Consequences of our Choices had gone through a few different titles since the first draft was written back in 2006. It's original title was "Unpredictable". Then from September 2008-April 2010 it was called "Email Order Bride".
Most of the locations used for the film are the actors actual houses. The character of Matt resides in director David Rutter's house. Ben Spencer's bedroom is DP David Riley Jr's cousins bedroom. Matt and Ben's work place is where David Riley Jr. works & Natalie's house is Sean Carritte's house.
While filming a fight scene between David Rutter and Edwin Cabrera, Edwin accidentally punched David in the jaw, but David and everyone else loved it so much they decided to keep it in the final product.
To save money on the budget, all the equipment used for the film except one camera and editing software was borrowed from a local public access TV station.
Scene 22 which features Edwin Cabrera and Michael Shea's characters having a phone conversation was filmed within two months of one another. Ed's part was filmed in June while Mike's was filmed in August.