"Little House on the Prairie" A Promise to Keep (TV Episode 1982) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Mr. Edwards' Hardships...
ExplorerDS678923 December 2010
Warning: Spoilers
Today was Carl Edwards' birthday, and it would have been a very special day, but sadly, it was not, thanks in big part to his father. Where is Isaiah Edwards? Grace found him out in the barn, dead drunk. Yeah, poor Edwards never really got a handle on his drinking problem, and things had only gotten worse. So after embarrassing his son, dancing drunk with his daughter and collapsing into the cake, Grace finally let him know she'd had enough. Isaiah was no longer the man she originally fell in love with and all that gobblty-gook. So after putting up a short fight, Mr. Edwards relented and left. He went back to Walnut Grove and got reunited with Charles. So after meeting Almanzo and being brought up to speed on all that's happened since he left, he went over to see Half Pint and baby Rose, and at dinner that night, he was named Rose's godfather. Things were going great for Edwards, but little did anybody know that he was holding all of his pain inside. After hitting the bottle all night, Edwards went to Oleson's to find a cure for his cough. Nels introduced him to an elixir that's 50% alcohol. Edwards bought out his whole supply. Now he's abusing cough medicine. Edwards was in dire straights, and sadly, it was about to get worse.

In hopes of earning enough money to buy a microscope for a science project, Albert accompanies Edwards on a freight run to Sleepy Eye. After making the delivery and getting tanked at the saloon and making a spectacle of himself, Edwards was ready to go back. Well he wasn't so much ready was he was forced out of the saloon by the bartender. Albert helped him stagger back to their wagon, but the blitzed Edwards insisted on driving. Getting behind the reigns drunk, never a good idea. An especially hard jaunt forced Albert from his seat to the ground, where an oncoming wagon ran right over him. He was taken to Doc Baker, who stated the injury was quite severe and if worse comes to worse, Albert could lose a leg. After hearing what happened, an infuriated Charles went to confront Edwards, who was of course drunk. Charles told him he wanted nothing more to do with him and told to leave. Even his life-long friend had given up on him, so Edwards felt he had no choice but to leave, but thankfully, one person has yet to give up on him. That's right, Half Pint! Laura refused to turn her back on the man that was like a second father to her, and she was determined to help him be his old self again. Well things went okay, until Edwards received a letter from Grace. Seems she met a new man named Nathan Simms (isn't that who Miss Beadle married? Is this guy an Arabian prince?) and thus their marriage was no-more. Feeling he had nowhere else to turn, Edwards humbled himself by going to church and confiding in Reverend Alden and God. So in the end, it all worked out. Albert was fine, Charles and Edwards made amends, and best of all, Edwards kissed the bottle goodbye. This was the start of a whole new life for him, and hopefully this one would be filled with as few hardships as possible.

Glad to see Victor French return the series after a 5 year absence, though he did appear in Season 6's "The Return of Mr. Edwards" and again in "Chicago", earlier in this season. I would consider "A Promise to Keep" to close out this unofficial Edwards Hardship Trilogy. Seems the injury of his daughter and the death of his son, John Jr., is what drove Edwards to drink. It's a shame he lost Grace and his kids, but he still has his other family to turn to- Charles, Laura and the rest of the family. This episode is quite good and pretty dramatic, particularly the scene where Charles confronts Edwards after Albert's accident. Very tense, especially when taking into consideration all the two had been through. So, great acting and directing by Michael Landon, a brilliant performance by Victor French, it was just all good. If you like Mr. Edwards, you ought to see his rise from the abyss and return to the happy life, then this is one episode you should see. And remember, do NOT get behind the reigns when you're drunk.
12 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Welcome home, Mr. Edwards!
mitchrmp23 November 2013
Mr. Edwards has returned home, but not under the best of circumstances. After the death of John Jr., he just couldn't face life anymore. He had a serious drinking problem and didn't know how to stop it.

He hid all this from his friends in Walnut Grove. He was welcomed back into their lives, got a job at the meal, and became part of the family. Laura even asked him to be Rose's god-father! But when he and Albert went on an errand in Sleepy Eye, a tragic accident happened while Isiah was drunk. Albert was almost killed!

The truth came out. Alice was divorcing him. Charles didn't want him near his family again. But Laura had a soft spot for Isiah and begged him to stay. Almanzo would make him work hard and earn his keep, but together they could make it happen. A letter from his soon-to-be ex- wife almost ruined everything!

We see the Wilder's in their new home. The timing is a bit unbelievable. Rose is still a newborn baby, yet a lot happened since she was born. She should be a lot older than she really is. A different actress played Grace Edwards, and Carol was played by a different actor. It just didn't feel like the same. Though I'm not happy that the writer's decided to take Mr. Edward's beloved character in this direction, I guess it's the way life happens. Bad things happen to good people.
10 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Edwards hits bottom
gregorycanfield9 February 2022
The scruffy Mr Edwards returns to Walnut Grove. His drinking problem is causing him to lose everything, except his beard. In a serious case of miscasting, Grace Edwards is played by the beautiful, ultra sexy Corrine Michaels. She was not believable as Edwards' wife, but I enjoyed just looking at her! In fact, I had trouble remembering the original actress who played Grace Edwards. In this episode, Grace decides to divorce Edwards, because of his drinking. I didn't care so much about that. What bothered me was that, once she told Edwards to leave the house, we didn't see her anymore. Why was this beautiful actress casted, if her part was to be so small? In any case, Edwards continues on a downward spiral, even causing Albert to suffer a serious accident. Albert was supposedly in danger of losing his leg, until the end of the episode, where he seemed to be miraculously healed. Will wonders never cease? Corrine Michaels also appeared in an earlier episode. In that story, she plays a mother who blames Laura for the death of her daughter. I may just watch that episode again. In that one, I get to see more of Corrine's lovely face.
4 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Grace, not Alice
rdotvflm17 September 2020
It was Grace that divorced Isaiah Edwards, not Alice...Alice refers to the wife of Jonathan Garvey..
9 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Why on earth did Grace write that letter to Edwards?
drfernandogil22 May 2024
Warning: Spoilers
Bright. The mere intervention of the great actor Victor French already gives shine to the chapter, whatever the topic is. He is so expressive, he conveys his feelings so clearly with a single look, which makes him lovable even in the worst circumstances.

I really liked Laura's role this time. I generally don't sympathize with his whims and stubbornness, but here he took on a truly human role. Good for her, although it is really risky to put your little daughter in the hands of a person who is recovering from a vice as harmful as alcohol.- Why on earth did Grace write that letter to Edwards? To ruin what was left of his life? Also, did Edward learn to read? I remember that someone had to read the notes to him.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed