I really want to like A Love Story, but I was just bothered by how the entire movie took its course. Film-making-wise it's above par, but I just don't feel sympathetic with the characters and the story. I must say that the animation movie Ratatouille has more emotional weight and character arc than the characters in this movie!
To begin, all the characters that we should care about here are rich and well-off. Now, how can most of the majority in the country, who has more low-mid income class than mid to upper class relate to them? I felt that it's alright that they should be beset with all the problems in the world just to balance out their privileged status in society.
Anyways, among the three leads, I find that the character of Angelica Panganiban is at least, the most believable one. She's the one who changed the most in the end. From a slutty party girl in the beginning, she evolved into a mature, often paranoid (which is expected as she was cheated upon), forgiving and wise mother in the end. That scene in the hospital where she begged Maricel to leave Aga is really good. And even though she was quiet in the next scene wherein Aga and Maricel (as the doctor) pretends that they don't know each other, she clearly stood out. Her quiet and subtle performance was the strongest among the three.
As for Aga, I don't really care for him. I would've been more satisfied if he ended up with nobody in the end. He's selfish. He has all the money and success in the world yet he takes that for granted. At his age, at 38, he hasn't grown up and still towards the end he's still the same. He's afraid of making choices and standing up with it.
In the movie, he even said, that he will leave his wife just to be with Maricel, now, what kind of a man is that? Then, later, when he learns that his wife is pregnant, he stays with her? If he truly LOVES Maricel, like what his character says, he should've made a choice and be with her. I know, people will react, well how about, the kid? Well, he made the choice of pursuing a relationship with Maricel in the beginning, so again, it's all about choices.
His monologue wherein he had a fight with his brother-in-law where he revealed all his angst is just so poorly developed. Again, i don't care with all the crap he said, he's rich, his family's rich, and nobody can have all the things in the world. If he had an unhappy childhood, well, that's fine, he's rich anyways, lol.
The subplot with Aga's father having Alzheimer's is under researched. His illness is Alzheimer's not amnesia for goodness sake!
As for Maricel, again, it's not believable in her character to be with Aga, who after, was left by her husband for another woman, is now the other woman. I know, people will say its LOVE, but, if Aga's character was YOUNGER, like that of Angelica's, it would at least make sense and we could use the argument that she was just attracted to him and she fell in love later on. But, they're almost the same age, and at her age, and after all the relationship mishaps she has experienced, would she be much WISER and EXPERIENCED now?
And what's with the random opening shots? Like, "5 YEARS LATER", we open up to a cheesecake? What's that? I don't see the connection? Film is a visual medium, and sadly, it wasn't used much in this movie. They could've staged the "accidental meeting" of Angelica and Maricel (which is a common thing in Pinoy movies) some other, more visually logical way.
I also find that the intended CONCEIT on who's the mistress or the wife thing in the beginning of the movie didn't work. C'mon! Again, we the audience, as the filmmakers wanted to, were supposed to believe that Maricel is the wife to shock us with the twist that she is in fact the mistress. But, they show scenes of her, being the IDEAL and LOVING wife that she should be to Aga, and the next scene, we see Aga and his family having a gathering, minus his "WIFE" and all he could reason out was she's busy? AGAIN, THIS IS NOT CONSISTENT WITH MARICEL'S CHARACTER AS EARLIER SHOWN. If they showed her as a loving and ideal wife, shouldn't she be in those gatherings despite her busy schedules? But of course, its a PLOY so that they can lead us on to believe that she's the wife, and later on be shocked that she's the mistress. This I believe back fired, because in their attempt to make it unpredictable, it ruined the twist in the end.
And i know I should not complain about the often and unnecessary musical score that's prevalent in pinoy movies, but thought I should just mention it.
To begin, all the characters that we should care about here are rich and well-off. Now, how can most of the majority in the country, who has more low-mid income class than mid to upper class relate to them? I felt that it's alright that they should be beset with all the problems in the world just to balance out their privileged status in society.
Anyways, among the three leads, I find that the character of Angelica Panganiban is at least, the most believable one. She's the one who changed the most in the end. From a slutty party girl in the beginning, she evolved into a mature, often paranoid (which is expected as she was cheated upon), forgiving and wise mother in the end. That scene in the hospital where she begged Maricel to leave Aga is really good. And even though she was quiet in the next scene wherein Aga and Maricel (as the doctor) pretends that they don't know each other, she clearly stood out. Her quiet and subtle performance was the strongest among the three.
As for Aga, I don't really care for him. I would've been more satisfied if he ended up with nobody in the end. He's selfish. He has all the money and success in the world yet he takes that for granted. At his age, at 38, he hasn't grown up and still towards the end he's still the same. He's afraid of making choices and standing up with it.
In the movie, he even said, that he will leave his wife just to be with Maricel, now, what kind of a man is that? Then, later, when he learns that his wife is pregnant, he stays with her? If he truly LOVES Maricel, like what his character says, he should've made a choice and be with her. I know, people will react, well how about, the kid? Well, he made the choice of pursuing a relationship with Maricel in the beginning, so again, it's all about choices.
His monologue wherein he had a fight with his brother-in-law where he revealed all his angst is just so poorly developed. Again, i don't care with all the crap he said, he's rich, his family's rich, and nobody can have all the things in the world. If he had an unhappy childhood, well, that's fine, he's rich anyways, lol.
The subplot with Aga's father having Alzheimer's is under researched. His illness is Alzheimer's not amnesia for goodness sake!
As for Maricel, again, it's not believable in her character to be with Aga, who after, was left by her husband for another woman, is now the other woman. I know, people will say its LOVE, but, if Aga's character was YOUNGER, like that of Angelica's, it would at least make sense and we could use the argument that she was just attracted to him and she fell in love later on. But, they're almost the same age, and at her age, and after all the relationship mishaps she has experienced, would she be much WISER and EXPERIENCED now?
And what's with the random opening shots? Like, "5 YEARS LATER", we open up to a cheesecake? What's that? I don't see the connection? Film is a visual medium, and sadly, it wasn't used much in this movie. They could've staged the "accidental meeting" of Angelica and Maricel (which is a common thing in Pinoy movies) some other, more visually logical way.
I also find that the intended CONCEIT on who's the mistress or the wife thing in the beginning of the movie didn't work. C'mon! Again, we the audience, as the filmmakers wanted to, were supposed to believe that Maricel is the wife to shock us with the twist that she is in fact the mistress. But, they show scenes of her, being the IDEAL and LOVING wife that she should be to Aga, and the next scene, we see Aga and his family having a gathering, minus his "WIFE" and all he could reason out was she's busy? AGAIN, THIS IS NOT CONSISTENT WITH MARICEL'S CHARACTER AS EARLIER SHOWN. If they showed her as a loving and ideal wife, shouldn't she be in those gatherings despite her busy schedules? But of course, its a PLOY so that they can lead us on to believe that she's the wife, and later on be shocked that she's the mistress. This I believe back fired, because in their attempt to make it unpredictable, it ruined the twist in the end.
And i know I should not complain about the often and unnecessary musical score that's prevalent in pinoy movies, but thought I should just mention it.