Reviews

2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Outstanding! One of Miyazaki's Best.
15 July 2005
WritelySo's review has said it better than I ever could. So I'll put my two cents worth in anyway.

Of the three big name and one independent feature films I've seen in the past six weeks, this is the best. The first thing that catches your eye (ahem!) is Miyazaki's wonderful animation. His scenes are to film what Hal Foster did to the Sunday comics. They are colorful, lifelike, have great attention to detail and are... well, just beautiful.

A late 19th European setting done to a fare-thee-well by a Japanese artist? You bet. He did it in Porco Rosso and he's done it at least as well here. That's another recommended Miyazaki masterpiece after this one charms you.

I was quickly caught up in the film. The characters are believable and the voices, well it's a shame to call it dubbing. I doubt it was easy to match English dialog to a Japanese film but they did a superb job. What this means to you is that you never, ever notice. The voices are appropriate to the characters and, I think, really enrich the character's personalities.

While kids will appreciate the animation and action, Howl's Moving Castle is really for adults. Take your kids to see it. When they see it again in ten years, they'll see an entirely new film all over again.

If there's any justice in the Academy Awards, this should get Miyazaki another one - I think it's even better than Spirited Away.

When they're worth it (rarely) I pay attention to film scores, and Joe Hisaishi has written one well matched to this fine film.

Did I make the point that I LOVED this film? I hope you do too.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Porco Rosso (1992)
10/10
Great story, wonderful characters, fantastic animation
8 July 2005
First of all, I've never seen the title "Kurenai no buta" except on IMDb. The English title on my copy and all other references I've found on the web are "Porco Rosso". Outside Japan, that's the title to look for at the video store.

Let's see what we've got: an Italian Pig speaking Japanese, "Knock your socks off" aerial vistas, not one but two beautiful heroines, an Adriatic hotel that's actually a small island, better dialog than many "live" movies, sky pirates, even good music. How many films can claim all that?

Perhaps the most attractive character of the film, after you've gotten past the many obvious ones, is Myazaki's amazing imagination which pervades all aspects of the production.

To me, the storyline is reminiscent of Hollywood's Golden Age. The characters are wonderful, even to an adult audience and, of course, high quality animation is the frosting on the cake.

After seeing Porco Rosso, I bought the DVD, and I hardly ever do that!
42 out of 50 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed