Change Your Image
larryg-2
Reviews
The Lumière Brothers' First Films (1996)
Fascinating Films/Narration A Drawback
The clarity and composition of the Lumiere films are amazing, given that they were made in 1895 and 1896. Both in terms of preservation and the ingenuity of the cameramen (see the shot of the rowers at sea and the tracking shot of the running children using a cart as a dolly are just two example), they are superior to the Edison films from the same time. (See Kino's multi-disc Edison set.) With that said, Bertrand Travernier's seemingly unscripted narration is a decided drawback. His stammering comments do little to put the films into historical context. The fact that he finds many of them amusing and hilarious is not insightful or interesting. Too bad the Lumiere Institution didn't put more care or scholarship into the narration. For an excellent film history project -- complete with historian interviews and extensive on-disc notes -- again, see Kino's multi-disc set of the early Edison films.
Nevertheless, the Lumiere films themselves are gems. Put on the mute button and enjoy. Some of the images are so crisp and life-like in motion that it's like time-travel to the 19th century.
The Panic Is On (1931)
Clever, funny short!
This classic Chase short features Depression-related gags including Charlie's suit (his everyday suit becomes a Sunday suit when turns around the hanger.) Another bit involves his walking down the street reading a newspaper which draws a crowd of over-the-shoulder readers. There's also a funny climax as Charlie thwarts the theft of $50,000 from the wealthy father of his love interest.
I've probably seen about 20 Charlie Chase shorts. I would rate "The Panic is On" among his best, along with "Girl Grief," "Nature in the Wrong," "Public Ghost #1," "Calling All Doctors" and "The Heckler." I highly recommend it.