"Dollhouse" Echo (TV Episode 2009) Poster

(TV Series)

(2009)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
An interesting pilot which wasn't aired
Tweekums30 October 2017
Warning: Spoilers
This, the original pilot, features several scenes that will be familiar to anybody who has already watched the first season… and given that it is tucked away amongst the extras on the final disc I imagine that will be fair number of viewers. For those who decided to watch this first it gives an interesting introduction to the Dollhouse, most of the main characters and to explain what is going on.

The Dollhouse is an organisation with branches around the world, this story focuses on the LA Facility which is run by Adelle DeWitt. It offers a unique service to wealthy individuals who, for a substantial fee can hire 'Actives'. These actives are people who have had their own personalities removed and can be imprinted with any other personality… the perfect lover, assassin, carer or whatever one imagines. Not everybody believes this system is moral; Boyd Langton, one of the handlers who looks active the Active known as Echo, is unsure about what they do and FBI agent Paul Ballard is investigating despite the fact that his colleagues believe the Dollhouse is an urban myth. Ultimately Ballard's inquiries put him in real danger.

I'm not sure why the network decided not to use this pilot; I thought it would have been an effective introduction to the series… perhaps if I hadn't seen the series first I might see things differently. The way things were introduces was intriguing and showed protagonist Echo in a number of roles. The cast does a solid job; Eliza Dushku really impresses as Echo; a role which effectively means she is playing many characters. The rest of the cast are good too; notably Harry Lennix, who plays Boyd Langton; Tahmoh Penikett, as Ballard; Olivia Williams, as DeWitt; Fran Kranz, as Topher, the man who programs the Actives and Amy Acker as Dr Claire Saunders. Overall I'd say that his episode is well worth watching.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A Good Introduction to the Series
tpennington-7644820 August 2020
A lot of scenes in this first pilot were repurposed for other episodes. Most of which were in the first half of the first season. I personally like the scenes being spread out more, but I do also think this is a really good introduction to the show. The second pilot that was actually used tried to do a story and an introduction at the same time, which may be a little confusing. If you possess the Season 1 DVD set, I would recommend watching this episode first even though some scenes are reused in other episodes.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
good enough, intriguing but not brilliant
Joxerlives20 December 2011
Warning: Spoilers
ECHO

The good; A solid introduction to the workings of the Dollhouse and the various characters we will encounter over the course of the series. Love Echo at the wedding reception and Victor being a doll is sure a shock. Interesting debate between Topher and Boyd, they seem closer here than in Ghost.

The bad; You can see why the network demanded a re-shoot, very little action and kinda hard to like the characters, especially when Echo shoots Agent Ballard. Also stretches credibility that there's no sex involved, reminiscent of the holosuites in ST;TNG

Best line; Victor's "People are mostly crap!" just beating Topher's "Morality is programming" (or do they mean the same thing?)

Packing heat; Echo shoots Ballard with his own gun.

Kinky dinky; Astonishingly in this first ep there's no sex whatsoever except for a little kissy kissy at the wedding reception. Addy remarks to the client about hiring girls to dress as cheerleaders for him. Topher justifies him being in the Dollhouse because it is "Cutting edge science in a house full of hot chicks". Personally all the naked showering scenes do little or nothing for me, when the actives don't have their personalities implanted they act like stoned children and I just find it extremely creepy (nudity in itself is seldom erotic, the context is everything).

Capt subtext; Addy's client is a little too eager to turn down the offer of a male doll. Victor says that he wants to be Doris Day (cut to Sierra looking just like her or actually a little more Jackie O perhaps?)

How'd they get away with that? The sociopath assassin Echo is programmed with is hard to take, she's loathsome but your heart bleeds for a girl who's been running from the police since she was 5. Still hard to watch Ballard threaten her though but this being a Joss show she turns the tables. Boyd seems pretty callous just abandoning a wounded Ballard but in fairness the police are on their way.

This weeks fantasy; Echo is a vengeful streetwalker, besotted fiancé, damaged goods assassin and rehab girl. Sierra is Jackie O, Victor is a Russian gangster

Total number personalitites; Echo; 4 Sierra; 1 Victor; 1

Total dolls;3 We meet Victor, Echo and Sierra

Addy is a bit British; Likes her tea

Topher is a bit geeky; His lab is an ubergeeks playground complete with gum-ball machine and whack-a-mole arcade machine

Dolls injured; Sierra with an unexplained cut on her face

Happy hookers; Essentially the Dollhouse is the ultimate fantasy brothel, amazing that Joss was able to get that onto the screen but I guess The Sopranos, The Shield etc led the way. Here we actually have Echo beating up a pimp and packing his latest working girl off home, rather hypocritical given the nature of the Dollhouse, is what Addy and co do that different to what he does?

Know the face? 2 Joss Whedon regulars, Amy Acker and Eliza Dushku.

Guantanamo; The conspiracy starts here, the power and reach of the Dollhouse is truly terrifying

Fanfic; Plenty where Echo and the girls get to dress up as cheerleaders and 'Bring it on'.

Missing scenes; Interesting missing scenes with Echo saving the girl in a spiral of self-destruction but the Dollhouse seems a bit TOO altruistic

Reminds me off; The dolls sleeping pods are very Alien whilst the Dollhouse itself is reminiscent of the Wolfram and Hart set in Angel.

Questions and observations; Gotta say I prefer Echo to Ghost although I can see why the network didn't. Do we ever meet Ballards ex? Addy seems to imply they're all dammed.

7 out of 10, good enough, intriguing but not brilliant
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Mostly a curiosity item - the "official" pilot is better
gridoon202419 October 2010
Warning: Spoilers
"Echo" is the unaired pilot of "Dollhouse", and can now be found as an extra feature on the Complete Season 1 DVD of the series. I've read some people's opinions that the TV network disapproved of this pilot because it was too "demanding" and forced Joss Whedon to make something more "accessible", so he did "Ghost" as the official pilot instead. This, frankly, doesn't make much sense to me: of the two episodes, "Ghost" is certainly the more demanding one, because it attempts to set up this world AND tell a full story at the same time, while "Echo" spends most of its time simply trying to explain the premise and the rules. Much of "Echo"'s footage was actually used in later episodes - and often more functionally: for example, Adelle's enthusiasm and strong belief in the value of the Dollhouse's services makes a powerful contrast with her future disillusionment in "Epitaph One"; the Victor = Lubov twist is also given away too early here, as is the first (altered) encounter of Ballard with Echo. Maybe the longer and more meaningful talks between Boyd and Topher could be considered a good addition, but mostly this episode is of curiosity value. **1/2 out of 4.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed