"Battlestar Galactica" Greetings from Earth (TV Episode 1979) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Despite A Number of Flaws, the Episode Works for the Most Part
spasek5 November 2022
Warning: Spoilers
I still remember seeing this episode when it first aired. It was a two-hour special and went well beyond my bedtime as a 7-year-old kid. Knowing how much the show meant to me, my father made a consolation that I could see the episode if I went to bed early, and then he'd wake me up.

Knowing that the Galactica's mission was to find earth, everyone was in a tizzy, hoping that the Galactica had finally succeeded. I was also pleasantly surprised to see Randolph Mantooth in the episode, as he was my favorite character on the show, "Emergency!"

Starbuck and Apollo come across a ship in deep space and tow it back to the Galactica. Of course, everyone believes that it might be their first contact with an Earth vehicle.

They discover a couple and four children on board. Of course, they are dressed in silver spacesuits, which they continue to wear even after landing on Paradeen. I guess there weren't any other clothes for them.

The first half of the episode is a moral debate on whether the family should be condemned to live out their lives in cryogen tubes, since the Galactica's atmosphere is incompatible for them. The Council of the 12--which quickly becomes more of a source of problems--is eager to get answers about the family and where they are from. We also get another episode with an over-emotional Apollo chewing out everyone who doesn't agree with his position.

The second half of the episode has Apollo and Starbuck following the shuttle to the planet Paradeen, where they eagerly hope to find information about the planets Terra and Lunar 7. Of course, there is resistance due to the threat of the Eastern Alliance.

We also have a very strange subplot that never really worked in which Sarah suddenly takes a romantic interest in Apollo. I always found it strange that Apollo never bothers to tell her that he's got a son waiting for him. Instead, he enlists Cassiopeia to show an interest in Michael with the hopes of making Sarah jealous.

Unfortunately, the second half of this episode isn't quite as strong as the first, as it feels as though it was put together piece-meal with many problems with the plot. Starbuck insisting on going into the catacombs despite Hector's warning. If there was a portable oxygen supply, why not get it first? Starbuck is impulsive, but he's not that stupid.

The end is still fun as the Commandant is shocked to see the size of the Galactica, especially when compared to his own ship, which he clearly thought was the superior force.

This isn't the best of the series by a long shot, but it's more than adequate.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Well a kids episode!
mm-396 July 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Well a kids episode! Greetings from Earth is part lost in space, space cowboys on the ranges, and space Nazis. There is a vassal intercepted, and some sci fi and a rush to a planet. Funny how B S G just does not stay on one of them tho earth like planets! But I digress. There is a soap opera love triangle, some mean space Nazis, and a mystery of a lost city. The beginning part is interesting, the middle bogged down with family love triangle, and the end has a lost city. The beginning, and ending save the middles. Watchable, but I give Greetings from Earth 6 stars. Good, acting and directed for a weaker script for the series.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Weaker episode
keyope14 February 2019
After a run of fun adventure episodes we end up with Greetings From Earth. The set up is good, a spaceship containing a family in sleep hibernation is picked up by the Galactica. Unfortunately what follows is pretty dull, and we are introduced to new villains, the Eastern Alliance, which I suppose is meant to be a subtle nod at the Nazis or the Russians. Thing is, after the Cylons, a group of blokes dressed like Nazis just doesn't really cut it. Their equipment and technology isn't as advanced as the Galactica's or the Cylons so these guys are a real step down (kind of like when Superman went from fighting General Zod, to fighting that daft Meteor Man). The Eastern Alliance subplot lasted a few episodes, none of which were any good in my opinion. This one is worth skipping.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Space Nazis! Part 2
Blueghost25 February 2013
"Greetings from Earth" deals with the ongoing trials and tribulations of the Battlestar Galactica as she plies her way through space with a ton of civilian baggage in the form of a Conestoga convoy blazing a trail through the stars to a much be-mythed world known as Earth.

"Greetings from Earth" is an episode in a children's' TV series that deals with the Galatica's first encounter with humans not of their colonies that laid seed in stars much distant from where they've come. We're shown a family of sorts who settle on a ranch, and are running from a power called "The Eastern Alliance". Apollo, Starbuck, Adama and the gang examine and re-examine the visitors they have found, what to do with them, then, once they've committed to actions, what to do next. The Galacitca has been running from a machine empire intent on annihilating humankind, so what happens when the Galactica comes across humans who have similar prejudices or a philosophy that seems to echo the worst aspects of the Cylon empire? So it is with the bad guys in this installment of the show. The "Eastern Alliance" (or whatever it's called) are, in essence, more space Nazis brought to you buy Hollywood, who forever seems to be obsessed with fascist Germany in the 30s and 40s. On the immediate level it's a good primer for kids to recognize the dangers of a kind of individual who believes their self worth to be above everyone else's, and the danger that kind of thinking can present. On another level, it's a little tiring. There are other political bad guys in the world; Joseph Stalin's Soviet Union, Idi Amin's Uganda in the 70s, Noriega's leadership of Panama, Santiago in El Salvador, the excesses of Ho Chi Mihn's red regime in Vietnam, and, more historically, Julius Caesar, Ghengis Kahn, and a host of others; including, but not limited to, the US Army dealing with native Americans in the 1800s. Yet it's the Nazis that continually get the nod, time and again, and the bad guy du jour. Well, this review is 30 years late for an editorial, but, well, here it is.

It's not a superb TV show, but has some fairly high production values which makes is entertaining on a certain level. I can't say I ever really got into the show as it did seem to be aimed at kids (the dialogue was simplified, the plots were pretty straight forward, no challenging dramatic moments...kind of a family friendly adventure in space kind of TV fair), but appreciated the energy that the TV show brought to the science fiction genre. In that regard it was a success, and I think cancelled too soon.

But this episode? Well, it is what it is. Whether it's Lucas's stormtroopers and Darth Vader Nazi helmet, or the Nazi like uniforms of the officers of the Galactic empire, then it's Galactica's Eastern Alliance's homage to the space Nazi that keeps the concept of Nazis alive as the worst enemy of all mankind.

Overall the episode is like the show which it adorns; it's okay. Take it for what it's worth.
7 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed