En el hoyo (I) (2006) User Reviews

A wonderful rumination on man's relationship to work

[tclark-5 · 8/10 · 2 August 2006]

I was fortunate enough to see En El Hoyo at a Melbourne International Film Festival screening and was delighted by this distinctive and artful piece of film-making.

Following the lives of a number of road-workers during the construction of a gargantuan bridge in Mexico City, the film follows a fairly loose narrative structure, but does what all good documentaries should do by helping us to understand why its subjects are the way they are. Rulfo offers us a mosaic of these people's lives, helping us to come to terms with the spiritual, political and psychological motivations behind their behaviour. While they remain in many ways enigmatic, particularly the wonderful Shorty, we are always connected to them because of Rulfo's skillful inclusion of humour and powerful visual sense.

And it never devolves into a simplistic political statement about their situation. They are there because they have a need to put food on the table, just like everyone else. Their job may be more physically demanding than most, but they never become martyrs or victims. Their strength is as palpable as their quiet desperation.

The final shot of the film, a sweeping five-minute (or more?) aerial shot traversing the full length of the bridge is quite overwhelming, highlighting the universality of the film's comments about work and the way we deal with it. I would certainly recommend seeing this film on the big screen to be able to absorb its full power.

honoring the working man

[Buddy-51 · 7/10 · 28 February 2008]

Based on the title alone, one might assume that "In the Pit" was a behind-the-scenes look at the fast-and-furious world of NASCAR racing. In actuality, it's a modestly-scaled documentary about the building of a massive freeway overpass in highly congested Mexico City. The "stars" of Juan Carlos Rulfo's film are the unheralded common workers without whose backbreaking labor - often performed at great risk to their lives and persons - such public-works projects could never be completed.

"In the Pit" is a paean to all the blue-collar folk who generally receive scant recognition from either the movie industry or society as a whole for the important work they do. Rulfo provides no voice-over narration, instead allowing the men to relate their life stories wholly in their own words. They talk not only about their work but their outside lives and interests, occasionally launching into reflective commentary on life, love, poverty, religion, the state of the world in general and life in Mexico in particular (the irony is that, in the two-tiered economic system in which they live, many of the men who had a hand in building the bridge will never have occasion to use it). But most of the time we see them simply going about their daily activities on the job, good-naturedly ribbing one another as only a tight-knit group of experience-sharing buddies can do. Rulfo obviously has a great deal of affection for these people, yet he neither romanticizes nor sentimentalizes them or their plight; they are always just ordinary guys trying to make their way in the world with as much honesty and dignity as their situation will bear.

Rulfo ends his film on a bravura high note of movie-making skill: a stunning six-minute-long helicopter shot that swoops along the length of the freeway barely above the heads of the waving workers. Beyond its own aesthetic value, the shot drives home the sheer technological impressiveness of what these hardworking, largely "uneducated" gentlemen have been able to accomplish - and the legacy they will have left behind.

construction as part of our lives

[lee_eisenberg · 9/10 · 1 January 2008]

I had never heard of "En el hoyo" (called "In the Pit" in English) when I turned it on. It sure impressed me. Focusing on some construction men working on an enormous freeway in Mexico City, the documentary really hits you. It shows how these men do this so as to support their families, but always maintain their sanity and, above all, a sense of humor (one man entertains himself by looking up the dresses of women in passing cars). The men talk about terrible things happening in the building process, but understand that this is their only option.

It's worth noting that this documentary is not a polemic. It shows a grim topic while letting the audience make their own decisions. The end shows one long shot of the freeway, forcing the audience to wonder something: given what the interviewees talked about, how often have similar things happened during the erection of this thing? Not to mention that Mexico City's already foul air will probably get even worse with more freeways.

Anyway, I recommend it.

Slow start, wonderful finish

[akdubois-34734 · 10/10 · 26 June 2016]

This is what a documentary should be. Don't give up on it if you feel like it's too slow at the beginning— there is such a rewarding pay-off. This is a timely film right now with all the contention about immigration and refugees in the world. You'll get to know a handful of constructions workers making an elevated highway in Mexico city, but you feel like every stranger you see after this has a very rich and hidden life. This is the reality for so much of the world, and it worth realizing if you are one of the privileged ones living in the US or Wester Europe. Juan Carlos Rulfo clearly got to know these people very well, and cares about them a great deal. So will you.