"Law & Order" The Corporate Veil (TV Episode 1992) Poster

(TV Series)

(1992)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Deadly culpability
TheLittleSongbird28 May 2020
The previous three episodes of Season 3 got the season (one that was no less inferior to the well worth watching and at their best brilliant previous two) to a promising start. Did feel though that "Conspiracy" was the only near-outstanding one of the three, but all three have so many great qualities. So of course anybody would have high expectations before watching "The Corporate Veil", to see if the season continued its good streak and how it would fare with its interesting subject.

Good news is that "The Corporate Veil" does a wonderful job with it and makes it even more interesting. It's a great episode and one of the best of the season's first half, if not quite an early season or show high point. It resonated with me in a way that the previous three episodes didn't quite ("Conspiracy" had more tension, was more hard hitting but was a different episode in feel, even that episode didn't resonate quite as much as this did) and had so many brilliant assets.

Criticisms are next to none for me, though perhaps it's slightly too reliant on its emphasis of high technology and a little slow to start with. The latter nit-pick very quickly did not matter, as "The Corporate Veil" kicked into gear very quickly and didn't let go whereas two of the three previous episodes were cases of their first halves not being as interesting as their second halves. This was a case of both halves being equally good.

What made "The Corporate Veil" stand out for me was how it made me feel emotionally. Anybody familiar with pacemakers, has a heart condition or has a family history of heart conditions are likely to feel a strong connection here. Being somebody that belongs in the third category and knows other people in the other two, that was the case with me. This was a case that was intricate without being too complex and always intriguing, one that made me both very sad and very angry. One may be put off from having a pacemaker for life, the case with me. The script is thoughtful and handles the subject with intelligence and sincerity, the legal scenes with all the conflicts and moral dilemmas are brilliantly written.

Production values have the usual slickness and grit and the music is unobtrusive and gives big revelations even more impact without over-emphasising. The direction is deliberate but not sluggish, quite sharp in the second half. The investigative/procedural work is never less than intriguing and makes sense. The acting is very good all round, especially in the final third.

All in all, great. 9/10
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Dear Heart.
rmax30482315 December 2010
Warning: Spoilers
Good episode. A young man from a Puerto Rican family is driving along, suffers a heart attack, and smashes into a fruit stand, spilling the guavas all over the place. Serreta and Logan are curious. How does an eighteen-year-old guy have a sudden heart attack. The trail leads to a company that "refurbishes" the pacemakers that are implanted in the chest to keep the heartbeat regular.

The pacemaker this victim was wearing simply failed. A check reveals that it was past its sell-by date and that someone had altered the registration date and extended the active period by a year. This particular pacemaker had been used by a patient for three years before it was replaced by a newer model that ran half on gasoline and half on ethanol. The old one was examined, batteries replaced, sterilized, and put back on the market at less cost. It was purchased by the poor but honest Puerto Rican family. Except for the alteration of the sell-by date, it's all legal. Even WITH the phony expiration date, it's nothing more than fraud, although the practice has resulted in at least six deaths.

Now, "Law and Order" deals chiefly with two kinds of narratives. One is personal and depends on love, jealousy, intrigues, perjured testimony, habeus corpus, in flagrante delicto, and whatnot. The other kind of narrative takes us up to the organizational level and pokes into the nooks and crannies of businesses like the diamond trade or the manufacture and marketing of cardiac pacemakers. We get to know some of the details of the businesses.

Did you know that the leads -- the little wires that lead from the battery of the pacemaker to the cardiac muscle -- can corrode without the corrosion being detectable without a test of conductivity? The law does not require a test of conductivity -- which is designed to see whether the gadget WORKS or doesn't work! And of course if it fails after implant, your only recourse is to return it to the seller and demand your money back.

What puzzles me as much as the absence of anything resembling genuine consumer protection is how the writers could dream up a story that depended so much on details of high technology, let alone law. Both are areas that seem specifically designed to cause an outsider to feel as if someone had just slipped some acid into his latte.

I couldn't find any evidence that Dick Wolf, the idea man, or any of his writers had any background in law. Wolf himself came out of commercials. Yet, on top of having to know the court system in its organic peculiarities, the writers here had to research the material background of pacemakers. In other "organizational" stories it's some business that's equally recherché.

You and I might have done it but it would have taken months, yet these guys bang this stuff out as if it were pulp fiction. Such hard work calls for applause.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Pacemaker Horror Story
sarastarfbi22 November 2021
This episode was well written, surprisingly memorable. When it 1st aired I was 2 years old. I must have watched it as a teenager however because I certainly recalled the episode after 2 minutes. Great acting, pretty medically accurate. My only issue is this may push people away from pacemakers. Please don't let this scare you. I've had mine for nearly 5 years. Pacemakers are generally safe. I couldn't help but feel for the victim, even if this was just a TV show. Again, loved the episode, just not the pacemaker horror side of things.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Searching for culpability
bkoganbing1 November 2018
An 18 year old boy who had a pacemaker has a heart attack at the wheel of a car and dies. It's discovered by forensics that the pacemaker was defective. Just where and how was the defection discovered is for you to watch the episode.

Assigning culpability falls to ADAs Michael Moriarty and Richard Brooks and the task isn't easy. The guilt falls on a laboratory supply house that was using used pacemakers and it's run by father Robert Milli and son Bruce Norris. Someone in the family has to roll on someone for justice to be served at least partially. So who to work on.

Anyone considering open heart surgery with an implanted pacemaker will think twice after seeing this story.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Keeping the pace
safenoe7 September 2023
Warning: Spoilers
The corporate veil is pierced in this early episode of Law and Order, aptly titled The Corporate Veil. Anyway, here it's a dodgy pacemaker that's the focus of The Corporate Veil, and it's interesting that the recipient of the dodgy pacemaker was originally accused of being a drug addict or alcoholic, maybe with the background.

Anyway, I like watching the early seasons of Law and Order and there's the gritty feel of New York City with The French Connection and Serpico coming to the fore. I wish there were more night scenes so we can have a spin-off series called Law and Order Nights like Baywatch Nights.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed