When I first heard this was being made, I was excited, Monsters Inc is one of my top 10 favorite Pixar films and I've always wanted a sequel. When I heard it would be a series I was even more excited as there's so much you can expand upon, it sounded like The Office but animated (and I mean that in a good way). When I started watching it though, the rest of the series after the first 2 episodes made me feel betrayed.
It's actually pretty simple as to why this show could've been an easy win but sadly isn't, Mike and Sulley (AKA the main characters of this franchise) are reduced to playing secondary roles. Despite still being in every episode the show doesn't focus on them as much as it should and only pop up in a special end segment most of the time, but that in of itself isn't even the main issue, it's the characters the show does primarily focus on.
The show is instead about a scarer named Tylor who was invited to come work for Monsters Inc days before they switched from scream energy to laugh energy and is instead lodged to work with the Monsters Inc Facilities Team (or MIFT as the characters call it) and they're not likable characters.
Tylor himself is not only a generic straightman who lacks personality, but he is also a passive-aggressive and manipulative jerk who always lies his way into getting what he wants without caring about how it affects other people, and somehow he's still the most tolerable of the MIFT members.
Fritz and Val are a pair of socially handicapped cultists who pretend they know Tylor better than they actually do and are obsessed with making him happy to be in MIFT permanently even though he's only there until he's studied at Mike's Comedy Classes enough to qualify being on the laugh floor. This makes them come off as creepy weirdos who won't listen to Tylor and just want him in their club by force which I'll talk more about later.
Cutter's gimick of telling stories of how deceased employees died at the company overstays its welcome thus resulting her in being the most forgettable character with nothing to ride home about.
Duncan is basically a kid-friendly Dwight Schrute who sees Tylor as a threat to his goal of taking Fritz's job when he retires. Despite Tylor explaining to him multiple times he doesn't want Fritz's job Duncan continues to belittle, threaten, and initiate competitions with him thinking Tylor is lying. There's even an episode where he learns not to be a jerk and grows to see the value in Tylor only for the next episode to have him go back to acting like a jerk and that the previous episode never happened, which makes him look like a jerk who can't be reasoned with and will harass Tylor whether he has a reason to or not.
Every episode has MIFT given a task to complete, Tylor will then discover something that he sees as a shortcut to the laugh floor only to get accidentally exposed and emotionally manipulated by Fritz and Val, then Tylor does what the show interprets as the earnest thing to do after learning his lesson and then decides to be more content with being part of MIFT, ending on a quick lesson from Mike during his comedy class. It doesn't work because the folks at MIFT aren't able to make you sympathize with them what with how ignorant and creepy they are towards Tylor despite the show always wanting him to look like the bad guy and them to look like the victims.
I will say what keeps the show from being completely bad are whenever we focus on anything connected to the movies. Mike and Sulley unsurprisingly steal the show but whenever we get to see the other characters like Celia, the janitors, the comedy class segments, and even an episode that brings back the Adorable Snowman, that's when the show gets good. It expands upon small details from the movies in a clever way while also providing some nice closure here and there, which is exactly what the primary focus of the show should've been if not for however much money it would've cost for Billy Crystal and John Goodman to record more lines for the show.
There are also a couple new characters that are a nice addition: Roz's identical twin sister Rose takes her place which is just a nice way for them to still use Roz's signature humor despite her being needed as the head of the CDA and the jokes with her always land. Then there's Gary who's basically Mike but blue and is voiced by the always charismatic and hilarious Gabriel Inglecias, the rivalry between him and Mike is cutely entertaining and is also a nice throwback to Buzz Lightyear dealing with his utility belt counterpart in Toy Story 2.
If the show did primarily focus on Mike, Sulley, and other aspects that were connected to and expand upon the movies or at the very least either focus on characters who are worth caring for or fix the issues with Tylor and MIFT, I would recommend you watch it.
As it is, if you don't connect it to the movies, you're left with a problematic and uncomfortable version of The Office with a main cast that consists of characters who are either boring, creepy, or unlikable and get more screen time than the side and background characters who are unironically more likable and interesting but don't get as much focus. If you do connect it to the movies, it's a pointless sequel that's not worth your time outside of the few good moments that you'll wish it focused more on.
It's actually pretty simple as to why this show could've been an easy win but sadly isn't, Mike and Sulley (AKA the main characters of this franchise) are reduced to playing secondary roles. Despite still being in every episode the show doesn't focus on them as much as it should and only pop up in a special end segment most of the time, but that in of itself isn't even the main issue, it's the characters the show does primarily focus on.
The show is instead about a scarer named Tylor who was invited to come work for Monsters Inc days before they switched from scream energy to laugh energy and is instead lodged to work with the Monsters Inc Facilities Team (or MIFT as the characters call it) and they're not likable characters.
Tylor himself is not only a generic straightman who lacks personality, but he is also a passive-aggressive and manipulative jerk who always lies his way into getting what he wants without caring about how it affects other people, and somehow he's still the most tolerable of the MIFT members.
Fritz and Val are a pair of socially handicapped cultists who pretend they know Tylor better than they actually do and are obsessed with making him happy to be in MIFT permanently even though he's only there until he's studied at Mike's Comedy Classes enough to qualify being on the laugh floor. This makes them come off as creepy weirdos who won't listen to Tylor and just want him in their club by force which I'll talk more about later.
Cutter's gimick of telling stories of how deceased employees died at the company overstays its welcome thus resulting her in being the most forgettable character with nothing to ride home about.
Duncan is basically a kid-friendly Dwight Schrute who sees Tylor as a threat to his goal of taking Fritz's job when he retires. Despite Tylor explaining to him multiple times he doesn't want Fritz's job Duncan continues to belittle, threaten, and initiate competitions with him thinking Tylor is lying. There's even an episode where he learns not to be a jerk and grows to see the value in Tylor only for the next episode to have him go back to acting like a jerk and that the previous episode never happened, which makes him look like a jerk who can't be reasoned with and will harass Tylor whether he has a reason to or not.
Every episode has MIFT given a task to complete, Tylor will then discover something that he sees as a shortcut to the laugh floor only to get accidentally exposed and emotionally manipulated by Fritz and Val, then Tylor does what the show interprets as the earnest thing to do after learning his lesson and then decides to be more content with being part of MIFT, ending on a quick lesson from Mike during his comedy class. It doesn't work because the folks at MIFT aren't able to make you sympathize with them what with how ignorant and creepy they are towards Tylor despite the show always wanting him to look like the bad guy and them to look like the victims.
I will say what keeps the show from being completely bad are whenever we focus on anything connected to the movies. Mike and Sulley unsurprisingly steal the show but whenever we get to see the other characters like Celia, the janitors, the comedy class segments, and even an episode that brings back the Adorable Snowman, that's when the show gets good. It expands upon small details from the movies in a clever way while also providing some nice closure here and there, which is exactly what the primary focus of the show should've been if not for however much money it would've cost for Billy Crystal and John Goodman to record more lines for the show.
There are also a couple new characters that are a nice addition: Roz's identical twin sister Rose takes her place which is just a nice way for them to still use Roz's signature humor despite her being needed as the head of the CDA and the jokes with her always land. Then there's Gary who's basically Mike but blue and is voiced by the always charismatic and hilarious Gabriel Inglecias, the rivalry between him and Mike is cutely entertaining and is also a nice throwback to Buzz Lightyear dealing with his utility belt counterpart in Toy Story 2.
If the show did primarily focus on Mike, Sulley, and other aspects that were connected to and expand upon the movies or at the very least either focus on characters who are worth caring for or fix the issues with Tylor and MIFT, I would recommend you watch it.
As it is, if you don't connect it to the movies, you're left with a problematic and uncomfortable version of The Office with a main cast that consists of characters who are either boring, creepy, or unlikable and get more screen time than the side and background characters who are unironically more likable and interesting but don't get as much focus. If you do connect it to the movies, it's a pointless sequel that's not worth your time outside of the few good moments that you'll wish it focused more on.
Tell Your Friends