The use of the Atomic Bomb on the Empire of Japan in 1945 by the United States was necessary to end the war and save millions of Japanese and American lives.
Why one may well ask did I find it necessary to quote every creditable scholar of the last century about an event of war in a review of a Sherlock Holmes movie? Because the makers of this film found it necessary to use it as a vehicle to criticize the aforementioned event as some kind of crime against humanity. It was not. The Empire of Japan was the crime against humanity.
In the course of the story the protagonist travels to post World War II Japan and is depicted being hosted by the kindest, gentlest and most polite people imaginable whereupon he tours Hiroshima and witnesses gape-mouthed the devastation - for no good reason. It was not elemental to the plot and served no purpose whatsoever. The Japanese of that era were not kind and gentle. They were a brutal militaristic people that enslaved a third of the planet and murdered millions upon millions under the boots of their bloodthirsty army.
Otherwise the film was perfectly charming. The landscape beautiful and the acting superb. What a pity that it was all wasted to make an absurd political statement.
If Marxist revisionist history is not your bag then you're sure to be insulted.
Why one may well ask did I find it necessary to quote every creditable scholar of the last century about an event of war in a review of a Sherlock Holmes movie? Because the makers of this film found it necessary to use it as a vehicle to criticize the aforementioned event as some kind of crime against humanity. It was not. The Empire of Japan was the crime against humanity.
In the course of the story the protagonist travels to post World War II Japan and is depicted being hosted by the kindest, gentlest and most polite people imaginable whereupon he tours Hiroshima and witnesses gape-mouthed the devastation - for no good reason. It was not elemental to the plot and served no purpose whatsoever. The Japanese of that era were not kind and gentle. They were a brutal militaristic people that enslaved a third of the planet and murdered millions upon millions under the boots of their bloodthirsty army.
Otherwise the film was perfectly charming. The landscape beautiful and the acting superb. What a pity that it was all wasted to make an absurd political statement.
If Marxist revisionist history is not your bag then you're sure to be insulted.
Tell Your Friends