I love science fiction, and the more 'out-of-the-box' it is, the more I like it. I also enjoy a good character-driven drama, once I believe deep, believable characters are essential for a good show. Moreover, I am not into action flicks, so I don't care about amazing special effects, electrifying soundtrack, explosions, etc.
My friends know my tastes, and so they recommended me to watch Battlestar Galactica. One of them even said it was the best sci-fi show he has ever watched. I decided to read some IMDb reviews and the sentence 'the best sci-fi show ever' was written in many of them.
Of course I got excited. Of course my expectations were very high -- and I know that high expectations often lead to higher disappointments... And I must say: I got really disappointed.
At first, naturally, I tried to blame pm my high hopes. As the episodes progressed, though, I started to notice that it was not my fault. This show is actually pretty lame and pretentious, and the fandom created by this series puzzles me. I think I just watched it until the end as a failed attempt to understand why people actually enjoy this.
I will try to make my point without spoiling anything, as a warning to other newcomers.
1. It is clear that the characters were supposed to be complex and believable, but they are just inconsistent, irritating and, in some cases, hateable -- and I am talking about main characters, the ones we were supposed to care about;
2. I know people are sometimes contradictory, but in Battlestar Galactica they are way too often. Someone just changing his or her mind is a recurrent used artifice for a plot twist, which is really cheap, to say the least;
3. The backstory of most characters is very inelaborate and badly explored;
4. Battlestar Galactica is a battleship, and it's got the worst army the universe has ever seen. These soldiers don't follow orders and entirely lack proper discipline. They keep on fighting with each other, partying, having sex (there are men and women in the army), playing cards (including a variation of strip poker), and getting drunk with whiskey (where the hell do they get all of that?);
5. Most annoying romances ever;
6. In most cases, the plans of action are pretty pathetic and laugheable;
7. There are some moral, religious, and political debates. I usually would enjoy that. Unfortunately, most of them are pretty lame and almost dumb;
8. Direction is not as phenomenal as stated by some reviewers. In addition to several notable continuity issues, some really important plot revelations were done in a very sloppy fashion. And I don't want to be picky, but the appellant exaggerated facial zoom in is quite annoying;
9. The main plot is interesting, but more predictable than I expected. Interestingly, all unexpected things are so senseless that they are just left unexplained;
10. At least for me, the notably Americanized culture doesn't fit well in the plot. Kudos for the original 1978 series;
11. The soundtrack is different, which is a good thing. However, it is forgettable and, at some moments, it doesn't fit the mood of the scene;
12. There are too many unimportant episodes;
13. It is scientifically inaccurate.
However, there are some positive aspects:
1. There are some really talented actors (and sometimes I felt really bad for them);
2. Aesthetically, there are more positive than negative aspects, despite cylon taste for high fashion and that every piece of paper is octagonal (what a waste!);
3. As I stated before, the main idea is pretty interesting (even though the key elements are not exactly original). I wish they didn't move away from it so often.
I probably forgot some things, but these are my general impressions on Battlestar Galactica. Just watch it if you are really curious and plenty of time. I also suggest you to look for some guide containing which episodes are skippable (there are some around the internet).
My friends know my tastes, and so they recommended me to watch Battlestar Galactica. One of them even said it was the best sci-fi show he has ever watched. I decided to read some IMDb reviews and the sentence 'the best sci-fi show ever' was written in many of them.
Of course I got excited. Of course my expectations were very high -- and I know that high expectations often lead to higher disappointments... And I must say: I got really disappointed.
At first, naturally, I tried to blame pm my high hopes. As the episodes progressed, though, I started to notice that it was not my fault. This show is actually pretty lame and pretentious, and the fandom created by this series puzzles me. I think I just watched it until the end as a failed attempt to understand why people actually enjoy this.
I will try to make my point without spoiling anything, as a warning to other newcomers.
1. It is clear that the characters were supposed to be complex and believable, but they are just inconsistent, irritating and, in some cases, hateable -- and I am talking about main characters, the ones we were supposed to care about;
2. I know people are sometimes contradictory, but in Battlestar Galactica they are way too often. Someone just changing his or her mind is a recurrent used artifice for a plot twist, which is really cheap, to say the least;
3. The backstory of most characters is very inelaborate and badly explored;
4. Battlestar Galactica is a battleship, and it's got the worst army the universe has ever seen. These soldiers don't follow orders and entirely lack proper discipline. They keep on fighting with each other, partying, having sex (there are men and women in the army), playing cards (including a variation of strip poker), and getting drunk with whiskey (where the hell do they get all of that?);
5. Most annoying romances ever;
6. In most cases, the plans of action are pretty pathetic and laugheable;
7. There are some moral, religious, and political debates. I usually would enjoy that. Unfortunately, most of them are pretty lame and almost dumb;
8. Direction is not as phenomenal as stated by some reviewers. In addition to several notable continuity issues, some really important plot revelations were done in a very sloppy fashion. And I don't want to be picky, but the appellant exaggerated facial zoom in is quite annoying;
9. The main plot is interesting, but more predictable than I expected. Interestingly, all unexpected things are so senseless that they are just left unexplained;
10. At least for me, the notably Americanized culture doesn't fit well in the plot. Kudos for the original 1978 series;
11. The soundtrack is different, which is a good thing. However, it is forgettable and, at some moments, it doesn't fit the mood of the scene;
12. There are too many unimportant episodes;
13. It is scientifically inaccurate.
However, there are some positive aspects:
1. There are some really talented actors (and sometimes I felt really bad for them);
2. Aesthetically, there are more positive than negative aspects, despite cylon taste for high fashion and that every piece of paper is octagonal (what a waste!);
3. As I stated before, the main idea is pretty interesting (even though the key elements are not exactly original). I wish they didn't move away from it so often.
I probably forgot some things, but these are my general impressions on Battlestar Galactica. Just watch it if you are really curious and plenty of time. I also suggest you to look for some guide containing which episodes are skippable (there are some around the internet).
Tell Your Friends