User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Cherry Hill, N.J. - Sins Of The Rabbi
ccthemovieman-15 July 2008
Warning: Spoilers
Anytime City Confidential can find a story of a minister, priest or rabbi gone bad, they jump on it like flies on sugar. Here, it's a rabbi they roast (but whose to argue, in this particular case?), a guy who had his wife murdered. Yeah, it's a pretty sad comment for a man in his position, made more disgusting by his lack of remorse and arrogant attitude at his trial. He may have the rabbinic title but he's no real man of God, obviously and the many practicing Jews in Cherry Hill, New Jersey, would agree. As the victim's brother said at the sentencing, "this man has disgraced Judiasm, among a lot of other things."

Before the crime story, we get a look at this area not far from Philadelphia.which used to be nothing but farm land but quickly became commercialized, I think CC narrator Paul Winfield pointed out, in the 1950s. Suddenly, folks who wanted out of Philly or Camden began flocking on the newly-built Route 70 and settled in Cherry Hill. The city then sported the East's first indoor shopping mall, a huge attraction (which is still very well attended). Soon, this area was almost wall-to-wall stores, fast-food places, gas stations and so forth. With it, came tons of traffic. However, it still had a lot of nice areas and was a good place to bring up kids, especially with the great schools they insisted upon having.

Rabbi Fred Neulander and his wife and family moved here in the early '70s. He wasn't satisfied with being an associate pastor so he started his own synagogue: M'Kor Shalom. Like Cherry Hill, it flourished quickly. In no time, a new, impressive building was erected, the congregation was soaring in numbers and even Fred's wife was very successful in her kosher bakery business. She'd bring home literally thousands of dollars in cash to their new suburban home.

The rest of the story, you have to see to believe. It's outrageous and involves a man who has spent his life as Walter Mitty, a total nutcase who thinks he's a famous person; the killer known as "The Bathroom Guy." We also learn the rabbi who has a mistress, who is head of a prestigious school, and we witnessed but happened in court - a couple of times! This is really an incredible story.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Cherry Hill: Sins Of The Rabbi
a_baron3 August 2014
The first ten minutes or so of this documentary gives a cynical potted history of Cherry Hill; most of this could have been omitted as it contributes little or nothing to the tale of the rabbi who used a fantasist to murder his cake shop entrepreneur wife so he could start a new life with his mistress.

Having said that, the cynicism is hardly misplaced, because this is one of those stories you couldn't make up, and it is hardly surprising that the rabbi's first trial ended in a hung jury. It took years for the police to put the whole story together, and that was only because one of the hit men confessed to a tabloid journalist. This was the aforementioned fantasist, who admitted murdering Carol Neulander but claimed he had been tricked into doing so by the rabbi, who had told her she was an enemy of Israel and had promised to get him a job with the Mossad on completion of the contract. One would have suspected that having already worked for both the CIA and the NSA, Len Jenoff would not have been duped so easily. Fortunately, the jury believed the prosecution case the second time around, and the rabbi is now behind bars. Perhaps even worse he has been airbrushed out of the history of the synagogue he founded. O, o, how hard it is to be a Jew!
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Rest in peace, Sarah
evening121 April 2024
Warning: Spoilers
I was able to find this episode of the excellent true-crime series after hearing of the death of Fred Neulander, a rabbi who was convicted of having his wife, Sarah, killed in 1994.

It's a terrible story well-told by the series' first narrator, the inimitable Paul Winfield, who had a way of sounding insinuating about locales that looked wholesome on the surface but harbored evil.

In this case the crime scene was bucolic Cherry Hill, NJ, a suburb of Philadelphia in which Neulander had built his Reform congregation and Sarah, 52, operated several successful bakeries.

The episode recalls a quote from early feminist Olympe de Gouges, who herself was executed, in 1793, in the wake of the French Revolution.

She called marriage "the tomb of trust and love."
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed