Although this review doesn't contain spoilers as such, it does outline small parts of the overall plot as well as some of the character traits.
As you might know, this show is about a conman who escapes from prison, is then caught by the FBI and has to help them solve crimes as part of his plea deal. The main reason to watch this show is the character of Neal Caffrey – and Matt Bomer plays him to perfection. He's cool, handsome, charming, witty, clever, confident, ambitious, and well dressed. But he's still flawed 'cause he has problems settling down and finding real connections with people. Especially initially I enjoyed the mismatch between Neal Caffrey and FBI agent Peter Burke. Burke is goofy and pessimistic and says that so and so can't be done, and we just have to do things the hard way, whereas Caffrey shows us that these things are actually possible. Part of the charm of the Caffrey character is his abilities. It's fun to watch him forge signatures, pull a scam or do other tricks and then explain how. At times his tricks, and the episodes' plots, do become a little bit too silly and slapstick-like. Too many characters in these situations are too stupid, and it's a little bit too coincidental that everything works out exactly as planned. So, not everything is credible as the scripts are not always that well-written.
What I also like about this show is the theme of being torn between getting exactly what you want, albeit getting it illegally, and settling into a normal, legal, life. Neal Caffrey has always been a conman, and it is second nature to him to get what he wants by illegal means. When working for the FBI he has to fight this urge, but settling into a legal life also gives peace of mind. He doesn't have to lie and run. He's trying to tell himself that he just wants to escape the trappings of a normal dull life, but does he truly believe this? At least, experience seems to prove him wrong on many accounts.
Although I don't know exactly how TV production works in Hollywood, it is my impression that the network sees if a show is a success and then they grant another season. If that season is also a success, then another season, and so on. Starting out with a script for e.g. 12 episodes that finishes completely after the last episode seems rare. Needless to say (so I'll say it anyway), the latter is the type I generally like the best. So with this let's-see-if-this-season-is-a-success-method, TV shows with an ongoing plot line often turn into perpetual motion machines where they have to come up with more and more bizarre/silly plot twists to keep it going. "Alias" and "Prison Break" are perfect examples of this. "White Collar" is becoming the same. I've watched all four seasons, but the ongoing plot line (which was always the best part of the plot) has gradually become more silly and less important, and the show focuses more on separate cases that needed to be solved in each episode (and, of course, they solve the case every single time). Each season has ended with a big finale, but a few episodes into the next season everything has returned to normal. Then what's the point in continuing this show? It has become a bit like Prison Break season three: "We break out – TONIGHT!", end of episode. Then next episode: "Nah, we have to wait until tomorrow". Then at the end of the episode: "We break out – TONIGHT!", end of episode. And so on. If this show didn't have an ongoing plot line it would be much less frustrating. The problem is that it promises evolution throughout the series but rarely delivers (or at least does it too slowly). Often throughout all four seasons only a few minutes in the beginning and end of each episode dealt with the ongoing plot line, and it seemed that almost every time there was a big thrilling conflict in the plot or between the characters, this would be dealt with in a few minutes in the next episode, so the show could return to business as usual. Part of the suspense is of course only getting to know the details little by little, but there must be limits to how long you can keep people waiting before they lose interest. In the end, there wasn't much difference between watching an episode from season 1, 2, 3 or 4 of "White Collar".
And honestly, there's no need to watch this show to see the team solve cases. Certain other shows manage to do that with better scripts and more surprises. The criminals get caught a bit too easily in this show, and when they are taken into custody at the end of each episode I often sit there with the felling of "was that really it?". If the upcoming season five has not had some changes to the overall plot, and it's still just Caffrey and Burke solving cases, then this show has become redundant. I also noticed that the amount of viewers have dropped consistently with each new season, so I'm apparently not the only one who has been discouraged with how this show has developed.
Season four ended recently, and season five is scheduled for the autumn of 2013. Season four, of course, ended with a big finale. I will probably watch the first few episodes of season five to see what happens, but I already have my theories and I'm pretty sure that all the problems will have been solved within the first couple of episodes so everything can return to normal (as it did with the ending of season three/beginning of season four). I assume nothing dramatic will happen to the ongoing plot line until the show is cancelled and we can finally see an end to the story.
1 out of 3 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends