hwiltshire-06889 Reviews

Doctor Who: The Stolen Earth (2008) Season 4, Episode 12

Epic Scale, Heartbreaking Stakes

[10/10 · 5 April 2024]

The Stolen Earth, the first part of the epic series four finale, is a breathtaking roller coaster of an episode. It flawlessly blends high-stakes action, emotional gut-punches, and the return of beloved characters, earning a perfect 10 out of 10.

This episode is a masterclass in raising the stakes. The threat is immense, with Earth literally disappearing, and the Doctor separated from everyone he loves. David Tennant's performance is raw and vulnerable, filled with fear and determination as the Doctor desperately tries to reunite his companions.

The return of so many beloved characters - Rose, Captain Jack, Sarah Jane, Martha, Mickey, and more - is a fan's dream brought to life. It's not just a cheap callback but a narrative necessity, with each character playing a vital role in the fight against the Daleks.

The action sequences are some of the show's best. The battles are thrilling and grand, while the personal moments back on Earth ground the episode in real human cost. The Daleks are at their most relentless and dangerous, cementing their position as one of the Doctor's greatest foes.

The cliffhanger is legendary, and the anticipation for the finale is almost unbearableable.

The Stolen Earth isn't just entertaining; it's a triumph of Doctor Who storytelling. It expertly balances epic spectacle with deeply personal stakes, delivering a thrilling, emotionally charged experience that leaves you on the edge of your seat, desperate for the resolution.

Doctor Who: Turn Left (2008) Season 4, Episode 11

A World Without the Doctor

[9/10 · 5 April 2024]

Turn Left is a powerful Doctor Who episode that takes a bold narrative leap. It's a chilling alternate reality story that explores the Doctor's impact and the devastating consequences of his absence. This unique concept, paired with a stellar performance from Catherine Tate, earns a well-deserved 9 out of 10.

The episode cleverly utilizes the "what if" scenario. By showing a world where Donna Noble never met the Doctor, it throws her ordinary life into extraordinary chaos. Catherine Tate delivers a phenomenal performance, showcasing Donna's vulnerability, courage, and ultimately, her strength in the face of a world gone wrong.

The bleak alternate reality is a fascinating concept. Familiar faces return, but their fates are tragically altered. The episode doesn't shy away from its darkness, portraying a world teetering on the brink of dystopia. This creates a stark contrast to the Doctor's usual adventures, highlighting the importance of his role in the universe.

While the episode excels in its emotional core, there are a few minor drawbacks. Relying heavily on reused footage from previous episodes can feel like a budget constraint at times. The resolution, while thematically satisfying, might feel a bit rushed compared to the meticulous build-up.

However, these are minor quibbles in the face of Turn Left's strengths. It's a thought-provoking exploration of loss, the power of choice, and the Doctor's profound influence on the universe. It's a showcase for Catherine Tate's acting talent, and a reminder of just how much the Doctor can change the course of events.

This episode is a must-watch for any Doctor Who fan, particularly those who appreciate strong companion stories and the show's ability to tackle complex themes. It's a chilling reminder of what we might lose without the Doctor, and a testament to the enduring power of hope, even in the darkest of timelines.

Doctor Who: Midnight (2008) Season 4, Episode 10

Terrifying Masterclass of Psychological Horror

[10/10 · 5 April 2024]

Midnight is a Doctor Who episode so masterfully crafted, it transcends simple entertainment and becomes a work of terrifying brilliance. This claustrophobic, chilling exploration of paranoia and mob mentality earns a flawless 10 out of 10.

The episode's premise is deceptively simple: the Doctor is trapped on a shuttle bus on a diamond-covered desert planet. An unknown entity attacks, possessing one of the passengers and mirroring their speech in a nerve-shredding display. What follows is a descent into pure, claustrophobic terror.

What makes Midnight so terrifying isn't the creature, but the exposure of the darkness within human nature. The trapped passengers turn on each other with chilling speed, their fear morphing into suspicion and cruelty. David Tennant's Tenth Doctor, normally so confident, is stripped of his usual tools and charisma, left as helpless as the other passengers.

The script is a masterpiece of tension. The dialogue is relentless, the score brilliantly discordant, and every close-up on the passengers fuels the paranoia. You watch in a state of mounting dread, unable to look away, unsure who - or what - to fear more: the creature or the terrified humans.

The lack of resolution is a stroke of genius. The ambiguity leaves the audience unsettled, wondering if they too might succumb to that kind of mob mentality given the circumstances.

Midnight isn't just a thrilling episode, it's an unforgettable one. It's Doctor Who at its most experimental and unsettling. It showcases the horrifying potential of the human mind under pressure, leaving a chilling echo long after the credits roll. A must-watch not only for Doctor Who fans, but for anyone who appreciates the power of psychological horror.

Doctor Who: Forest of the Dead (2008) Season 4, Episode 9

Hauntingly Beautiful and Heart-Wrenching

[10/10 · 5 April 2024]

Forest of the Dead is the stunning conclusion to an exceptional two-parter, a masterpiece that delivers on every front. It expertly blends sci-fi horror, mind-bending twists, and gut-wrenching emotion, earning a flawless 10 out of 10.

The episode's greatest strength lies in its emotional weight. The stakes are devastatingly high, with Donna trapped in a virtual world and characters facing impossible sacrifices. David Tennant's performance is raw and heartbreaking, conveying the Doctor's anguish and unwavering determination. The ending, while inevitable, is nonetheless a masterclass in bittersweet triumph.

River Song continues to shine. Her tragic fate and her connection to the Doctor are woven into the narrative with poignant beauty. The resolution of the Vashta Nerada threat is clever and satisfying, proving that the Doctor's greatest weapon isn't sonic screwdrivers, but his brilliant mind.

Director Euros Lyn delivers stunning visuals. The library's grandeur contrasts starkly with the terrifying shadows, creating an oppressive yet captivating atmosphere. The episode is full of haunting imagery that lingers long after the credits roll.

The script is a triumph. The intricate plot never feels convoluted, expertly juggling action, emotional beats, and mind-bending twists with heartbreaking precision. Forest of the Dead solidifies River Song as one of Doctor Who's greatest characters, establishing her as a force to be reckoned with.

This episode isn't just satisfying; it's unforgettable. It's a haunting exploration of sacrifice, the power of memory, and the enduring nature of love. Forest of the Dead is a testament to the show's ability to break your heart and rebuild it, stronger than before. It's simply Doctor Who at its finest.

Doctor Who: Silence in the Library (2008) Season 4, Episode 8

Sci-Fi-Horror Masterpiece

[10/10 · 5 April 2024]

Silence in the Library, the first half of a thrilling two-parter, is a Doctor Who episode that transcends mere entertainment and enters the realm of true brilliance. It delivers suspense, scares, and heartbreaking emotion, earning a perfect 10 out of 10.

From the opening moments, the episode establishes a chilling tone. The vast, seemingly empty library is the perfect setting for a slow-burning horror story. The introduction of the Vashta Nerada, shadows that devour, is pure nightmare fuel - an instantly iconic threat.

This episode introduces the unforgettable River Song, whose mysterious connection to the Doctor immediately captivates. Her flirtatious confidence, sharp intelligence, and hints of tragedy make her a compelling enigma from the start.

David Tennant is at his best, balancing the Doctor's usual energy with a hint of unease. The episode delves into themes of knowledge and loss, adding layers beneath the surface thrills. The poignant introduction of Donna's virtual world is an emotional gut-punch that sets the stakes for the rest of the story.

It's not just horror - there's humor, a thrilling mystery, and moments of pure heroism. Director Euros Lyn expertly balances tension with bursts of action, creating an edge-of-your-seat experience. Steven Moffat's script is a marvel, full of memorable dialogue and heartbreaking twists.

Silence in the Library is a near-perfect episode of Doctor Who. It's terrifying, emotionally resonant, and introduces one of the show's most beloved characters. This story showcases how Doctor Who can expertly blend genres and deliver an experience that stays with you long past the final credits.

Doctor Who: The Unicorn and the Wasp (2008) Season 4, Episode 7

A Charming Murder Mystery

[8/10 · 5 April 2024]

The Unicorn and the Wasp is a delightful confection of a Doctor Who story. It's a lighthearted, humorous adventure with a dash of classic Agatha Christie-style murder mystery, earning a solid 8 out of 10.

This episode thrives on its guest cast. The legendary Agatha Christie is played with charm and wit by Fenella Woolgar, bringing a perfect mix of literary brilliance and a touch of bewilderment at the Doctor's antics. David Tennant is in top form, exuding manic energy and finding great comedic chemistry with Catherine Tate's Donna.

The mystery itself, while not overly complex, is fun and engaging. The giant wasp creature, although a tad silly, works surprisingly well in the context of this almost-parodic whodunnit. There are playful references to Christie's work scattered throughout, adding a layer of enjoyment for fans of the genre.

Where the episode loses a few points is in the predictability of some plot beats and the slightly too convenient resolution. Some supporting characters could use a bit more depth. Despite this, the strengths far outweigh the weaknesses.

The Unicorn and the Wasp is a pure joy to watch. It's a love letter to classic British murder mysteries with a healthy dose of sci-fi absurdity and witty banter. It's a welcome change of pace for Doctor Who, delivering laughter, charming characters, and just enough intrigue to keep you guessing.

Doctor Who: The Doctor's Daughter (2008) Season 4, Episode 6

A Surprisingly Emotional Episode

[8/10 · 4 April 2024]

The Doctor's Daughter is a surprisingly heartfelt story that explores themes of family, identity, and the moral ambiguities of war. It's a fast-paced adventure with a focus on character dynamics, earning a solid 8 out of 10.

The introduction of Jenny, the Doctor's genetically-engineered 'daughter', is a brilliant concept. She's instantly likable - a fierce warrior with her father's spark. Her dynamic with David Tennant's Doctor is a joy, filled with warmth, confusion, and the occasional bit of bickering.

The episode's conflict centers on a land dispute between humans and the Hath, fish-like humanoids with striking visual design. The episode does a decent job showing both sides of the conflict, avoiding a simplistic 'good vs. Evil' setup.

Where the episode shines is in its emotional beats. The Doctor's struggle to reconcile his pacifist beliefs with Jenny's soldier mentality is poignant. The resolution offers a bittersweet ending that emphasizes the tragedy of war and showcases the Doctor's capacity for difficult decisions.

While it's generally strong, The Doctor's Daughter isn't without flaws. The pacing feels rushed at times, and some of the science gets a bit hand-wavey for the sake of the plot. Yet, these are minor hiccups in an episode that shines because of its emotional core.

This episode is a treat for fans of the Tenth Doctor era. It delivers a fun adventure, asks interesting questions, and leaves a lasting impact thanks to the delightful introduction of Jenny and a surprisingly poignant ending.

Doctor Who: The Poison Sky (2008) Season 4, Episode 5

A Classic Invasion with Modern Flair

[8/10 · 4 April 2024]

The conclusion to the Sontaran two-parter, The Poison Sky, delivers a satisfying mix of action, heart, and a clever twist to the usual alien invasion plot. It earns a solid 8 out of 10.

This episode shines in its character moments. The companion dynamics are fantastic, with Donna showcasing bravery alongside her usual humor, and Martha proving her strategic brilliance. The return of Wilfred adds a heartwarming element. Even the Doctor gets some poignant moments of quiet resolve.

The Sontarans continue to be a fun, if predictable, threat. The stakes are raised from the previous episode, with the threat now more global and the Doctor facing difficult choices. There's a great sequence with cloned Martha that explores ideas of identity and free will.

The episode has a few weaknesses. The science isn't always sound, and the resolution relies on some familiar Doctor Who tropes involving a last-minute reversing of the big weapon. Some of the supporting characters are thinly sketched.

However, The Poison Sky succeeds due to its pacing, emotional impact, and a thrilling final act. Director Douglas Mackinnon delivers stylish action sequences, and the core themes of family and sacrifice resonate nicely.

Overall, it's a highly enjoyable Doctor Who adventure. While not groundbreaking, it expertly weaves together classic elements like an Earth-based invasion with strong character interactions and a few genuinely surprising moments.

Doctor Who: The Sontaran Stratagem (2008) Season 4, Episode 4

A Fun But Predicable Romp

[7/10 · 4 April 2024]

The Sontaran Stratagem, the first half of a two-parter, marks the return of the iconic warmongering potatoes to modern Doctor Who. It's an enjoyable, albeit somewhat formulaic adventure that prioritizes humor and lighthearted action over depth.

David Tennant remains a delight as the Tenth Doctor, his energy and infectious enthusiasm carrying the episode. He shares great chemistry with Donna, who provides the perfect mix of humor and exasperated snark. The reappearance of Martha Jones adds a welcome layer of tension and complexity to the companion dynamic.

The Sontarans themselves are their usual warmongering selves, providing solid antagonists but not much new in terms of character development. The episode revels in their unique military culture, with lots of battle choreography and bellowing of commands.

The plot is fairly standard Doctor Who fare. Earth is invaded, the Doctor does some clever stuff, and there's a healthy dose of quippy dialogue. It's all fun, but a bit predictable. The factory setting is decent, but not particularly memorable.

Overall, this episode is a solid 7 out of 10. It delivers exactly what you expect from a Sontaran story: militaristic aliens, a dash of cleverness, and plenty of witty banter from the Doctor. While it won't blow you away, it's a fun way to spend 45 minutes if you're in the mood for decent Doctor Who adventure.

Doctor Who: Planet of the Ood (2008) Season 4, Episode 3

A Revolution with Tentacles

[8/10 · 4 April 2024]

Planet of the Ood delivers a satisfying mix of sci-fi action, social commentary, and a deeper exploration of the iconic Ood species. While a bit heavy-handed in its themes, it boasts a gripping plot, strong performances, and a sense of genuine urgency, earning a solid 8 out of 10.

This episode takes a bold step by flipping the Ood narrative. No longer passive servants, they're driven to a bloody rebellion against their human oppressors. While the social commentary on slavery and exploitation lacks subtlety, it's undeniably effective, sparking important discussions.

The episode benefits from some excellent performances. David Tennant's Doctor embodies righteous fury, making his passionate defence of the Ood inspiring. Donna Noble continues to impress with a newfound compassion alongside her signature sass. The supporting cast, notably Tim McInnerny as the loathsome Klineman Halpen, are well-cast.

The visuals are a bit of a mixed bag. While the Ood Planet setting is suitably stark and atmospheric, some of the creature effects feel dated. However, the action sequences are well-paced, building to a satisfying, even if slightly predictable, climax.

While not without flaws, Planet of the Ood is a strong episode. It challenges the audience, introduces new layers to a familiar species, and delivers a thrilling adventure. The themes might be a bit blunt, but they work well in the context of this high-stakes story.

Doctor Who: The Fires of Pompeii (2008) Season 4, Episode 2

A Moral Dilemma with Volcanic Action

[8/10 · 4 April 2024]

The Fires of Pompeii is a thrilling episode that grapples with weighty themes of history vs. Intervention, offering a satisfying mix of action, drama, and a touch of classic Doctor Who humor. It earns a solid 8 out of 10.

David Tennant is at his best, his Doctor a whirlwind of charm, brilliance, and, eventually, a deep moral struggle. Peter Capaldi, in his first Doctor Who appearance, offers a compelling and grounded portrayal of Caecilius that makes the central dilemma feel truly impactful.

The episode cleverly utilizes the historical backdrop. Pompeii is vividly realized, creating tension as the audience knows the inevitable destruction that's coming. The Pyroviles, while a bit visually cheesy, serve their purpose as a cataclysmic threat.

Where the episode shines is in its exploration of the Doctor's role. It's a classic 'can't change a fixed point in history' story, but the emotional stakes are high. The supporting characters, particularly Caecilius' family, are fleshed out enough to make their fates matter.

It loses a few points for its slightly too convenient resolution and some pacing hiccups in the middle section. However, these are minor complaints compared to the strengths of the episode.

The Fires of Pompeii is a classic Doctor Who adventure. It delivers on the spectacle of an erupting volcano and the emotional impact of a difficult choice. It's entertaining, thought-provoking, and features solid performances from its cast.

Doctor Who: Partners in Crime (2008) Season 4, Episode 1

A Fun and Frothy Reunion

[8/10 · 4 April 2024]

Partners in Crime marks the delightful return of Donna Noble as the Doctor's full-time companion. It's a lighthearted, fun episode full of charm, humor, and the re-establishment of a fan-favorite dynamic, earning a solid 8 out of 10.

The chemistry between David Tennant's Doctor and Catherine Tate's Donna is electric from the get-go. Their comedic timing is impeccable, and Donna's brashness is the perfect foil for the Doctor's frantic energy. The plot, involving a weight loss scheme and adorable but dangerous Adipose, is silly and entertaining.

The episode cleverly pokes fun at itself and at some classic Doctor Who tropes. While not heavy on action, it never takes itself too seriously, focusing instead on witty dialogue and a brisk pace. Director James Strong keeps things visually interesting, making it a treat to look at even when the storyline itself is a little ridiculous.

While the Adipose aren't the show's most menacing villains, they fit the lighthearted tone perfectly. There are some unexpectedly emotional moments, particularly at the end with Donna's grandfather, showcasing that even a fun episode can have heart.

Partners in Crime isn't perfect. Some side characters are a bit thinly sketched, and the resolution is somewhat simple. But those are minor gripes for an episode that delivers plenty of laughs, a satisfying Doctor/companion dynamic, and even a few moments of genuine sweetness. It's a fantastic reintroduction to Donna and a welcome change of pace for the series.

Doctor Who: Voyage of the Damned (2007) Season 4, Episode 0

A Star-Studded Space Titanic

[8/10 · 4 April 2024]

Voyage of the Damned is a classic disaster movie with a Doctor Who twist. It's a fun Christmas special with an all-star cast, lavish visuals, and a healthy dose of action and melodrama - all aboard a doomed spaceship!

One of the episode's biggest strengths is the impressive cast. Kylie Minogue is surprisingly charming as Astrid, and the late, great Bernard Cribbins is excellent as the heartwarming Wilfred. David Tennant is in peak form, full of energy and quips, while the supporting characters provide a mix of humor and tragedy worthy of a disaster flick.

The episode shines visually. The Titanic-inspired spaceship is stunning, and the disaster sequences are well-executed for a TV budget. There's a grand cinematic scale to it all, even when the plot occasionally dips into cheesy territory.

Where the episode falters a bit is in its predictability. The story follows disaster movie tropes pretty closely, and the villain is more of a caricature than a fully-fledged threat. Some of the emotional moments land a bit heavy-handed.

Despite these flaws, Voyage of the Damned is a thoroughly entertaining Christmas adventure. It has action, heart, and plenty of Christmas spirit mixed in with the science fiction spectacle. While it might not be the most groundbreaking Doctor Who story, it's a fun and festive watch that earns a solid 8 out of 10.

Doctor Who: Last of the Time Lords (2007) Season 3, Episode 13

An Epic Yet Flawed Finale

[9/10 · 4 April 2024]

Last of the Time Lords"is the culmination of an explosive series, a grand finale filled with heart, spectacle, and a few unfortunate stumbles. It's a flawed but unforgettable conclusion, deserving of a strong 9 out of 10.

This episode brings the full force of John Simm's unhinged Time Lord to the screen. His Master is a chillingly delightful mix of cunning and manic energy, making him a memorable foe. The Doctor, pushed to his limit, is forced to make impossible choices, showcasing Tennant's range as we see his joy and idealism tested like never before.

The sheer scope of the episode is impressive. The Doctor's imprisoned, the Earth is conquered, and the stakes have never been higher. It's visually ambitious with battles on a grand scale and some fantastic special effects (given the time). The supporting cast, particularly Martha and her family, offer powerful moments of resilience and hope that ground the story.

Where things stumble is in trying to cram too much into the runtime. Plot resolutions, especially the final defeat of the Master, feel overly convenient and rushed after such careful build-up. Thematically, certain ideas, like the Doctor's near-deification by the end, feel a bit muddled.

Despite some flaws in execution, Last of the Time Lords delivers on the emotional core. The consequences of the Doctor's victory are devastating, leaving a bittersweet note that lingers long after. It's an imperfect yet ambitious ending that successfully caps off a thrilling season.

This episode is a must-watch for fans of the Tenth Doctor era. Its strengths - high stakes, emotional performances, and a thrilling villain - more than make up for the occasional messy moment, leaving a lasting impression on the legacy of Doctor Who.

Doctor Who: The Sound of Drums (2007) Season 3, Episode 12

A Chilling Masterclass in Suspense

[9/10 · 4 April 2024]

The Sound of Drums takes the groundwork laid in Utopia and builds a thrilling and deeply unsettling episode. It expertly weaves together character development, political intrigue, and the Doctor facing his most cunning adversary yet, earning a well-deserved 9 out of 10.

John Simm steals the show as the Master. He's brilliant, chaotic, and genuinely terrifying in his power. His domination of Earth through manipulation and charisma is a chilling testament to his new incarnation. David Tennant's Doctor is pushed to his limit, with a fantastic mix of fury and cunning as he tries to outsmart the Master.

The supporting cast is excellent. Freema Agyeman's Martha gets her time to shine with an emotional and action-packed subplot that mirrors the Doctor's own plight. The inclusion of the Jones family adds a grounded, human element that amplifies the stakes of the Master's rule.

The Sound of Drums isn't just about action; it's psychological. The episode explores themes of manipulation, blind faith, and the resilience of hope even in the darkest of times. The Doctor is forced to make difficult choices, and the tension builds beautifully towards the epic cliffhanger.

If the episode has a weakness, it's that some of the plot resolutions in the finale feel a bit rushed in comparison to the setup here. However, that doesn't lessen the power of this individual episode.

The Sound of Drums is suspenseful, heartbreaking, and a chilling showcase of the Doctor facing a villain perfectly matched to him. It's a must-watch for any Doctor Who fan and earns a high place within the show's long history.

Doctor Who: Utopia (2007) Season 3, Episode 11

A Thrilling Launchpad for a Groundbreaking Finale

[9/10 · 4 April 2024]

Utopia sets the stage for one of Doctor Who's most iconic season finales, delivering a wild, twist-filled ride that earns it a solid 9 out of 10. It cleverly introduces new characters and mysteries, all while leaving you with a sense of exhilarating dread.

David Tennant is at his charming best, balancing the Doctor's boundless energy with an underlying darkness. Freema Agyeman's Martha continues to be a strong and proactive companion. The most thrilling addition, though, is John Simm as a charismatic and unhinged Master. His reveal is a jaw-dropping moment that fundamentally shifts the series' dynamic.

The episode's sci-fi premise - the end of the universe and a desperate attempt to reach "Utopia" - is suitably epic. Director Graeme Harper keeps the tension high, ramping up the action in the final act but leaving the best twists for the following episodes. It's not afraid to be a bit bleak, creating a palpable sense of hopelessness against an unknown enemy.

Where it slightly falters is in its supporting cast. Professor Yana and his companion Chantho could have used a bit more depth, particularly considering their significance later on. Some of the science also gets a bit wobbly if you think too hard about it.

Despite these minor hiccups, Utopia is a remarkable setup episode. Its pacing is excellent, the Master's return is a bombshell, and it delivers a satisfying mix of action, humor, and genuinely shocking twists. It's the first piece of an unforgettable three-parter and a must-watch for any fan of the revived series.

Doctor Who: Blink (2007) Season 3, Episode 10

A Masterwork of Timey-Wimey Terror

[10/10 · 4 April 2024]

Blink has solidified its place as one of Doctor Who's most beloved and critically-acclaimed episodes, and for good reason. It's a masterclass in suspense, a triumph of storytelling economy, and a testament to the show's ability to frighten and delight in equal measure. Here's why it earns an undeniable 10 out of 10.

At its heart, Blink is a horror story of the finest kind. The Weeping Angels, introduced here, are instantly iconic villains. Their fixed poses, frozen tears, and quantum-locked nature make for genuine chills that linger long after the episode ends.

The genius lies in the episode's structure. With the Doctor largely sidelined, the focus shifts to the fantastic Sally Sparrow. She's resourceful, charismatic, and the perfect stand-in for the audience. The timey-wimey plot unravels piece by piece, creating a puzzle that's as thrilling to solve as it is terrifying.

Director Hettie MacDonald expertly builds tension. The pacing is relentless, the jump-scares perfectly timed. The use of shadows and flickering lights ramps up the dread factor, and the DVD Easter egg sequences add an extra layer of chills.

What elevates Blink above simple horror is its heart. Sally's determination, her friendship with the endearing Larry, and the heartbreaking final scene with the aged Sally are emotionally resonant. Woven through the fear is a theme of the fleeting nature of time and the importance of seizing the moment.

Blink is a masterclass. It's clever, scary, and surprisingly poignant, proving that Doctor Who can be at its absolute best when stripping everything back and focusing on a perfectly crafted story. It's a must-watch for fans and newcomers alike and rightfully earns its place as one of Doctor Who's greatest achievements.

Doctor Who: The Family of Blood (2007) Season 3, Episode 9

A Triumphant Masterpiece

[10/10 · 4 April 2024]

The Family of Blood, the conclusion to the two-part Human Nature story arc, is not only a perfect episode of Doctor Who, but a masterpiece of television. It's a stunningly crafted tale of vengeance, sacrifice, and redemption, earning a flawless 10 out of 10.

This episode is the payoff to everything Human Nature set up, and it delivers with brutal brilliance. The Doctor is no longer the charming John Smith, but a vengeful force of nature. David Tennant's performance is raw and powerful, a reminder of why his Doctor is so beloved. The Family of Blood, previously menacing, now become chillingly tragic.

The action sequences are thrilling, interspersed with heartbreaking moments of loss and despair. The emotional stakes are sky-high. Martha Jones finally emerges as a hero in her own right, her strength and bravery a beacon in the darkness.

The episode doesn't shy away from its themes. It's about the cost of war, the terrible consequences of revenge, and the power of forgiveness. The ending, though bittersweet, is thematically perfect. It's both devastating and triumphant, the Doctor making a terrible choice to save lives.

Director Charles Palmer delivers a visual feast. The episode is beautifully shot, the action set pieces thrilling, and the quiet moments hauntingly intimate. Murray Gold's score is a masterpiece, building tension and underscoring the emotional devastation.

The Family of Blood isn't just a great episode, it's an example of storytelling at its finest. It's emotionally complex, visually stunning, and leaves you changed when the credits roll. It's a perfect ending to a near-perfect two-parter, a landmark in the history of Doctor Who.

Doctor Who: Human Nature (2007) Season 3, Episode 8

A Hauntingly Beautiful Exploration of Identity

[9/10 · 4 April 2024]

Human Nature, the first part of a gripping two-parter, is a Doctor Who masterpiece. This poignant tale about the nature of humanity, sacrifice, and hidden darkness transcends the genre, earning a resounding 9 out of 10.

Based on an old Doctor Who novel by Paul Cornell, the premise is brilliant: the Doctor transforms into a human named John Smith to hide from the relentless Family of Blood. David Tennant gives a career-defining dual performance, embodying both the Tenth Doctor's boundless energy and the quiet vulnerability of John Smith. Freema Agyeman shines as Martha, whose loyalty and independence are put to the ultimate test.

The 1913 setting is meticulously crafted, creating a stark contrast with the Doctor's usual adventures. The episode isn't action-packed, but the tension lies in the psychological battle between Smith's emerging memories and the Doctor's repressed nature.

Director Charles Palmer infuses the episode with an aching sadness and quiet dread. The Family of Blood are genuinely terrifying, their relentless pursuit making them some of the best villains of the modern era. Yet, there's a bittersweet beauty in Smith's blossoming romance with Joan Redfern, a woman who sees past his strange nature.

While the episode's deliberate pace may not suit everyone, those who relish deep character exploration and emotional resonance will be richly rewarded. The climax is a heart-wrenching look at choices and consequences.

Human Nature is a rare gem. More than just a sci-fi premise, it asks profound questions about identity, sacrifice, and the light and darkness that resides in all of us. Its melancholic tone, exquisite performances, and haunting atmosphere make it a true standout of David Tennant's era.

Doctor Who: 42 (2007) Season 3, Episode 7

A Claustrophobic Race Against Time

[7/10 · 4 April 2024]

42 is a solid Doctor Who episode with an engaging central concept and a fast-paced plot. It delivers suspense, humor, and some decent character moments, though it stumbles slightly under the weight of its premise, earning a 7 out of 10.

The central premise - the Doctor and Martha racing against a 42-minute countdown to stop a spaceship hurtling towards a sun - is excellent. The confined setting and ticking clock create a sense of real tension and urgency. The episode leans into claustrophobia, with good special effects and some creative camera angles to enhance the feeling of being trapped.

Both David Tennant and Freema Agyeman give committed performances. The Doctor is brilliant and resourceful as always, while Martha's courage and compassion come to the forefront. The supporting cast is likeable enough, even if slightly underdeveloped.

The episode cleverly incorporates humor, lightening the mood at key moments. The plot twists are a bit predictable, and the sun-creature, while a neat concept, could have been more menacing. The resolution feels a touch too easy and convenient, slightly underwhelming after such a well-paced build-up.

Despite some flaws, 42 is largely successful. It's a thrilling, self-contained story that showcases the Doctor's resourcefulness and quick thinking under pressure. While not the most profound episode, it's tightly paced, delivers a satisfying dose of suspense, and provides an entertaining watch.

Doctor Who: The Lazarus Experiment (2007) Season 3, Episode 6

A Mixed Bag of Concepts and Clunkiness

[6/10 · 4 April 2024]

The Lazarus Experiment is a Doctor Who episode with some fascinating ideas that, sadly, get buried under clumsy execution. While there are moments of brilliance and a touch of classic sci-fi horror, it ultimately feels bloated and uneven, earning a 6 out of 10.

Mark Gatiss excels in his role as the villainous Professor Lazarus. His performance is both charming and sinister, highlighting the dangerous allure of his rejuvenation technology. David Tennant and Freema Agyeman are solid as ever, playing off each other with witty banter.

The episode's strong point is the exploration of themes like aging, ambition, and monstrous transformations. The potential for a thoughtful sci-fi horror story is there, but the execution is where things fall apart.

The pacing is uneven, bogged down by unnecessary scenes and exposition. The monster, while visually interesting, lacks genuine menace (and has obviously not aged well). The plot gets unnecessarily complicated, and the resolution feels rushed and unsatisfying.

The Lazarus Experiment has its moments. The core concept is intriguing and Gatiss's performance is captivating. Sadly, these elements don't gel together to form a cohesive and satisfying episode.

While it does offer some food for thought, its clunky execution and missed potential make it a forgettable entry in Doctor Who's extensive catalog.

Doctor Who: Evolution of the Daleks (2007) Season 3, Episode 5

Ambition Outweighs Execution

[6/10 · 4 April 2024]

Evolution of the Daleks, the conclusion to the two-part Manhattan adventure, is an episode full of ambition that sadly falls short of its potential. It boasts interesting ideas and some strong performances, but ultimately collapses under its own weight, warranting a 6 out of 10.

The concept of the Cult of Skaro attempting a Dalek "evolution" holds promise. The Dalek-Human hybrid, while morally dubious, is an intriguing twist. David Tennant is fantastic as the Doctor, his righteous fury a highlight of the episode. However, it also marks the show's overuse of the "Doctor makes a difficult choice" trope, lessening the impact.

Unfortunately, the episode stumbles in execution. The plot is overly convoluted and rushed, leaving little time to really explore the ethical dilemmas it raises. Solomon is disappointingly one-note, and the supporting characters are largely underdeveloped. The final resolution is predictable and too rushed.

There are a few redeeming features. The visual of the iconic Dalek Sec in the Empire State Building is striking. Some emotional beats, particularly those involving Martha and Frank, do work well.

Evolution of the Daleks isn't without ambition, but it lacks the finesse to pull off its complicated plot and ethical questions. It feels messy, with great moments overshadowed by frustrating plot holes and an unsatisfying ending. While not a complete disaster, it's ultimately a missed opportunity.

Doctor Who: Daleks in Manhattan (2007) Season 3, Episode 4

A Flawes but Fun American Adventure

[7/10 · 4 April 2024]

Daleks in Manhattan, the first half of a two-parter, takes the iconic villains to 1930s New York City. While flawed, it's a visually impressive and generally entertaining episode with a few standout elements that earn it a 7 out of 10.

The setting is one of the episode's biggest strengths. The recreation of Depression-era New York and the Hooverville settlement adds a strong sense of atmosphere and social commentary. The visuals, like the Daleks in the sewers, are memorable. One of the central ideas, the Daleks turning humans into Pig Slaves, is deliciously dark, even if not fully explored.

The performances are generally strong. David Tennant is as charming and energetic as ever, and Freema Agyeman continues to impress as the capable Martha Jones. Tallulah steals every scene she's in with her sassy, no-nonsense energy, and Andrew Garfield's earnest Frank adds heart to the episode.

Where Daleks in Manhattan falls short is in its execution. Some of the plot points, particularly the Daleks' unnecessarily complex plan, feel convoluted. The pacing sags in places, and the resolution to the Pig Slave problem borders on silly.

Still, the episode shines despite its flaws. The atmosphere, the strong performances, and the core concept of the Daleks infiltrating a historical setting make it an enjoyable watch. While not a top-tier episode, it delivers an entertaining, if flawed, romp through New York's darkest days.

Doctor Who: Gridlock (2007) Season 3, Episode 3

A Unique Vision with Emotional Heart

[8/10 · 4 April 2024]

Gridlock is an ambitious Doctor Who episode that takes viewers on a thought-provoking journey into an eternally congested future. It's a unique and sometimes uneven story with a strong emotional core, earning it a solid 8 out of 10.

The premise alone is brilliant: an entire planet caught in an endless traffic jam. The visuals of the Motorway, layered and filled with tiny, vibrantly decorated cars-turned-homes, are both fascinating and a little bleak. The episode delves into themes of social division, hope, and the resilience of the human spirit.

David Tennant is particularly strong in this story. We see not only the Doctor's usual cleverness and charm, but also a weariness and underlying desperation that hints at a darker past. Freema Agyeman's Martha continues to shine, proving herself resourceful and compassionate. The introduction of Novice Hame, a compelling and tragic character, adds another layer of depth.

The iconic Face of Boe returns, offering another mystery and hinting at the Doctor's grand destiny. The villains, the Macra, aren't the show's most memorable, but the focus here is more on the societal commentary.

Where the episode loses some points is in pacing and a few overly sentimental moments. Certain plot elements could've been fleshed out a bit more. However, it more than makes up for it with its thought-provoking themes, memorable visuals, and strong performances.

Gridlock is not a perfect Doctor Who story, but it's one that lingers with you. Its unique setting, social commentary, and the moving final sequence solidify it as a memorable and ambitious outing for the Tenth Doctor.

Doctor Who: The Shakespeare Code (2007) Season 3, Episode 2

A Clever and Whimsical Time-Travel Romp

[8/10 · 4 April 2024]

The Shakespeare Code is a charming and witty Doctor Who romp, a love letter to Shakespeare infused with alien witchery and playful humor. It's more atmospheric than action-packed, but delivers enough timey-wimey fun to earn a solid 8 out of 10.

The episode's star attraction is its historical setting. The recreation of Elizabethan London feels vibrant and believable. Dean Lennox Kelly delivers a charismatic performance as the famous playwright, while the Tenth Doctor's unabashed fangirling is infectious.

The plot blends classic Doctor Who elements - shape-shifting witches, word-based magic - with a playful homage to Shakespeare's works. While it may lack the high stakes of some adventures, the joy lies in the clever dialogue and witty references. It's great fun for both casual fans and those with a deeper knowledge of the Bard.

Freema Ageyman's Martha gets a chance to shine, showing intelligence and independence beyond her initial infatuation with the Doctor. The Carrionite witches are genuinely creepy, adding a satisfying layer of menace.

The episode does falter a tad in its pacing and its reliance on convenient solutions when the Doctor unravels the witches' plan. Yet, these are minor hiccups in an otherwise entertaining and atmospheric adventure.

The Shakespeare Code isn't perfect, but it's a clever and enjoyable celebration of the Bard. It offers a lighthearted mystery, a historical atmosphere, and plenty of witty banter. For those looking for a fun mix of aliens and iambic pentameter, this is a delightful watch.