This is the first time I am going to disagree with IMDb's ratings.
Hachi should never have been made into a film. My main reason being that a dog and its master's relationship is not something that can be completely explained, analyzed or documented. I don't know the details of the true story, but I'm pretty sure not many people do - as it happened in the 1920s in Japan. This just seems to be another example of American filmmakers trying to cash in on someone else's story.
While the acting wasn't abysmal, it was pretty damn Hallmark-y. The dog- vision was a bad decision, as it didn't add anything meaningful to the already sentiment-laden mood. This mood pervaded the entire film - which had no real emotional ups or downs. Not helping matters was the monotonous, unremarkable piano theme that never paused while dog or owner was on screen.
Supporting cast were typecast and dull. Several big plot holes as well.
All in all very disappointing.
Hachi should never have been made into a film. My main reason being that a dog and its master's relationship is not something that can be completely explained, analyzed or documented. I don't know the details of the true story, but I'm pretty sure not many people do - as it happened in the 1920s in Japan. This just seems to be another example of American filmmakers trying to cash in on someone else's story.
While the acting wasn't abysmal, it was pretty damn Hallmark-y. The dog- vision was a bad decision, as it didn't add anything meaningful to the already sentiment-laden mood. This mood pervaded the entire film - which had no real emotional ups or downs. Not helping matters was the monotonous, unremarkable piano theme that never paused while dog or owner was on screen.
Supporting cast were typecast and dull. Several big plot holes as well.
All in all very disappointing.
Tell Your Friends