7/10
quite different, poignant ... yet lacking the thrills of the book
22 August 2009
I rated it a 7, but actually think it's a bit shy of that. I read the book years ago, long enough to forget a lot. But, I remember the book as having much more action-oriented scenes and drama. Thus, more of a balance of sentimental and exciting scenes. I found the movie started dragging about 2/3s of the way through, but picked up a lot at the end.

I was ~very~ impressed with the casting of the young Clair. Between, the two Claires, they managed to capture the same look and nuance of expression. I was also very impressed with the casting and performances of the younger and older Alba. The girls did a terrific job with their roles.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed