I was following this title since it was first announced (the article comparing it to Blade Runner got me hooked cause I was riding a Blade Runner 2049 high), but once I heard an article calling it Netflix's "Game of Thrones" I was hyped to see it for possibly all the wrong reasons.
Whenever a network, distributor, or platform says "It's the next Game of Thrones", I know it's going to be an utter mess so I have to see it. Altered Carbon didn't disappoint in that regard, but it did have some elements that made me recommend it to my family (but none of my colleagues).
The visuals are cool and sometimes even great, the acting is well-done, and the story is mysterious and complex without getting out of hand. That being said, it's a bit of a snore-fest and feels way too much like Television. (I could easily see this show on FX but not HBO and possibly not even Showtime).
The action, for a show about dispensable bodies, rarely is engaging, extreme, or innovative. The characters are barely likable and the majority of the good guys feel whinny. The main character is interesting and shows his complex nature further along into the show, but still is undercut by this whole 'anti-hero' and 'stoic' manner that seems to be enforced in detective-esque shows (the Batman complex if you shall). The dialogue is a big issue. What GoT does right is the dialogue, it's interesting and revealing, it keeps us really listening and obsessive, trying to get us to decipher the characters intentions and thus the plot. I love it when shows are trying to be passed off as the new GoT because they forget the simple fact that even if your show is visually amazing, well acted, and in all essence good, if it doesn't have the writing down to the small details, it won't be GoT. It can be highly successful (The Walking Dead, Stranger Things, MadMen), but it won't be GoT.
Watch Altered Carbon if you want to, it's fun and I'm actually into watching the next season. It's better than Sense8 (the bar is so low) and worse than Stranger Things, in the context of Netflix shows. But, as per my rating, it's not anything special nor great on its own.
3 out of 7 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends