I'm a big Indiana Jones fan. I have the first three on DVD, and have watched them maybe 100 times total. Needless to say Raiders of the Lost Ark gets the most plays.
Compared to those movies, Kingdom of the Crystal Skull was seemingly written and directed by a totally different group of people.
In the first five minutes of Raiders of the Lost Ark, maybe half a dozen lines are spoken. It's all mystery and leaves the audience to figure things out for themselves.
In the first five minutes of Kingdom of the Crystal Skull there had already been dozens of cheesy lines, and the majority of the bad guys' plot had already been revealed in nauseating detail straight from the characters' mouths.
The characters are all there, though some of them shouldn't have been. The Marion and Mac characters were completely superfluous and added nothing to the plot, except to fill holes in it, in Marion's case.
The important characters, like Indiana, Mutt, and the ruskie that Cate Blanchett plays do a good enough job and give it that sense of adventure that is otherwise forced by increasingly unrealistic predicaments. I just wish Blanchett's character could have held a candle in the intimidation department compared to the Nazis in the first or third Jones installment.
The movie was also distractingly self-aware, giving a tedious amount of screen time to nods to the previous films, as opposed to playing on its own merits. The music was also an almost entirely recycled amalgam of the previous three films.
That could be a good thing for some people though. It's just that most of those nods to the previous films are about Raiders of the Lost Ark, manifested through petty, forced relationship squabbles between Indy and Marion.
On its own merits, the film falls flat. The movie starts out with many similarities to Raiders, but the plot then becomes convoluted and far fetched, and as a consequence of that most of the dialog is spent explaining what's happening in the current scene, and what's going to happen next.
Almost nothing happens without being explained directly by a character in the scene, almost like George Lucas wanted to make sure first graders would be able to keep up. But the plot turns so much supposition into unbelievable reality that it's hard to keep following without asking why.
The smart, dryly wrought mix of drama and comedy that made the original so special is tossed aside in favor of lame one liners and pseudo-emotional power plays.
Many of the action scenes are either logically flawed or extraneous. When Indiana Jones tries to evade a hail of machine gun fire in one scene, he essentially runs directly in the line of fire when he could easily have jumped two feet sideways and ran behind a barrier. When a sword fight scene breaks out during a chase, the fight keeps going even after one of the characters gets what he wants, as if lengthening the runtime of an already stale sword fight would somehow make it more intense.
That seems to be the philosophy with the plot as well. It just goes on and on. It doesn't intensify. It doesn't reconnect with itself at any point. The plot never builds toward anything. It just runs through a scene and then switches gears. You're only really told about what's going to happen next once the scene you're in is about to end. It doesn't build tension and then release it, because there's no tension, just confusion and then a quick scene cut.
Apparently the producers thought it would be acceptable to turn it into a kid-friendly film by disappointing the rest of the viewers with CGI monkeys and prairie dogs too. That monkey in Raiders did an admirable job. Why not just bring him back? Well, aside from the fact that he's probably dead by now.
Despite all this, The Kingdom is still worth visiting, but only to deepen your love for the original three films in the foursome, and to deepen your hatred of Spielberg and Lucas for screwing up a good thing.
This movie could have stuck with the style of the other films, and turned out a winner even if it plagiarized the others heavily. Instead it eschewed the tried and true 1980's style epic film- making and instead tried to capture modern, presumably intellectually inept viewers with big explosions, worn out lowbrow humor, cartoon animals, and a total disregard for physics or reality in general.
Of the four films, I'd put this at a solid #4. It's still better than most action/adventure movies, but it's not as good as the other three in the series.
But my opinion might change, since I plan on watching it again. Hopefully it's better the second time.
6 out of 14 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends