It would seem that the makers of this film had at least one premise of their film right, apparently this is not an issue someone is allowed to bring up for discussion. The only reason to give this movie the lowest rating possible would be a narrow-minded and intolerant pre-judgement of the film. Or a desire to keep anyone else from viewing the film. Certainly those people cannot be objective.
I personally found the film very enjoyable and much better than I expected after reading the reviews. I am a scientist (former chemistry teacher and current physician)so I think I am qualified to speak a little about the film. Yes it is pretty one sided, but I felt like it made its point in a funny and entertain-able way. I think it gave the scientists who spoke the freedom to say what they believe. If asked again, I doubt Richard Dawkins would contradict his statements in the film. One of the more awkward moments for Dawkins on film is when he insists on reading a quote from his own book, "The God Delusion".
I know from experience in the schools at all levels from grade school to medical school that there does seem to be a wall in this discussion that you are not allowed to breach. I have been there and seen the discussions take place. I challenge anyone else who has been involved in education and has a doctorate to tell me an example that shows otherwise.
You may not like the premise of this film. It is not a perfect film, but give it a chance. If you can be open minded, (most people can't)I think many people will enjoy the movie.
I personally found the film very enjoyable and much better than I expected after reading the reviews. I am a scientist (former chemistry teacher and current physician)so I think I am qualified to speak a little about the film. Yes it is pretty one sided, but I felt like it made its point in a funny and entertain-able way. I think it gave the scientists who spoke the freedom to say what they believe. If asked again, I doubt Richard Dawkins would contradict his statements in the film. One of the more awkward moments for Dawkins on film is when he insists on reading a quote from his own book, "The God Delusion".
I know from experience in the schools at all levels from grade school to medical school that there does seem to be a wall in this discussion that you are not allowed to breach. I have been there and seen the discussions take place. I challenge anyone else who has been involved in education and has a doctorate to tell me an example that shows otherwise.
You may not like the premise of this film. It is not a perfect film, but give it a chance. If you can be open minded, (most people can't)I think many people will enjoy the movie.