This episode of "Hallmark Hall of Fame" would seem a prime example of what Rod Serling used to complain about when he discussed hack-job script writing for television, yet he wrote this little bore. It has a very straight, flat story; problem: college has no money. Offered solution: compromise high standards or go belly up. Main protagonist too noble to do such a thing. Resolve: his goodness is rewarded with tons of free money from unexpected source. Happy ending. No twists or turns or curve balls to give it any fire at all. The actors' lines are pretty cliché, and the acting itself has a stock "great man at momentous time" gravity that I'd expect in an ancient B-picture. It's almost a parody. The odd thing is that Serling actually went to Antioch, the school being celebrated in this story.
2 Reviews
Early Serling Melodrama
reesrw14 October 2014
It is 1859 in rural Yellow Springs, Ohio. Horace Mann and his wife have come west to start a school, Antioch, on the principle of education for all regardless of background or financial means.
They soon confront the mounting problem of insolvency. The college is broke and faces having to close. One of the trustees proposes charging more for tuition from the wealthy who don't like their children mixing with the lower orders. But Horace will not hear of it.
Horace is deeply touched when one of the students shows up and delivers the contribution from his fellows, $8 and some change.
Eventually, Horace gets the news that his banker, Frank Palmer, has turned him down and not a single supporter can be found. The school will finish the term and then be auctioned off. It is the end of an idea, a dream. It is all too much to bear and Horace takes ill.
Horace prepares to give the school's final commencement speech to the class of 1859 when he gets the news that the school has been auctioned for $40,000 to the only bidder, Frank Palmer. Palmer, who earlier denied support, has inexplicably changed his mind and bought Antioch in order to give it back, thereby saving the school.
Horace gives a rousing speech to the graduating class, announcing that "Antioch has been restored to us." He leaves them with his most famous words, "Be ashamed to die until you have won some victory for humanity." ----------------- An interesting work revealing what television was like in the early 1950s. The budget is shoestring. The writing shows Serling still working on the craft. It is interesting to see Serling write about his alma mater. He had graduated from Antioch only three years before in 1950. He would include these lines in the Twilight Zone episode, "The Changing of the Guard." Serling would later teach at Antioch College in 1962.
The work is a melodrama and lends itself to overwritten, overly dramatic lines. The lead, Frank Thomas, had been in television and movies for forty years. His performance is a bit stilted and some of the acting from the supporting cast is not always good. Actors occasionally seem to forget their lines or foul them up. The most embarrassing is the announcer in closing. But the show was live, like much of TV in the 1950s, and so the flubs can't be fixed.
The show aired March 8. There is a hilarious commercial in the middle suggesting that we send Hallmark St. Patrick's Day cards to your Irish-American friends.
They soon confront the mounting problem of insolvency. The college is broke and faces having to close. One of the trustees proposes charging more for tuition from the wealthy who don't like their children mixing with the lower orders. But Horace will not hear of it.
Horace is deeply touched when one of the students shows up and delivers the contribution from his fellows, $8 and some change.
Eventually, Horace gets the news that his banker, Frank Palmer, has turned him down and not a single supporter can be found. The school will finish the term and then be auctioned off. It is the end of an idea, a dream. It is all too much to bear and Horace takes ill.
Horace prepares to give the school's final commencement speech to the class of 1859 when he gets the news that the school has been auctioned for $40,000 to the only bidder, Frank Palmer. Palmer, who earlier denied support, has inexplicably changed his mind and bought Antioch in order to give it back, thereby saving the school.
Horace gives a rousing speech to the graduating class, announcing that "Antioch has been restored to us." He leaves them with his most famous words, "Be ashamed to die until you have won some victory for humanity." ----------------- An interesting work revealing what television was like in the early 1950s. The budget is shoestring. The writing shows Serling still working on the craft. It is interesting to see Serling write about his alma mater. He had graduated from Antioch only three years before in 1950. He would include these lines in the Twilight Zone episode, "The Changing of the Guard." Serling would later teach at Antioch College in 1962.
The work is a melodrama and lends itself to overwritten, overly dramatic lines. The lead, Frank Thomas, had been in television and movies for forty years. His performance is a bit stilted and some of the acting from the supporting cast is not always good. Actors occasionally seem to forget their lines or foul them up. The most embarrassing is the announcer in closing. But the show was live, like much of TV in the 1950s, and so the flubs can't be fixed.
The show aired March 8. There is a hilarious commercial in the middle suggesting that we send Hallmark St. Patrick's Day cards to your Irish-American friends.
See also
Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews
