In France, Roland Emmerich and his career, since his very beginning behind a camera always criticised on mostly every level (stupidity of his movies, lowbrainer, Teutonic copycat with not an inch of a new idea and a pile of rusty crap to sell...) by the "wannabe independent-spirit" (lol...) "expert" press, for example my beloved Mad Movies... and Co.
After his first (and almost unknown for most of the audience) effort, the very ambitious SF & student film called "The Noah's Ark Principle", almost every film "directed by..." got systematically bad reviews (politely said...).
Now the question is: Why? Let me guess: as evreybody knows, France isn't (nor has ever been) in the past centuries quiet much fond of Germany, his language and history, and there may be here and there some solid reasons, of course ! Unfortunately, history and Art have sometimes been confused, especially by some media positions.
As a matter of fact, the economic and artistic expansion of this (mean/enemy, as GB as a matter of fact, and Holland, and...etc...) country has been faced sceptically by many many people. And there has always been some kind a strange jealousy since.
Another explanation may be that since 1990, the year in which Moon 44 has been made in Germany , French SF didn't even exist otherwise than as a concept or has been reduced to cinematographic "WTF-Wonders" like Terminus (1986 directed by Pierre William Glenn)... Hum. Yes, maybe, just maybe (the situation hasn't change a lot since, by the way...).
Therefore, this modest tiny little SF Production (6 million D-Marks as budget!) called Moon 44 and directed by Emmerich has been literally dismembered as some kind of copy material assembled by "wannabe Jim -Aliens- Cameron" newbie Roland! WOW folks! I can remember clearly what came up about this one before and after the former (and cult!) French Avoriaz Fantastic Film Festival in 1991... and so I didn't go to see it and has instead of been waiting 31 years to get a proper copy ('cause just newly released)!
And what a pity it is for the audience! Even more: a shame. Because even if Moon 44 isn't an accomplishment as ALIENS, OUTLAND, BLADE RUNNER, THUNDERBIRDS and the later released TIMECOP (oups!) and FORTRESS (does he even one bit of a second try to be???), it is a great B movie with plenty of joy, fun and charm: YES, for sure, it is!
For example, for such a "super-low-low-cost" budget-production, the models and special effects are as a matter of fact mesmerizingly well done! Made by Emmerich himself and Volker Engler (Oscar winner for Independence day!), the lovely-detailed miniature effects are still astonishing, even for today's standards!
Karl Walter Lindenlaub (UNIVERSAL SOLDIER, STARGATE, ID4, GODZILLA. ROB ROY, THE JACKAL), as a mostly unknown artist, also did a tremendous job, allowing for instance the sets to shine bright in their functional and gloomy/dirty environment (a foreign, outer world moon exploited by huge corporations who send poor settlers there to create a digging colony providing new energy resources, officially for our dying Earth...) as such a picture request it (it's a Dark SF concept we are talkin' about here: cf. The rape scene of the kiddie by the sic Scooter character...). Great visuals all along the movie, even if any type of audience can figure out the restrictions here and there...
And what else can we say? What about the cast? No real "Star" in sight? Ok: But isn't it always a delightful pleasure to see once again solid B-movie veterans as Michael Paré (STREETS OF FIRE., PHILADELPHIA EXPERIMENT..), Brian Thompson (TERMINATOR, COBRA...). Stephen Geoffrey's (FRIGHT NIGHT...), Leon Rippy (TRACK 29, YOUNG GUNS 2, KUFFS, STARGATE...) and the one and unique Malcolm McDowell (CLOCKWORK ORANGE, and, euh, DOOMSDAY...lol...) in the same pic??? Ten times of course it is! Especially if they all seem to have some good fun playing their parts, as it is obviously the case here! Even youngster Dean Devlin (the future screenwriter and producer on R. Emmerich most famous blockbusters and director of GEOSTORM) ist giving an enjoyable performance, especially for this kind of mostly annoying type of sidekick in a otherwise gritty movie...
Of course, this movie has it flaws, especially the small story, but who cares? All considered, how is it possible not to give this fine little movie some more credit (and respect once and for all for his director who did all by himself, in Germany-Europe for instance!) because we all know that we are living on a dying planet (if things go on like they do until now, of course...) and that our governments (corporative thinking always on it's way too here, yes sir!) are already looking for outer world solutions (Trash evacuation, new energy and life sources etc...). Is the director somehow visionary in it's own ways?
As already mentioned, this movie isn't a "clean", enjoyable and in the "usual politically correctness swimming" kind of tale: YES, Mr Emmerich is emerging it's audience in a world (somehow even our actual world?) in which governments (relayed by the chosen Corporative Spirit!) use no less than children to take responsibilities for kamikaze high-tech helicopters driven by HS-convicts sent on a desolate moon too die there defending there capitalistic interests! Wow, so much for Roland Emmerich-filmo's lack of background clarity, pertinence and criticism of the ugly aspects of capitalism gone wild.
Of course, don't understand me wrong, Moon 44 is "just" a B-Movie and can't compete with its illustrious predecessors (once again, does he only try to do so?), but a delightful, fun and classic/classy B-Movie with a heart in it's cove, lots of love for details and old fashioned, beautiful and various SFX of all kind, a good cast and some violent action too. What is there not to love?
In other words, if you are looking for the perfect Saturday night movie session film, don't look any further: here you get it! Find a good copy (in its original ratio 2:35:1), sit back/lay back and ENJOY this old fashioned, 0% CGI, action packed, low-budget/ major results SF - classic from the early Nineties. Yeah, just be entertained by the SHOW (and for former movie students without a dime, the master class) here!
P. S.: By the way, MM just published an interview of Roland Emmerich (?) and brought us the DVD-copy of this wonderful movie I missed to watch years ago because of their own continuously massively destructive reviews (??). They even liked Moonfall (???), arguing "He finally got us. Respect!"... Lol... Bienvenu en France, le pays de mon enfance!...
P. S. S.: To mister Del Toro: Haven't you seen (and of course ENZZZZOYED A quiet A LOT!!!) this early effort by Roland emmerich before directing your magnificent and underestimated PACIFIC RIM?...lol...
0 out of 4 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends