"Gunsmoke" Breckinridge (TV Episode 1965) Poster

(TV Series)

(1965)

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Introducing A Very Short-lived Dodge City Resident
wdavidreynolds11 January 2021
Breck Taylor arrives in Dodge City with the intention of establishing a law practice. Shortly after he arrives, he witnesses an incident in the Long Branch Saloon where Marshal Matt Dillon has to stop a troublemaker named Sled Grady from wreaking havoc, because he has spent all his money and the bartender refuses to serve him more alcohol. When the Marshal orders Grady to leave Dodge, Taylor intervenes and begins arguing that Dillon is overstepping his authority.

Although Taylor is technically correct, he learns a lesson in frontier justice when the Circuit Judge Danby harshly chastises him for his actions.

Meanwhile, Kitty Russell fires the bartender Jocko for his lack of management in the situation with Grady in the Long Branch, which angers the man. Jocko finds Sled and encourages him to rob the saloon and even gives him detailed instructions as to how to accomplish the task.

When Sled commits the crime, he knocks out bartender Sam and kidnaps Miss Kitty. The remainder of the story involves the Marshal pursuing Grady. Since Breck Taylor feels some responsibility for Grady's actions, he convinces Matt to let him tag along.

Les Crutchfield wrote many episodes of Gunsmoke, and this is not one of his better efforts. I am not sure why the ending was written as it was when there were more plausible resolutions available.

Ben Cooper fills the role of Breck Taylor. Cooper had previously appeared in one of the outstanding episodes of the series in Season 7's "Apprentice Doc." Cooper reprises the Breck Taylor role later in Season 10 in the episode "Two Tall Men," which leads to the speculation that the character was perhaps considered as a recurring role. Burt Reynolds had departed (he would make his last appearance in the next episode "Bank Baby," but that episode was filmed earlier), and it seems clear the producers were looking for a replacement. For some reason, the Breck Taylor character did not stick, and Roger Ewing joined the regular cast as Thad Greenwood in Season 11.

Robert Sorrells appeared in 14 episodes of Gunsmoke, and I think he always played a heavy of some sort. He does a good job here in the Sled Grady role. Elisha Cook, Jr. is Jocko Beal. Cook had appeared as a "good guy" character in an earlier Season 10 episode, "Hung High," but here he is one of the antagonists. Dorothy Neumann was one of the most prolific bit-part actors of the time. She appeared in nine different Gunsmoke episodes, and many other television shows throughout the years. In this episode, she plays the "Old Woman" who has her wagon stolen by Sled. Her husband is played by Harry Harvey, who appeared in eight different Gunsmoke episodes and had parts in nearly every western television series ever made.
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Such Irony!
hoovie7018 May 2019
Richard Sorrells, the actor who played Sled and who gets 2 hours to get out of town for shooting up the Long Branch, is serving a life sentence for murder and attempted murder in a bar room fight.
9 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
How this ended was actually shameful to the viewers.
kfo94947 February 2013
This episode had the makings of being one of the better shows in a long time. Then we get an ending that is as odd and unbelievable as any I think I have seen. With such a good script, the way they ended this episode should be shown at schools and universities about how never to end a show.

The entire episode centers around a man named Sled Grady. He has come to Dodge, run out of money and then tears up the Long Branch. Matt tells Sled to leave town in two hours but there is this new guy in town named Breck Taylor that is a new energetic lawyer that thinks Marshal Dillon has overstepped his authority. Taylor gets a Judge to grant a hearing on the case and Sled is giving 24 hours to clear town.

A bartender has been fired by Kitty because of the drunk Sled incident and he wants to get back at the Long Branch. He gives Sled some information about where the money is kept in hopes that he robs the place. Indeed, Sled knocks out Sam and takes the money but was seen by Kitty. So Kitty is taken as hostage as Sled makes his way out of town.

When Matt hears the news, he and lawyer Taylor set out to find Sled and Kitty. They track him to a farm house where it looks like Sled has the upper hand. Then all of the sudden something quite unbelievable happens that puts an end to the crisis. It is so weird and shameful that it ruins the watching experience.

This could have been one of the better shows but the ending was like a plane crash. But even with the script problem that acting in this show was top-notch. The episode did have enough interest to make this a good watch for viewers.

Note- there is one part of the show that made me laugh out loud. After Sam has been knocked out he regains consciousness and manages to walk over to the Marshal's office. When the door is opened, Sam falls face first on the floor. I feel sure that was a 'one take' fall because it was perfect.
10 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Actor commits murder
LukeCoolHand9 August 2020
Another reviewer alluded to the fact thet Richard Sorrells, the actor who played the bad guy in this episode was in prison for murder. He committed the murder in 2004. Well that review was in May, 2019 and the actor died in jail the next month after the review. Also his name is listed as Robert Sorrells not Richard.
3 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Promising episode that collapses
lrrap2 September 2021
Exactly what IS this episode supposed be? Starts with a whimsical, almost slapstick scene with Festus and Ben Cooper in the abandoned room, then shifts to a wild and crazy brawl outside the Long Branch (during which Ben Cooper demonstrates his fighting abilities..which could have been used effectively in the show); then the plot turns dramatic with the drunk Sorrells, and Elisha Cook swearing vengeance against Kitty for firing him.

So far, we have a promising show.

Then comes the conflict between the dandy-ish, East Coast whippersnapper, pain-in-the-neck lawyer (Cooper) and the rough, tough, wise and fair Matt Dillon, which is nicely resolved by the Judge. Cooper and Miss Kitty then hint at a possible cozy relationship between them, followed by the "conspiracy" scene with Sorrells and Elisha Cook (loved the placement of the kerosene lantern in that scene).

Then, the entire show goes straight to hell, becoming another "Kitty is Kidnapped" drama which I absolutely HATE (Kitty, as usual, in her bouffant hair-do, big eyelashes, fancy make-up and long-trained dress being roughed up and manhandled in the wild while we all wait for Matt to catch up with them. As I said, I hate these plots...though there's a VERY convincing shot of Kitty falling off her horse and tumbling down the roadside; GREAT stunt-double work that looked exactly like Amanda Blake).

Anyway, it's just a matter of time: will Kitty be molested by the bad guy before Matt shows up? And the director's handling of the big climatic scene near the end is poor; why didn't Cooper and Matt split up, to give them an advantage when Sorrells emerges, holding Kitty hostage?? Why did Matt wait a full 8-10 seconds to move while the pooch was chewing on Sorrells' arm? The tension and realism were just deflated.

Actor Ben Cooper, who was fabulous in the great Season 7 episode "Apprentice Doc", here is saddled with a script which cant' seem to figure out who-or-what his character is supposed to be, being reduced to a tag-along with Matt, and a silly final scene that attempts to patch together a poorly-plotted script.

NOTE TO WRITER CRUTCHFIELD: next time, have Ben Cooper, the "social justice, by-the-book warrior" be forced to shoot and kill the thug he was so hot to defend in order to save Miss Kitty, thereby teaching him the realities of administering justice in the violent, dangerous emerging society of the Old West; now THAT would have been a good ending!

Instead, we get this silly, lame' "whimsical" scene at the very end, a real eyeball roller. Just plain bad.

And speaking of eyeballs, how about Hank Patterson's mouthful of dry corn..expanding in his mouth 'til his eyeballs were going to pop outta' his head..... Now THAT was weird!

LR.
6 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Breck
schappe18 August 2020
I agree with Maskers-87126 that Ben Cooper's Breckinridge character was basically an audition to be a semi-regular character. I think he was contemplated as a replacement for Quint, whose last episode was shown the next week but which was filmed before 'Breckenridge' and "Two Tall men', the two episodes where Breck appears. I don't think that Carl Reindel's 'Cale' character from three seasons before was intended to be a semi-regular. I think that that character, a wanderer, might have been under consideration for a series of his own. (There's a couple other episodes from that era that looked like pilots).

The problem with Breck is that there wasn't much he could do with the character. To have an attorney as part of the series turns it into "Arrest and Trail" where Matt would arrest somebody and a sympathetic character would then try to prove him innocent. The audience wouldn't know what to think.

Thad would have been a much more interesting character if they'd hired Jon Voight, a much superior actor, to play the role. Roger Ewing was a nice, good looking guy who couldn't act so Thad was a nice, good looking guy who wasn't interesting.
4 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
B as d idea
maskers-8712616 October 2018
Another attempt at adding a semi reg character. Not a,believable character in any way WAS THE DANDY LAWYER. COULDNT HAVE FIT in in any way. Like dropped from the future. Almost as bad as another attempt with the unappealing Kale guy. Quint was great, Newly was good, Thad was God awful and the flatest actor ever.
4 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed