love story between the two brothers and a woman, why spend all that money going to Dubai, and not just film in, say, Bohol, where the scenery is also great and could've even helped the local tourism industry? But then again, the romantic side of the film isn't one of the great things here.

The script is generic (although it would be churlish to fault co-scriptwriter Ricky Lee considering that he pens MOST of the local films nowadays so it's possible he's over-stretching himself), but eventually what matters is whether it all hangs together; whether we care if these people get together or are they worth rooting for. Here, it's hard to see how anyone could care about Muhlach's character. His great love for his brother doesn't justify his reasons for being a heart-breaker. In fact, the script just seemed to completely convert his character to take the easy way out. Cruz and Barretto don't come off as convincing and there is zero chemistry between the pair, so it's hard to feel for them, much less feel the dilemma of a love triangle.

Of course there are bright points. The acting, particularly by Muhlach, is great. Barretto does a decent job, although I feel she seems uninspired here and has done better in her previous outings. Cruz can be a good actor in less serious films but here, he pales in comparison with the more seasoned leads. Nevertheless, he manages to hold his own.

The cinematography and sound design in my opinion perfectly captures Dubai, with the juxtapositions of colors and music that are used to portray this part of the United Arab Emirates perfectly in accordance with the enamor shared by the main actors.

But in the end, the actors and the scenery can't save this film. The script needs more depth and background to make the audience rooting for its characters. While "Milan" felt like a good film with a nice social commentary, "Dubai" only looks and feels costly, but never really gets to that point to make it a true wonder.
12 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
I don't see that..
sockscats16 January 2008
Warning: Spoilers
I just want to comment on the last review. The previous review said that faye went home to manila to have her child with no support from the father. There is nothing in this movie to indicate that. Andrew offered to marry her when he found out and wanted to fly back with her. His character is depicted as a hard working responsible man. Why assume no support just because they are not together? I assumed the opposite that andrew is probably sending her money.

What is missing from the film is the fact that andrew loves faye and now she that she is carrying his child she wants to live apart from him and won't marry him which for most men would be devastating in the highest degree but we don't see much of that just his anger to his brother which is unfounded.

If filipinos are presented here in a negative light it is because of the poor decisions that are made. Raffy sleeps around so faye breaks up with him even though she loves him. Faye allows herself to go out with and sleep with andrew unprotected and gets pregnant and of course andrew has all sorts of problems.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
a brother's love
newton2003200411 December 2006
Dubai is one of the few movies which made me cry, a touching film that exemplifies a brother's love. This masterpiece tells the story of two brothers who were actually torn between a girl. Their relationship is being hurdled by love and by their dreams

The cinematography is great. The film has captured the beauty of Dubai.

The story is excellent.

The actors gave noteworthy performances. Aga, here makes another remarkable performance. John Lloyd proved his worth as a dramatic actor. Claudine is also good, but this is not her best performance.

The movie received good reviews and it was actually a box-office hit.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Overrated and formulaic
peter072 May 2011
Warning: Spoilers
How many other Philippine movies have the same themes and such? It started out with a good premise -- the overseas Filipino worker in Dubai -- and just degenerated into formulaic and overplayed melodrama.

Quite a few crazy and unrealistic things happen in this film. The younger brother finally joins his older brother in the UAE, then falls in love with his older bro's part-time girlfriend. Then he gets her PREGNANT and his older brother just sits there calm and stuff. I highly doubt that any guy would just be calm, even if it was his brother.

The movie would have been more interesting had it dealt more with living in Dubai instead of the workers' personal problems. Filipinos have a tough time in the Mideast but the film dealt nothing with it.

The worst part was when the movie just becomes a tear fest of people crying, apologizing, saying saucy stuff and the like. Then the brother Raffy starts a nationalistic speech about how great it is to be Filipino. There's nothing wrong with being proud of who you are but the way he said it was very corny and awkward. Speeches like that make people forget the real problems of Philippine society -- corruption, class system, extreme poverty, runaway birth rate and others.

Screw this overrated, overdone and over-hyped movie. If you want to see a movie about the overseas Filipino worker, skip this one and try "Anak" with Vilma Santos and "Caregiver" with Sharon Cuneta.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Movie gives an excellent story!
conradz5823 June 2006
Wow! This movie gives an excellent story itself. When I first watched it, I thought this was going to be another Claudine and Aga Mulach sex scene, but the story plot is about two brothers that one brother fell in love with a woman (as Claudine), but the other brother is his girlfriend. As the movie goes by, things will get sadder and sadder, and it gets really heart-warming when it gets to the end, but that's what make this movie a special love story movie.

As far as I know, this is the first time John Lloyd Cruz has actually showed his bad temper on big screen Cinemas or TV, but he did such a great job on this movie:::even though he got into an ancident somewhere on this movie.

If you think the plot is too sexual or too mind-blowing for you, well it isn't.....Try out the movie today, and enjoy the film and make some waterworks somewhere in the movie.....Just kidding!
0 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
its not Milan
charambo12 June 2007
Following the success of Milan, which was a very good film, the producers thought they would make a similar film based in Dubai. Wrong. Two brothers fall in love with the same girl.( played by Aga Muhlach and John Lloyd Cruz ). The girl is Claudine Barretto a very good actress. so, whats the problem with the film. the story is a basic love triangle film, with beautiful locations. The second fault is the ending. The girl really loves one of the brothers but gets pregnant with the other brother, so far so good. The brothers argue at some point. the girl can't take it any more and goes back to the Philippines, heavy with child. The brothers then get back together, and the older one gets to go to Canada, and the younger one ( who is also the father of the unborn child ) remains in Dubai. A happy ending. Come on guys. Filipinoes go abroad to make money for their families. This girl goes back home with no support from the father, and he does not seem to care. Is that the way Star Cinema wants to portray the Filipino abroad. Whatever was gained in Milan was lost in Dubai.

The film also makes out that life in Dubai is great, well believe you me it isn't, ask any Filipina.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed