Reviews

2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Sideways (2004)
9/10
beautifully acted comedy
20 March 2005
I think it would be fair to say that many if not most film lovers in the UK get annoyed with the American movie industry for wasting vast sums of money on overproduction, publicity and over paid stars.

Yet toiling away, almost unknown to most cinema-goers are directors and actors who produce exquisite gems like "Sideways". I thought it might be better than my favourite American film of recent times, "The Station Agent", but that would have been asking a little too much.

It did not have my total attention until about 5 minutes after the start when I became riveted with concentration. The cast was outstanding; I nearly said acted well, but they didn't seem to be acting at all, it was if someone was filming events as they happened.

Being a man, I was drooling over Virginia Madsen, if I am honest, but the two male leads were brilliant. It is always great to laugh at comedy, but the scene were the wallet is retrieved and the brief chase afterwards had the cinema helpless.

If the Oscars were distributed fairly, someone in this film deserved one.

Geoff Livesey
1 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
favourite film of the last few years
16 July 2004
I have never commented on any database about anything until now.

I wanted to find out more about the cast and Google raised this DB; I was delighted to see the customer comment facility. Reading a selection of comments I was astonished to find how much uniformity there was. Many of us seem to have had a similar experience.

I have seen the film twice. I enjoyed it so much that I thought perhaps it was because I was in the right mood and it would not stand scrutiny a second time. I enjoyed it, if anything, more on the second occasion. On both occasions when the film ended there was an audible groan of dismay from the audience that it finished long before they were ready.

It has not had a wide circulation in England and I have been a one man promotional bore encouraging friends to go to see it.

I thought that Lost in Translation would be my favourite of the last few years but it has been pushed out of the top slot.

I am surprise at a few of the comments from other contributors. "what is a coffee wagon doing in such a place", "poor script for Patricia Clarkson" etc.

For me the script, photography, acting, cutting and casting were perfect. Only one complaint- too short.

It is hard to pick the best performance and I will certainly change my mind next time I ask myself, but today I would go for Bobby Cannavale.

Geoff Livesey
155 out of 187 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed