- Joe Carroll invites his former attorney, Olivia Warren, to meet him at the detention center and insists that she once again represent him with the media. She very reluctantly agrees and publicly reads a passage from Poe, sending a signal to some of Carroll's followers. Claire Matthews gives her FBI protection the slip after Joe sends her a message via Olivia. After Joey Matthews manages to call his mom, the FBI now has a general idea where he might be located. Ryan and Mike Weston head to upstate New York. There, Ryan locates the house but goes in on his own rather that wait for backup.—garykmcd
- Jacob, Emma and Paul all wake up in the same bed. Jacob gets up, assuring Emma he's not freaking out as he goes to freak out. Paul and Emma spoon and giggle.
Meanwhile, Joey finds the hidden cell phone downstairs and goes to make a call in the kitchen. He calls his mom and says he's in a big white house in the country. He says Paul is mean. Claire hears Joey yelling as Paul finds him and drags him away from the phone.
The FBI tries to trace the scrambled call.
Ryan is upset when he sees Joe Carroll's attorney Olivia Warren coming to visit him.
Emma tries to reason with Joey, telling him his mom wanted him to be safe and sent him away. She says the police are the bad guys and are lying about his dad.
Paul wakes up captive Megan in the basement, telling her she's never going home but it won't be long now.
Upstairs, Paul suggests the right knife for Jacob to use on Megan. Jacob is moody and finally tells Paul he's not gay. Paul insists that the three of them together feels right.
Jacob asks Paul to kill Megan for him, but Paul insists they believe he can do it.
Olivia visits Joe, not exactly happy to be there.
2010 Olivia apologizes for losing his appeal, but says there's nothing else she can do for him.
Joe tells Olivia he needs to move things along and wants to know everything that's happening with the FBI. Olivia looks terrified.
She goes in front of TV cameras to read a statement from Joe, Poe's "The Mask of the Red Death."
One of Joe's followers sees the press conference and calls another, saying it's time. The first one arms up.
Debra Parker thinks it's a message to Joe's followers. Ryan insists on flying to Duchess County, even though they haven't unscrambled the phone trace yet. She deputizes Ryan and gives him a gun.
Ryan explains to Claire what they're doing, using local cops upstate to canvass. He tells Claire he knows the way he left her years ago wasn't fair and he'd like to talk to her when he comes back with Joey.
At the country house, Emma has called Roderick for direction. Paul argues that they need to smack Joey around, but Emma is against it. Joey overhears as Paul says he's going to figure out they're lying to him.
Olivia goes to Claire's house and demands to speak with her alone. She delivers a message from Joe, saying the only way she'll see Joey again is by going to a street corner at 3 p.m. and telling no one.
Ryan and Mike arrive in Duchess County, where the local cops tell him about 150 properties meet the house's description.
Jacob comes up from the basement, not having killed Megan. Paul follows him outside. Emma goes looking for Joey and finds he's gone.
Joey races through the woods where a man finds him.
Claire gets off the phone with someone and then announces she's meeting a friend for lunch. Turner insists on protection and updates Debra.
The Duchess chief recognizes Paul from the convenience store footage from where Megan was last seen. They narrow the area down.
The man brings Joey to his house, where his wife recognizes him. They're about to let him use the phone when Emma runs out. The couple is wary, but lets Joey leave with Emma.
In the woods, Emma tells Paul and Jacob she forgot to "thank" the neighbors, so Paul goes to do it for her. Back at the house, the man is reporting seeing Joey when Paul comes in wielding a hoe.
The sheriff's office gets the call about the Joey sighting and Ryan and Officer Lopez race there.
Back at the farm house, Emma promises Joey he can call his mom, then locks him in his room. Emma hears noises in the house and sees a strange man, who says Roderick sent him and they need to go.
Claire meets her friend for lunch as Turner and another agent sit nearby.
Officer Lopez and Ryan arrive at the couple's house and see the door open. They find the phone off the hook and the couple slashed to death inside. Ryan sees the fresh blood and realizes they were just there.
He goes outside and finds bloody clothes. They race through the woods to the next farm, arriving at the farm house. They see Paul and Jacob returning and Ryan calls Mike for back-up. Ryan and Lopez go closer to the house to get a better look.
Inside, Emma introduces Hank, who tells them they have 10 minutes to pack up.
Parker calls for additional reinforcements to race to the farm house.
Claire nervously checks her watch then tells Taylor she's going to the bathroom. She goes out the exit before he can see her leave, but he checks the exit anyway. He doesn't see her hiding in the parking lot and checks the bathroom. Back outside, he makes a call.
Ryan and Lopez split up outside the house. Hank packs up the car. He calls Roderick, who reports Claire is late.
Hank sees Lopez running to the barn.
Ryan sneaks around the house.
Lopez hears a noise in the barn and thinks it's Ryan. He runs into Hank, who plays innocent and unarmed as he walks toward him. Hank gets close enough to grab Lopez's gun and shoot him. He's about to shoot him again when Ryan races in and shoots Hank.
In the house, they hear the gunshots and go to investigate. Emma passes out guns and they go look around. Ryan calls in Lopez's shooting. He lives a few seconds longer, but dies. Ryan reports to Mike, then goes to the house.
Inside, Joey discovers he's looked in his room.
Olivia returns to see Joe, reporting the FBI has located the farm house but hasn't found Joey. She tells him his statement went national. She asks him what message she sent and says she doesn't want to be part of it.
"The messenger is somewhat preferable to that of recipient, I'm sure you'd agree," he says.
2010 Hank goes to see Olivia after hours, saying he's there on Joe's behalf. He's carrying pruning shears.
Back in his cell, Joe says he has more work for her. She takes out a pen to write and we see she's missing two fingers.
Claire arrives on the street corner and gets in Roderick's car.
Back at the farm house, Joey takes down a curtain rod and uses it to break the knob on his bedroom door. The door is still locked, so then he uses his skateboard to pry the door open.
Emma and Jacob find Lopez and Hank dead in the barn.
Ryan races to the back of the house and breaks in through a basement window. He finds Megan, tells her who he is and asks her to be quiet. She freaks out, so he puts her duct tape back on and promises to be back.
Ryan heads upstairs. Joey sees him, but is too scared to come downstairs. Ryan says he's there to take him to his mom, but Paul sneaks up behind Ryan and holds a gun to his head.
Contribute to this page
Suggest an edit or add missing content