- Captain Flint: They took everything from us. Then they call me a monster? The moment I sign that pardon, the moment that I ask for one, I proclaim the world that they were right. This ends when I grant them my forgiveness, not the other way around.
- Eleanor Guthrie: Now you think you can waltz back in here and pick up where we left off like nothing happened.
- Mr. Scott: Where else would I go? I belong to you. Chattel property of the Guthrie estate.
- John Silver: [to Randall after he's called Silver a thief multiple times] Alright, yes, I'm a thief. I took the page and I shouldn't have. I should have counted my blessings to be let off that merchant ship. But what can I say, Randall, I'm not a joiner, never have been... but I'm willing to do it now. So pull your head from your ass and let's both live to fight another day.
- Dufresne: The lying we could forgive, Singleton we could forgive, we could forgive all of it... but not Billy. That requires an answer.
- Rackham: [to a crying prostitute] I"ll have you know I have slit men's throats while they have wept, begging my forbearance, and slept soundly that very night.
- Mr. Scott: If you need me, I will be here for you. But as long as you insist upon this course with Captain Flint, I will always be tempted to interfere.
- Captain Charles Vane: [to his new crew] You don't know me, but you once did, when I was the lowest among you. Now I return, and I offer you a chance to be free of this place. I'm Charles Vane and you were a strong crew once, proper pirates, feared as you should have been, before he dragged you away from the sea, before he convinced you to live here like animals because it suits his weaknesses. There is a place not far from here where strong men live lives of pleasure, not labor. A place where you could be feared and respected once again. Follow me and I will show you what life is.
- Captain Naft: [addressing the new consortium members] It is with great pleasure that we shall now commence our inaugural meeting of the Guthrie-Frasier-Naft-Lawrence Shipping Consortium for the Purposes of Trade in the West Indies, Excelsior... .Reginald, add to the agenda discussion of a shorter name.