It's rare to see the iconic Cary Grant get second billing, but in 1937, he did, under Edward Arnold in "The Toast of New York." This is the purported story of financial schemer Jim Fisk (Arnold), who, in the 1800s, tried to corner the gold market, oversold stock to his railroad company, and fled to New Jersey, continuing to print convertible bonds where no one could get him. The film takes a lot of liberties with the truth but it leaves no doubt that Fisk was a real character, beautifully portrayed by the talented, energetic Arnold. Grant plays his co-conspirator who also loves Fisk's discovery, Josie Mansfield (Frances Farmer). Fisk is madly in love with her and wants to make her a big star.
I have to say the movie dragged for me, and I didn't find it particularly interesting. The point of interest in it today, I guess, would be the presence of Frances Farmer, whose fascinating story was made into "Frances" starring Jessica Lange (and wow, the resemblance is incredible). Farmer was very beautiful with a deep voice that didn't really match her looks. The fact that her life story made her better known than her film career ever could have shouldn't be confused with acting ability, which wasn't that great on film. She was probably much more effective on stage. She doesn't register much here -in fact, the only ones who do are Arnold and Donald Meek. Handsome Grant doesn't have much to do - seen today, that's disconcerting. Viewers are used to him being the whole show.
Overall, a disappointment, though Arnold was a strong actor who usually did supporting roles. This is a rare lead for him, and he's more than up to the task.
I have to say the movie dragged for me, and I didn't find it particularly interesting. The point of interest in it today, I guess, would be the presence of Frances Farmer, whose fascinating story was made into "Frances" starring Jessica Lange (and wow, the resemblance is incredible). Farmer was very beautiful with a deep voice that didn't really match her looks. The fact that her life story made her better known than her film career ever could have shouldn't be confused with acting ability, which wasn't that great on film. She was probably much more effective on stage. She doesn't register much here -in fact, the only ones who do are Arnold and Donald Meek. Handsome Grant doesn't have much to do - seen today, that's disconcerting. Viewers are used to him being the whole show.
Overall, a disappointment, though Arnold was a strong actor who usually did supporting roles. This is a rare lead for him, and he's more than up to the task.