The Golden Dream (2013) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
9 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Mind-blowing; heart-rending; yet life-affirming poetry in motion!
electric_sunrise25 October 2013
At the recently concluded Mumbai Film Festival, I had the pleasure of watching this brilliant & moving homage to the treacherous journey thousands of Guatemalan immigrants undertake from their home country into "The Golden Cage", i.e. USA, in search of a better life.

Shot in a hand-held documentary-style, the movie gallops at a steady pace without staggering or slowing down too much. It finishes well below two hours, but the complications of the journey and the character experiences make it feel a lot longer than its running time. Maybe its because it is a brilliant road movie with so much happening. Watching these kids whose journey and eventual struggles I soon became an intimate part of, made me feel as though I was living this adventure as it unfolds, traveling beside these children on a train, with the afternoon sun mercilessly blazing into my eyes, my face dried up by the dust in the wind, hair-blowing wildly, as I peer at the ever-changing countryside, with fellow-wayfarers. I felt that way because of how intimately the camera lets us into their lives.

Juan, Samuel, Sara (a girl pretending to be a boy for the journey) and I, the viewer (as the intimate witness behind the camera), begin a journey at Guatemala which we will end in the US. Getting to the US is the only consistent plan, the aim that binds us together; for the rest of the story is like an account of a leaf on a stream; randomly tossed and turned about by the currents of life. We know we'll get there; but we don't know in what condition: Here I lose a friend, there I make a friend; here I dance in a loving crowd, there I am alone in my misery; here I hunt for food, there I'm the object of someone's hunt; here I hitch a train ride, there I run on golden fields. In this uncertain wilderness, yesterday's rival can be today's friend, and characters who disappear from our lives create a haunting presence. In the end, the long journey takes its toll. This is a road movie – yet it is more. It is poetry.

There are great cerebral filmmakers who make you ponder about the nature of Existence (Bergman, Tarkovsky etc); then there are those who draw you into their story in a way that you intimately experience the character's existence and share his world-view. With this impressive debut, Diego Quemada-Diez shows streaks in that second, rare breed; of being not necessarily a cerebral filmmaker, but more of a poet or artist and filling the canvas with strokes of 'feel', and not 'reason'. Diego spends much of the reel time cataloging what these little insignificant lives do – these little dots on the map that flitter about the earth from here to there going seemingly nowhere, affected by the random turns of life; but through the length of the film, he lets us know them personally, and that gives these unknown lives and their unsung stories a soul. On knowing them, we discover they have values of friendship, loyalty, love, honor, sacrifice, without the knowledge or pride of knowing these are noble values. By the end of the film, I recognize what happens to these children might happen to anyone were we not protected by the proud shackles of civilization and education. Theirs, on the other hand, is the raw, wild spirit, proud and dreamy, full of self-belief; yet suffering from their oversimplified, innocent view of the world.

Poetry in film is a tribute I once paid to Joon-ho Bong, after watching his beautifully haunting "Memories of Murder", where the 'feelings' the movie impressed on me stayed well after watching it. In "Memories of Murder", I could 'smell the rain' till few days after watching the movie. After finishing this cross-continental travelogue of "La Jaula de Oro" few days back, I still feel dry in my throat and dry on my face: it is a thirst unquenched. It is a promise unfulfilled. A dream betrayed and denied, as a direct consequence of my ignorance of the world I live in. I feel I have paid for my foolishness; for the reckless pursuit of my desire for a better life, for my over simplified view of the world. Now, I'm more than thousand miles away from home. My skin is full of scabs, my eyes still dirty from the travel, my hands stained with grease from my new job in the promised land, but my head is turned upward, and when in the night, snowflakes fall over my eyes like infinite stars from the sky, I'm cleansed. Like Juan, I know my heart is always ablaze with an infinite Hope for wonder, and that can never die.
63 out of 69 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A subtly brutal account of young people's experiences of fleeing poverty
johnnymurphy156 August 2014
Warning: Spoilers
Known more for his work as a cinematographer, Diego Quemada-Diez has made his feature debut, and what a debut it is. Initially set in a slum in Guatemala centred around children trying to cross the US border to seek a better life, Quemada-Diez researched the story by interviewing real life young people who have attempted this themselves and the horrific experiences they endured doing it.

Juan, Sara and Samuel are three teenagers who escape their slum to begin hopping freights to the United States. Sara has to cut her hair short and disguise herself as a boy as she understands the risks of being a young girl attempting something this potentially dangerous. During their travels, they meet Chauk, a native American who cannot speak a word of Spanish. He joins the group despite Juan's initial hostility and together they endure many awful events that happen to them. When things seem to be going well for the group, the train is suddenly raided by people traffickers looking for young women. Also, there are teenage scammers working for illegal employers which the characters fall for. When these events happen and the characters are prised apart from each other, your heart sinks like a stone. Later, the remaining characters have to deal with border patrol and they need to attempt to find people they can trust who know of a way through the American border.

What the Director has created here is something very harrowing. It is what you don't see that is most disturbing. The writing is also very clever. The dialogue is very minimal throughout the entire film as there is a character who cannot speak Spanish. There is still a lot a of character depth through the actions they choose to escape poverty for a better life. It is also a very confronting film pointing out the problems of de-regulated capitalism and all it's inequalities and how it has effected countries in central America. It is a very bleak and complex situation which most people either turn a blind eye to or would treat these human beings like dogs. The lack of compassion from not only Americans, but their own people is astounding. It reminds us that atrocities like these continue to be a daily occurrence which needs to be looked at.

This for me is a film which everyone must see. It is not just an educational film, but a fine example of visual poetry. It shows the beautiful rural dwellings of Guatemala and Mexico and how such human cruelty and barbarism could co-exist in this natural beauty. The performances are excellent as it is more in the children's faces which give us all we need to try and understand their plight which we could never imagine or fully understand. I could not help but compare this to Ken Loach's 'Bread & Roses' and coming to the logical conclusion that his is far more superior! Truly exceptional work.
13 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A million reasons to go up north, but to stay here none.
Reno-Rangan29 July 2014
The movie also known as 'The Golden Dream' is about the central Americans who try to cross the borders of their neighbor country looking for the opportunity to live a better life. From the Spanish filmmaker who is famous for his camera works on Hollywood's big projects carved this movie. This movie was based on the collections of the true information given by the immigrates. Like a documentary style it was told with many heartbreaking incidents.

The story begins with the three youngsters from Guatemala, set a one way voyage by foot to the land of opportunity leaving behind the life of poverty. They need to cross a couple of borders and in a halfway through a new member joins them. One of the longest expedition is the train journey travelling across the Mexico where the series of obstacles are waiting for them. Overcoming from all the dangers to reach the final destination is the remain half.

''I feel that everything we will see on the other side will be full of good.''

Most of the movie is about the train journey. Since it was partially inspired by the real events there are some scenes which are hard to digest. It happens just like that, I once went mute for a scene. Half a world still live in a world like this which is not safer. Very realistic narration with the outstanding performances by the young actors given a great product output. It is just like the British movie 'In this World', except set in a different continent. Same youngsters with same notion who were ready to face odds to get a bright future.

For the director it is a fine debut. Looks simple work, but done lots of hard work to capture the images. The majority of the movie was shot in remote places like rail track, villages and jungle like landscapes. It might have not done a good commercial business, though the appreciation from the film festival circuit will boost the filmmaker's confidence for his future projects. The movie is slow and it is silent in most of the parts, but the strength is the powerful contents about the adventure.
12 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The mythical city of El Dorado - opportunity in US
cekadah15 February 2016
In this story El Dorado is the myth of economic opportunity in the USA! It doesn't exist in the 21st century yet the story, the myth, the legend, lives on. And our three main characters, Juan, Chauk, and Sara, learn this the hard way.

In "The Golden Dream" three native Central Americans head north to find the promise in the myth of opportunity in the USA. To achieve this goal they put their very lives on the line; for to travel as a peasant is precarious at best. They encounter danger, kindness, injury, and conflict. From the very start the three - Juan, Chauk, and Sara - must communicate between themselves and this is a problem as Chauk does not speak Spanish.

This film is beautifully photographed, has minimal dialog, and the three travelers capture your heart and hopes. The story of their traveling together will keep you on the edge of your seat wondering what their next danger will be and will they make it? Juan learns first had how cruel and false the myth is. But at movies end you the viewer are left to decide for yourself if Juan found his reward or does he feel lost, lonely, and forgotten.

This is easily one of those must see films because it is both beautiful to see yet disturbing to comprehend how immigrants are willing to suffer danger and death to find the elusive American dream.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Gripping and atypical Mexican immigration story
Leofwine_draca26 September 2016
THE GOLDEN DREAM is a quietly gripping story about illegal immigrants from Guatemala striving to reach the US where they can begin the new life of their dreams. The narrative adopts the format of a road movie which follows four different characters as they suffer many trials and tribulations in their attempts to head north. This is a Mexican movie although it does well to put across life in Guatemala. It's low budget but grimly effective, but also one of the more depressing films I've watched; not quite REQUIEM FOR A DREAM levels of depression, but getting there.

This is a harsh and realistic film in which the characters find themselves abused by various people smugglers and corrupt officials and suffer the consequences of their actions throughout. As a 12 certificate movie it leaves a lot of the more explicit material off screen but I found this to be more effective than in, say, an explicit film like HELI, because the power of the human imagination is infinitely greater than anything that can be put up on film.

The performances from the young cast are electrifying and the characters carefully delineated. Brandon Lopez is the brash head strong youth who has to learn a few life lessons en route. Karen Martinez is the heartbreaking girl who has to disguise herself as a boy just to survive. Best of all is Rodolfo Diminguez as the Mayan-descended lad whose tribal language means that the viewer as well as the other characters never find out what he's saying. Despite this he warms the heart with his oh-so-human portrayal of a boy driven to find a better world and a better life. Throughout the darkness there are a few touching moments and the excellent and thoughtful direction makes this one to watch.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Interesting and provoking Mexican/Spanish/Guatemala co-production about three teen immigrants and their journey to the U.S.
ma-cortes2 January 2016
A strong road movie dealing with three boys , Juan : Brandon López , Sara : Karen Martínez , Samuel : Carlos Chajon , they are three teenagers from the slums of Guatemala, all of them travel to the United States in search of a better life . On their journey since Guatemala through Mexico , they meet Chauk : Rodolfo Domínguez , an Indian from Chiapas who doesn't speak Spanish . Along the way they suffer famine , attacks , robbing and many other things .

This is a thought-provoking and hard movie with very powerful moments concerning about three teenagers traveling together in freight trains and walking on railroad tracks , but they soon have to face a harsh reality . "Jaula" tracks three teens , one a young Tzxotzil native, from Guatemala across the length of Mexico as they dodge migration cops , clash with gangs and travel on train-tops to a white-knuckle climax on the U.S.-Mexico border . It is a groundbreaking film about a teenager's decision to move to United States and leave everything that he has behind to start a new life in the pursuit of the American Dream . Crossing countries they learn that the American Dream is not easily acquired and maybe and impossibility to attain for some , and they are forced to make some tough choices . The screenplay manages to give some brief laughs from the audience and some romantic elements that you never loose your attention from the film . The picture has a brilliant and evocative cinematography by María Secco who shows splendidly the colorful South American outdoors . Furthermore , a sensitive musical score by Jacobo Lieberman , including attractive Latinas songs . The film was premiered at the Cannes Film Festival -Un Certain Regard Official Selection-, winning Un Certain Talent Award, Gillo Pontecorvo Award and François Chalais Special Mention Award . In its Mexican premiere at the Morelia Film Festival, as the picture won three awards: Audience Award, Best First Film and Press Guerrero Award .

The motion picture was compellingly directed by Diego Quemada whose first version of the movie was about 2 and a half hours ; being his first long-feature film . Diego was born in the Iberian Peninsula , Burgos , Castilla . He has lived in the American continent for the past two decades , being nationalized Mexican . His first job in the film industry was in 1995, in Ken Loach's film Land and Freedom as a camera assistant to the director of cinematography . Diego went on working as a camera operator assistant in known titles as : Gone in Sixty Seconds , Man on fire , The lost son , 21 grams , Any Given Sunday , The constant gardener , among others . His graduation film at the American Film Institute (AFI) as writer/director/ was : A Table is a Table . He also shot several shorts . Diego then stepped up in scale with his feature debut "The Golden Cage" , this immigration drama that swept the 2014 Ariel Awards snagging nine kudos , the talent prize at Cannes' Un Certain Regard and a Gold Hugo at the Chicago Fest . Director of Guatemala-u.S. road movie-thriller made "La Jaula De Oro" (The Golden Dream), a standout Latin American debut . Spain-born Mexican Diego Quemada-Diez is readying political thriller "Operacion Atlas" as he launches an Academy Award campaign for this feature . After immigration, "Operacion Atlas" takes another hot-button issue : Civil resistance to multinational corporation development projects backed by local governments – hydroelectric dams, massive deforestation and various fossil-fuel programs (oil, mining, fracking) – which is a recurrent narrative throughout Latin America .
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Fantastic piece of Mexican cinema!
KarenYVR29 July 2015
How big must one dream? The road leading to your dream is like a long tunnel. You see the fading little spark of light behind you and shiny dream-white light of hope on the other side. But in-between you have this black unilluminated path to walk through. Does it worth it? What are you ready to sacrifice for your imaginary life? Will you have the courage to go all the way till the end? The movie is about a group of teenagers from Central America trying to immigrate to the Golden Cage (i.e. United States). During the whole film you see miserable faces hoping to seek a better world of opportunities. Do they fear? Do they struggle? Their eyes will expose the truth. Was it all worth it? Excellent film!
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Not my favourite picture, but I love that it lets me make up my own mind about how to feel about it.
GiraffeDoor22 July 2019
Candid, leisurely paced road movie with a mystical quality.

It's not over emotive or soapy; it tells its story visually with an arty touch only when called for.

It overstays its welcome somewhat but it is a vivid depiction of people in quiet desperation and the camaraderie, kinship and viciousness such people must encounter on their journey to a better mediocrity.

You almost don't buy that there's really much threat or conflict so when there finally is, I feel it as if I was right there.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Why is it a dream?
p.newhouse@talk21.com1 September 2022
Warning: Spoilers
The Golden Dream (2013) is a thought-provoking treatise on what drives people towards becoming undocumented migrants. A small group of teenagers leave Guatemala, in search of a better life in the USA. Though inexperienced at this, they are aware of some of the dangers that go with what they are embarking upon, but what they are leaving behind makes them feel the risk is worth it. This film is lean and spare, and relies on the viewer being intelligent and observant. The information is all there, but it is not spoon-fed to the viewer. The acting is so good, however, that the viewer is totally absorbed by these three teenagers, who let you into their lives with a casual nonchalance, so you absorb the information osmotically. Anyone who feels that immigrants come looking for an easy life should watch this; it is almost newsreel footage.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed