I am Catholic and was concerned when I read that a priest falls in love with a woman in this film. Much to my happiness, the movie does well in making one realize that priests are human. I also have been aware of Edward Norton's work since seeing him in "Larry Flynt vs. the...". Unfortunately, I have yet to see other works of his but with my curiosity peeked, his having starred, directed and produced this film instantly won me to go.
The film decently portrays these human beings of faith and deals with the very constant issue of God in a serious and, well done, light hearted tone. They are not too passe' as to make you feel they have no real convictions but then they also keep open to the masses. I am concerned that the "old-fashioned" belief of waiting until marriage for sexual relations has seemed to totally gone out the window; I thought the Jewish faith believed that, but then the priest, who knew since he was 8 of his calling, has had sex, and I _know_ the Catholic faith still has strong convictions on waiting, but I see that not much of a story line may have transgressed without that aspect in this film. Maybe that issue will come up in some other film in the future. The aspect of the rabbi and priest falling in love is a reality. I am ecstatic of the straightforward realization that the priest, to stay a priest, cannot go with his drive and that the rabbi is under the realization that certain factors of his life do effect his congregation and their view of him as a spiritual leader. Their mutual love interest makes it more understandable as she is delightfully played and is erroneously affectionate at times, thus making the priest's feelings more forgivable and the rabbi a very blessed man. All characters are going through very believable situations and that is what makes this movie so universal.
I overall give it a ten, yes, a perfect 10, since it not only deals universally with a very touchy subject but it did deal with it in a strong light of the respective faiths and overall views of God. It was a perfect example of what _many_ feel today, and that is what movies do, portray our current views, help us not to feel so alone and, hopefully, to make us look in the mirror, too.
0 out of 0 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends