ER (TV Series) Motherhood (1995) User Reviews

Motherhood (#1.24)

[ComedyFan2010 · 8/10 · 26 November 2014]

Well this episode as the title says pretty much goes over different mother issues and different mothers.

For once Chloe now becomes a mom and is overwhelmed with the idea to protect her baby while her own mother doesn't ant to help taking care of her grand kid. We'll see how it will go, I am sure that big Susie will have to help taking care.

And Peter's mom dies. So this story is now over....I like how they did it. The same episode Peter had to tell a mother how her son died in the ER and they couldn't save him and then he had to hear the same about his mother. For some reason this parallel made it even more powerful. As Peter said he thought he would be more ready, based on his job, but it still hit him as hard as anyone.

watched it mostly cause it's a QT episode, his trademarks included, but still quite sharp and dramatic for regular fans

[Quinoa1984 · 10/10 · 14 September 2006]

I must confess, I'm not an avid, or even really regular, viewer of ER. A few episodes sometimes stick out that I have seen, a few really indelible images (i.e. there's one episode, which I can't totally recall, that has a woman with a bug in her ear that creeped me out intensely). But as with CSI, another show I'm not very keen on, I decided to check out a specific episode based most of all on a credited director- Quentin Tarantino in this case. Amid the big frenzy over Pulp Fiction, he got offers all over the place, and this was one of them that he took on, as he "put on the scrubs" QT himself called them, and also in a very rare case took the helm as director and not (also) as writer of the episode. This episode starts off quite intensely with, what else, a woman on the verge of delivery of her child. Right away some of that Tarantino edge comes in with the hand-held style, and while it obviously isn't there, one could guess if this weren't a network show it would be cursing galore.

The episode then unfolds with some of the character drama unfolding, but for the most part it's really focused on two things- a big helping of some head-rushing, manic hospital work on some wheeled-in-right-away patients, and on pregnancy and giving birth and such. There's even a bit of tenderness towards the latter part of the episode, which might come to be expected with the title. But those who, like me, will seek out the episode for likely QT trademarks wont be too disappointed. He does stick with the main form of the show, and if one didn't know he directed it it might be seen as usual- though above average usual- ground being covered. The hindsight does trigger some grins during the episode at the recognition of certain things, like the shots that track along (I remember there's one scene where the camera goes from one conversation to another, almost no cuts really between the two). And the aforementioned big ER scenes are a bit bloody and almost veering to the over the top. It didn't surprise me it made it on TV, but the intensity of the cuts and the action kept things going along quite well.

In short, an obscure little treat for fans of QT, and for fans of the show it provides equal doses of regular-character drama and pathos on mothering and delivery-room semantics.