Before watching this film, I need to mention that the co-star of this film, Ginger Rogers, plays a woman named 'Miss Mantin'. This character is NOT to be confused with the character from "The Mad Miss Manton"--a detective film starring Jean Arthur and William Powell. And, to make it more confusing, "Star of Midnight" is ALSO a detective movie starring William Powell as a hard-drinking gentleman amateur crime-solver!!
William Powell plays a lawyer, 'Dal' Dalzell. A murder is committed in his apartment and he's shot (and only slightly injured) by the killer. When the cops come to investigate, one wants to arrest Powell (which makes no sense--and the cop is a stereotypical idiot cop you find in these sort of films). The other (J. Farrell MacDondald) is MUCH more pragmatic and does something I can't recall any other cop doing in a film--he lets Powell do all the investigating and just waits for Powell to uncover the killer!! This is a GREAT thing about the film, as is the nice repartee between Powell and Rogers. As a result, it's a fun and enjoyable film--in the same tradition as Powell's "Thin Man" movies. The only drawback concerns the crime itself. It seems like some things were missing and the heroes made a few logical jumps in reasoning--like the writer needed to hash out the story just a bit better. Still, it's enjoyable and worth a look.
William Powell plays a lawyer, 'Dal' Dalzell. A murder is committed in his apartment and he's shot (and only slightly injured) by the killer. When the cops come to investigate, one wants to arrest Powell (which makes no sense--and the cop is a stereotypical idiot cop you find in these sort of films). The other (J. Farrell MacDondald) is MUCH more pragmatic and does something I can't recall any other cop doing in a film--he lets Powell do all the investigating and just waits for Powell to uncover the killer!! This is a GREAT thing about the film, as is the nice repartee between Powell and Rogers. As a result, it's a fun and enjoyable film--in the same tradition as Powell's "Thin Man" movies. The only drawback concerns the crime itself. It seems like some things were missing and the heroes made a few logical jumps in reasoning--like the writer needed to hash out the story just a bit better. Still, it's enjoyable and worth a look.