While he was making this movie, director Joel Schumacher was quoted saying many things that struck fear into the hearts of bat-fans everywhere. Things like "when I think of Batman, I think extreme sports," and "wait till you see the costumes -- they're practically wearing nothing," and "I want to return to the roots of the old Batman television series." Was Schumacher seriously planning to take Tim Burton's brilliantly dark vision and reduce it to leather-clad S&M freaks spouting campy one-liners while snowboarding? Sadly, he was.
Where to start? There's so much to dislike. George Clooney plays Batman as, well, George Clooney, the same character he's played in every appearance to date. His Batman smirks when he should scowl, his Bruce is insufferably arrogant. Chris O'Donnell (Robin) takes his cue from George and swaggers and preens, going from whiny brat ("I want my OWN car!") to juvenile-in-heat in every scene. Arnold Schwarzenegger as Mr. Freeze physically resembles and has all the acting talent of a 1983 Buick, and Alicia Silverstone as Batgirl plays up her valley-girl schtick to a ridiculous end -- ending up seeming even more clueless than she did in Clueless. The only characters who retain any sort of dignity are Alfred, as always, and Uma Thurman's Mae West-ish Poison Ivy.
The script, for I assume there was one at least at some point, is composed of the worst indulgences of Uber-Hack Akiva Goldsman . Goldsman doesn't write dialog, he writes one-liners, as if his goal would be to have every line in the film appear on a bumper-sticker or a T-shirt. For example, in the comic books and animated series, Mr. Freeze is a tragic character prone to long monologues about his internal suffering (Patrick Stewart was considered at one point for the role, and would have been perfect). But Goldsman diminishes him to a role far more cartoony than the cartoon, spouting insufferable dialog like "Everybahdy Freeze!" and "All right, be cool." Schwarzenneger, apparently, doesn't get the joke, because every single line is delivered straight, ignoring any pretense of comic delivery, bringing to mind a high-school play more than a major motion picture. The first two films, and the third to a limited degree, explored Batman's psyche and that of his villains, asked questions about why and how the characters are how they are. This script has all the depth and emotional subtext of an acne medication commercial.
Even the props in the movie are all wrong. The Batmobile now has no canopy, leaving the driver's head exposed (given the speed of the thing is supposedly 100 mph, it's not terribly practical). It also looks in most scenes as if it's going about 20 mph, tops; I kept expecting a bicyclist to pass it and spoil the illusion. In the end of the film, Batman is dressed in a silver suit -- perfect camouflage for a nocturnal creature, eh? And, perhaps most unforgivably, Batgirl has no hood -- just an aesthetically pleasing domino mask which leaves her hair loose, all the better for the enterprising villain to grab and rip out.
All of which could have been at least mitigated by some decent directing -- but alas, that was not to be. Schumacher includes several shots from Batman Forever in this film, perhaps to tie the two together, perhaps because he's out of ideas: Batman and Robin running towards the camera, the chest emblem, vinyl-clad buttocks, and codpiece of each character as they suit up, and the entire opening sequence are all cribbed from Batman Forever. He also bravely defies gravity and logic, letting our heroes fall all the way from the upper atmosphere and freezing Robin in sub-zero temperatures -- all without suffering so much as a scratch.
None of it makes any sense, none of it is particularly watchable -- it's not even good for camp value. The only salvation of the franchise will be to put it back in the hands of a competent director and a scriptwriter who is capable of writing an actual script. Until then, Bat-fans are better off watching the animated series on the WB to see what can be done with the character, in the hands of talented artists.
2 out of 3 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends